Jump to content

whatwhat say what

Life Member

Everything posted by whatwhat say what

  1. that looked like an acl for lever - just a change of direction and his reaction was 'oh no, not again'
  2. good to see they're allowed to just drop the ball, push in the back...no penalty
  3. we're not well liked by the maggots, it's fair to say
  4. followed it up with a weak effort against chol
  5. whatwhat say what replied to Matsuo Basho's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    langdon arguably bog tonight
  6. ah, yes, wrong himmelberg although, in saying that, elliot is borderline best 22 for the crows there's no way that they're giving him up for stretch
  7. Er, no One is a best 22 for a top 8 side, the other can’t make the squad of 26 when there’s only 30 players to pick from
  8. God I love Robbie Gray
  9. whatwhat say what replied to Pates's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    petty gets knackered midway thru the third quarter currently, but he's hardly alone there hopefully he can continue to develop and be our aaron naughton next year pls
  10. more softening up in the little paper today that gc17 are going to get pick 1 and 2
  11. only thing i want to see is suns and carltank winning so that the former can't argue for a priority pick and the latter stay ahead of us on the ladder
  12. Free agent = win His disposal = average His contested ball use = atrocious
  13. it wouldn't be melbourne without at least 'frostball' moment i still can't fathom how we gave up a second round pick for him - he's a good ordinary player, but nothing more / less he's clearly in our best 22
  14. He’d clearly fit right in!
  15. whatwhat say what replied to Matsuo Basho's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    tell peter bell he's dreamin! the coin doesn't worry me, particularly, but pick 2 would be absurd, unless they were chucking their first rounder (circa pick 9) back, and even then i would want to know whether our prospective pick 2 has been bumped down to pick 3 and thus ruling us out of rowell / anderson thanks to gifts to gc17
  16. whatwhat say what replied to Matsuo Basho's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    possibly but if yr freo and another club is offering a contracted player $800k a year for, presumably, four or five years, then absolutely yr hand is out saying 'first round pick or no dice'
  17. from what i gather, footywire has the date of his expiring contract with gc17, rather than whatever deal he had with the demons there doesn't seem to be a consensus in terms of his contract length with us, but like you i thought we were simply honouring the terms of his previous deal; have not seen / cannot recall seeing anything regarding updated terms with kk
  18. whatwhat say what replied to Matsuo Basho's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    that fact that he's commanding $800k a year says he's immediately worth FAR more than a second rounder
  19. he was a rookie pick originally, wasn't he? i can't see him getting a look in at gw$
  20. whatwhat say what replied to Pates's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    Got Dec’d
  21. Kerr has a lot of upside I think Wont get a look in at Carlton and would probably only be a depth option with us as well, but his skill set is interesting as a kpp forward depth option
  22. Re the Adelaide blokes; Jenkins is 31 at the start of next season, is on big money for the next two seasons coming up, and plays best as third option Fogarty is thicc and thick; too small to play kpp and too slow for a role in midfield - Crows have tried him in all three areas of the ground at sanfl level and he simply doesn’t get involved in the play Greenwood is akin to Harmes - good player but not a world beater
  23. If he can get thru the first half of a wafl season in 2020 he MIGHT get a third crack via the mid season draft or at the end of the year
  24. richard's brother