H_T

If there is a reasonable offer (ie late first round or early 2nd round pick on offer) on the table, and the club trades him to another club, we will have picked up a pick for the national draft with alot of depth. Better to get something in return now (a yound draftee), rather in 3 years time when the club would take a bigger hit. Look to the future.

Not really. 12 goals from 10 games the highlight.

Sometimes a picture tells a thousand words....I don't suppose you have their stats from this game by any chance, to show the real proof??

And yet this defence - whilst mostly young and inexperienced - is considered the worst in the league and has more leaks than a human sieve. It needs repairing.

I would of said this too.... What is the answer Bobby?

It was a decent revival, wasn't it>

I'll make it easier. Not one Melbourne player will get double figures.

As has been stated before, White should go through to the PSD, we won't get a draft pick for him anyway.

Absolutely absurd. Settle down. When did Naita kill Warnock this year and jump all over him?

Adam Campbell's stats: - http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/players...m_Campbell.html

Adam Campbell: - http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/players...m_Campbell.html

Cheers Bazza good luck on the weekend, thanks again for your detailed reports. All the best for Chris Lamb for his future too.

You would think that would be so kramer. Carlton want him, He wants Carlton,.... but what does Fremantle want? Some would say it's not up to them...but as some have mentioned on other threads, "Nothing is a done deal, until it's done"

Is he????? I wouldn't of thought he'd be a worry to opposition sides. He doesn't hurt them enough. I Wouldn't say underated, IMO they don't rate him. <_< To me he is more of a link man when the ball is in the teams possession. He doesn't hurt opposition sides. They let him roam, he's not damaging to them.

Just a thought, it was 7 changes to the list wasn't it?...I think that is what Connolly said...7 or 8? My "Crystal Ball" side: - B: GRIMES MARTIN GARLAND HB: BUCKLEY RIVERS MORTON C: ZAHARKIS McLEAN BLEASE HF: DAVEY MILLER SYLVIA F: VICKERY WATTS MARIC Foll: R.WARNOCK JONES MOLONEY INT: WONAEAMIRRI, BATE, P.JOHNSON, A.THOMPSON Bit far fetched..........we can only dream!

Yes I tend to agree with that. Thompson has played just 28 games over 4 years, about half-a-dozen this year. The report on him in the Adam Thompson thread reads quite well. (Colin Wisbey's report). http://forums.demonland.com/index.php?showtopic=11682

And Podsiadly for Werribee got up and won the Liston with 16 votes!! http://www.aflvic.com.au/index.php?id=14&tx_ttnews[tt_news]=417&tx_ttnews[backPid]=4&cHash=fb5da9825f

I think you have jinxed them. However, I rate Rivers highly.....now if he could just get back on the park. Dunn however is right now very far away from the CHF position and also being pretty darn good. As they say in the classics....hindsight is a wonderful thing. My best 5: Ron Barassi, Robert Flower, Iva Warne-Smith, Garry Lyon, David Neitz.

Wheatley seems to do his best work in the back half of the ground with penetrating kicks out wide to the wings. Worth a try whilst Bailey keeps throwing the players around to suit........

Yes. Or even WS18 (as opposed to GC17)...

Is it a foregone conclusion? Will we pick up Jack Watts in the National Draft as it has been widely tipped? Or will it be Naitanui or Rich? Or will Melbourne somehow lure Warnock from Fremantle from the financial grip of Carlton (commonly referred to as VISY Blues in some circles)? If you had a wish list what would it be (ie like a list for Santa) come trade and draft time, what would it be? Here's my list: - TRADE: - Green & Pick 35 to Bulldogs for Pick 14 in return. Daniel Bell and pick 67 for Adam Thompson (Port Adelaide) DRAFT: - Picks 1, 14, 17, 19, 51 Pick up Watts, Zaharkis, Blease, Vickery (not necessarily in that order) and fluke quality with 51 somehow. PSD: - Robbie Warnock! GO DEES!!

Let them scrub Carlton out 45! The VISY Blues. Losing the name Carlton will not reduce its financial clout, at least while Pratt is there. I can see it now....... "Full time at the MCG and the final scores are: - Melbourne 19.11.125 def VISY Blues 5.10.40............."

I don't agree with 19. IMO pick 35.

Can I just have an enless supply of Tim Tams?........

Like that thread BB.... Here's the latest with Freo's David Mundy and Ryan Murphy....... http://www.afl.com.au/News/NEWSARTICLE/tab...px?newsId=67814