Demon_JB

Just putting it out there, could you imagine Frawley in the forward line? Reminds me of David Neitz's situation, would have been one of the greats in the back line, but his calling at the time was kicking goals.

Not sure if you guys know about this, I found it hysterical when someone told me. Apparently when they first got trapped, some of the miners wives came to the spot and their mistresses showed up as well. Some of the wives found out who they were there for LOL such bad luck

Why not experiment with Danny Hughes again? I thought he did alright until he got injured?

Honestly, I would consider taking Cloak. Why? I don't understand why people get fixated on someones ability thinking its the be all and end all, and sport players are incapable of improving. All the people posting here right know who are saying "HE CANT KICK, HE IS A DUD BLA BLA", a couple of years ago if Lynden Dunn was playing for another team, and Melbourne were looking at recruiting him, you would be saying the exact same thing about Dunn like you are for Cloak. Now look at Dunn. exactly. We are missing that big bodied Key position forward line player to create a contest, bring the ball to ground and let our crumbing forwards finish it off. Cloak has proven he can hold his own, he can create a contest, take a great mark - Why not consider? Dunn has improved out of sight, obviously at the Melbourne FD we have shown him a thing or two, why can't we do the same with Cloak? At 23 years of age, don't tell me he does not have the years to improve. /endrant

I was thinking of actually getting in cursive writing across my left pec "My heart beats true" Not only you can say its for your footy team when your mates question it, but it could always mean anything in the world when the ladies ask

Melbourne were after Hale because he could create a contest deep in our forward 50, bring the ball to ground and let our small crumbing forwards to the goal snapping. i.e Petterd, Wonna, Jurrah, Bennell, etc We do not need another small forward /end

An amazing ability to win one out battles. Every time he is running back for the ball or chasing it up against one other opposition - I will back Joel all the way

Watch PJ have the preseason of his life, and an exploding 2011 season after all this.

We want Hale because he has the ability to play as a Forward. Putting Frasier deep in our forward line would be as worthless as banging your own sister. Will get you absolutely no where and it's just utterly pointless. /endrant

Melbourne obviously know something that we don't know. They are targeting him for specific reasons if we are going to trade those types of picks to lure him in. The interchange rules is an added incentive to get him, but Melbourne have drafted and traded exceptionally well over the few years. For everyone having a massive banter fest at the club, saying its a big bloody joke and how you are disgusted - should really stop posting if you have nothing to provide but a negative attitude. They know more than we do, if we are targeting him this hard - we obviously need someone of his personal attributes. Maybe Jamar has had a word to the department? He needs someone because he is getting tired of running around too much? Maybe he knows so many clubs would be interested in him if he does decide to move on so he doesn't have to do all the work? If Melbourne want Hale in our team, then going from previous history in our recruiting department, I give them all my faith this year as well.

Would be an alright pick up for Richmond actually, take the pressure off Jack Riewoldt that the opposing back line will drill to shut down hard core every game

Dont get rid of Bennell. It will be as bad as trading Tarrant for Medhurst. A magician in the making, just wait and see

If anyone says Alwyn Davey over Bennell your absolutely insane.

Why have Fevola when we have Jurrah /end

Jack is born and bred in Melbourne, I remember when I was younger and I ran into Todd Viney and got his autograph and he was holding Jack lol. Who would have thought that I was staring at a 4 year old who is probably going to become a superstar. He better make the right decision and know where his future is at

Just because we have a lot of skilled midfielders coming through (Scully, Trengove, Gysberts, Blease, Mckenzie) doesn't mean they will over take and knock out a player such as Brent Moloney from our best 22. We do have young talent that will get better, but going up against a strong bodied midfield with those players that wont gain the bulk needed by 2012 will just result in us getting dominated in the center. This was shown against Hawthorn, they absolutley killed us and ran rings around us. You need a tough body to get in and under and feed the handball out to our Scullies and our Trengoves. In my opinion Moloney does a better job of that than Nathan Jones or Colin Sylvia.

