Redleg

Is he better than Gillies? Was he delisted? Do you think he is better than Nicholson? If he is and we are looking for a player like him, do you think he would go in the PSD or 1st pick in the Rookie draft, before we could get him in the rookie draft?

Doesn't even have to go that far. We will never hear a recruiter say " I wanted player X but we are thrilled with player Y".

I would delist Nicholson and rookie him and open up the 2nd PSD pick, which is now the first live one, with GWS having declared their pick. I would be shocked if there isn't a better player available out there, better than Nicholson.

404 Glenhuntly Road Elsternwick.Mrs. Redleg has me booked in for another committment at 8.45, but I would imagine we could exhaust our discussion on the MFC's 2013 drafting in 2 hours. Not to mention watching WJ scoff down his dim sims.

Bit left field here, but I wonder if with 3 established ruckmen next year and another just added, plus another I think on their list, would the Dockers see Hannath as surplus. If we still wanted him and if they don't, we could do a deal with the Dockers to delist him, on the basis we PSD or rookie him and take up his contract payment. Then again if we don't want him or they do, it's all over. Nicholson could be delisted and taken back as a rookie if we wanted to use our PSD pick, which I hope we do, if there is a better player available.

One thing we can be sure of in life, every year all AFL clubs are thrilled on draft night, with the boys they drafted.

Great post.

You can and well done.

6- days to the Rookie draft.

Will let you know soon.

I think some on here have taken Taylor's words in the wrong context. I don't think he is saying he is confident of getting one particular targetted player at each selection, but rather that he has a group of players in the mix for each selection and that he will get one of that group, at each pick. Therefore I don't think you can draw the conclusion that we are picking someone from left field for each selection or who is thought not to be in the mix for that particular selection.

So far there are four of us. Can make a booking, though I hardly think we will need one, closer to wednesday. How does 6.30 sound?

And away we go.

Having considered this issue for a while I am on the side of those who feel they were too young. To be a captain at such an early age you have to be nearly a superstar on the ground first and have no issues about your own game, so that you can help and rally others. When you are not playing well or injured and very young, the task IMO is too much, as it was in this case. I think both boys didn't play to their ability and Captaincy was one of the factors. That then affects the whole team.

Here I am and here is what you have all been waiting for..................................0. Congrats to all all contributors and readers of this informative thread on 300 pages and nearly 7500 posts and 164000 views.

And maybe another couple this year.

Wonder who will be the first poster to knock our pick and how long it will take after the selection is made?

Didn't say it was a mortal blow, just more of the same from a bloke who clearly doesn't like us.Hopefully we can turn it around and get some respect in the footy industry.

Well get cracking then.

Whoops!

That DH is Denham.

We are clearly not wishing to show our hand with our permission to train list. Last year we lost Hannath after he trained with us. Don't think we would devastated to lose Jetta.

You have my vote.

Have heard a whisper that Dogs are looking at Bontempelli. If they take him, Aish could slide to 6 and then it gets very interesting. If Lions then take the tall forward you could have Scharenberg, Freeman and Salem all there at 9.

Last year we had hannath train with us and then get pinched. This year we have only Jetta who the other clubs know and who we would not be shattered to lose to another club. I think we will be raiding a couple of other clubs training invitees.