David-Demon

Nooo Noooo stay for McDonald, Verrall, Monitz- Wakefield and Hore. Heck you have delisted 30% OF OUR 2024 LIST.

Thankyou for your comments, as a supporter, I hate seeing all these other negative comments in this thread. Heck the man gave exceptional service at a time when it was needed back in 2014

Hmmm.. that's a possibility... I will take $1: to $1,000 against it happening. any takers?

Lot of work went into that summary. well said...... but surely T.Mc has one more year ? I would try to offload some others such as Spargo. Billings and McAdam. They are limited senior players as you say.

That's just a circular discussion that does not resolve either party. Look, the guy is not 21.. He has ten years of service, surely there is a life after playing in which he could spin this yarn in the not-too-distant future.

Sorry, the bigger picture prevails in my mind. He signed a new CLUB approved contract in 2023.. Are you telling me he never thought of his current reasoning about his views now.? I would sit down with him and his family and seek a deliverance whereby, at the end of his playing days, it is time to move to S.A. I thought a pregnancy lasted nine months.... Maybe I am wrong on that.....

I think the overall view here on this thread is that we need 100% loyalty at the club; having others resign is a step in the right direction, however, when there is one player rocking the boat, it is not a good sign. Maybe there are others that will see a way out - Tracca, Viney et el.

I've got a good idea... Let's recruit a guy by the name of J. Hogan playing for GWS. Does anyone know much about him - or his history?

BUT the medical team is handling our list well. When did we have a list with so few injuries? Gawny will play.. Name Injury Expected Return Max Gawn Ankle Test Lachie Hunter Calf 1 week Charlie Spargo Achilles Season Christian Petracca Spleen Indefinite

Yeah to Bowey - He stays.... I would have Sparrow sub and def Disco in the 22.. Just sayin.

My God, they ramble on so much BS. Think they are trying to get ratings up...

stick with Bowser. He is a needed player

The word is that Gawny is not feeling the effects of the chipped bone. Just hope caution is the word they use when considering him for this game.

Oh great, when does it come to fruition.? The year 2025 has to see changes in assistants at least.

Good try but def no BBB please. He is cooked.

You forgot to give a vote for - Meg Macdonald, she played an awesome game.

I would politely drop Petty (inj) and bring in Fullerton. I would give Sparrow one last chance... Poor guy is having a downer right now. BUT still adds value. Heck he had 15 possessions last week and an AF score of 79.

agree with most but thought you were tough on Fritsch. As for Woey he only played about 20 mins of the game.

Please No as much as I love BBB service he is cooked.. Jeffo over BBB please.

Of course and I apologise for not saying that. On another note: Billings must be devastated at being dropped against his old side considering he played every game till now this season.

Regrettably, BBB is in that twosome as well my friend.

Yes, I want to see more experience behind the wheel. Coaches need to do more and take accountability as well.

OUT: BBB should never get another game. Lever (concussion) Woey. IN: Tomlinson JVR Langdon Somehow or other Fullerton needs to be also blooded... dunno how but when I can't even give a 6.5.4.3 vote for that pathetic effort I am in a quandry.

My "expert" view is that Turner should be sub with Billings being dropped as well as Chandler as he is not fully fit. I would bring in Fullerton to support Max and rest in the forward pocket. I would also drop Woey (for now.. prefer him above Laurie actually.) for more experienced McAdam. Granted McAdam did not have a good game against Carlton but feel we need more speed and support through the centre and I believe that's Tracks best position - centre or on ball.. Take Tracca out of the centre and we drop in performance. I would bring in Tomlinson at HB and move JB to the forward flank or wing or move Windsor closer to goal. Just my view...

Well, Danger did not play so don't see how he could have given him a vote.. Ahhh sorry, you are correct... We are speaking about Scott ... that makes sense ( or no sense in his mind).