The time when Jack Riewoldt kicked one goal because Frawley is one of the best defenders in the league. game set match

24 yeah sorry, got my numbers mixed up

He has wracked up possessions after possessions, kicked critical goals and assisted many in his past games this year. Despite missing 6 games for the season, he has been a massive stand out. I believe he is one of our most important player running through the midfield, as his blitzing speed, strength, agility and passing have been phenomenal this year. David Schwarz on Sunday said he thinks Colin can win a Brownlow Medal. I believe with an uninterrupted season, being apart of an up and coming side like Melbourne whom are bound to be a competitive and top side in the years to come, he has shown the potential that he can At 26 years of age do we think he has the ability/time to do so? Thoughts?

Questioning me mate?

In: Trengove, Moloney, Tapscott Out: Bennell, Jurrah, Bail /end

It's hard to pull players out as everyone had a good game, but lets be realistic a 73 point thrashing everyone is bound to chip in and have a go. If it was a closer margin you would have found players easily to replace with. Playing Brisbane is a total new ball game, gloating on the fact everyone did well last match was and is a different story. Brisbane at the gabba are a tougher side, and we do need our best and most experienced players in. Holding onto the fact that every player would contribute as they did last Sunday isn't the best approach, personally I would look at what best team I can field on paper and go from there. I.e in: the likes of Moloney, Trengove And out: Maric, Bail. Maric and Bail did have a great game, their 2nd efforts were amazing and great contributors. But lets be realistic, the match this weekend will be a closer margin than last Sunday no doubt - and having two young players with not all that many games under their belt really wouldn't best be suited. You noticed them in a 73 point game, but come a 10-30 point ball game which I expect more I would rather my experienced players out there showing leadership.

No doubt we are a stronger, faster and our chemistry has strengthened. But then again it is an interstate match, I believe if we go out with the same attitude in the first quarter against the swans we could repeat what happened on Sunday.

Before anyone jumps down my throat, I know Frawley is an awesome defender and pushing for All Australian and this is purely hypothetical but I was just curious on peoples opinion on how we would actually go down forward? He has a big sized body, knows how to read the ball and his man - if we had a player like Frawley in our forward line I believe it would be quite damaging. Thoughts? P.S - GUYS I KNOW HE IS A BRILLIANT DEFENDER, THIS IS PURELY OUT OF CURIOSITY a.k.a L. Tapscott?

The draft is there to peak and trough AFL teams. I have gone to game after when we are playing locally, and watched the smashing and had to deal with the frustration over the years when Melbourne were at the bottom of the ladder. Sydney had their premiership win not all that long ago, supporters should stop being selfish and learn to deal with the fact their team lost to a better one on the day. And it annoys me to tears about this whole 'draft pick' situation. Yes, we got Tom Scully, Jack Trengove, Jack Watts - but we traded for Jack Grimes, and Jordan Gysberts. We won against Carlton and settled for Cale Morton, Jordan Mcscrub kicked that winning goal for Richmond. What more do they have to sook about? On the day, Trengove wasn't playing Scully contributed but wasn't a massive stand out and neither was Jack Watts our two top picks. ALSO, maybe Sydney should wake up and come to the realization really how good our drafting has been over the years. Not only for the priority picks, but the rookie and pre-season draft picks. Rookie Drafts: - Mark Jamar (2002) - Aaron Davey (2004) - Austin Wonaeamirri (2008) - Jordie McKenzie (2009) Pre-season draft picks: - Liam Jurrah (2009) - Joel Macdonald (2010) Not to mention late draft pick that are stand out players: - Colin Garland Pick No.46 overall (2006) - Ricky Petterd Pick No.30 overall (2006) - Jamie Bennell Pick No.35 overall (2008) In my opinion, Sydney are scraping the barrel for excuses and are realizing that our recruitment over the years are finally coming together which will definitely achieve victories like these over the coming years. /end rant