Youngwilliam

Jack Trengove... we really stunk up draft '09 with our first 2 picks.

I'll take the correction to my comment. How about we see how we do against Brisbane next round. I think we are still fragile and how we handle the Lions will tell us a lot more.

Good win, but we need to back it up. Hawthorn are in a different place to us. We need to beat a team in the 8 before we start thinking we are out of Hell. Its a good start and the game was enjoyable to watch.

How Melbourne would it be for us to Trade him to Collingwood and then Weids would go on and kick 6-8 against us every time. Nope, keep him until he is 28-29 and if he is no good by then trade him. If Weids kicks 18 this season, he stays. Let's get 80-100 games into him then see where he is before we call the executioner.

Where should we play the GF? Are We playing? Not Sydney. Adelaide or Perth before Sydney.

Game looks too fast for Kossi right now. He will develop if we don't ruin him first. 2 more games for Kossi and rate if he stays or gets a rest.

How funny would it be for their flight check-in. Sorry Mr Goodwin, there is no seat here for you in the system.

Pack your bags Goody, you're not going to Sydney.

Melbourne players are just plain dumb. I just think we don't have any football brains out there. These players need a smart coach at least and we are missing that too.

Collingwood won't get a look until they sort out their Lamumba drama. Wouldn't suprise me if Hawthorn got Charlie. Annoyingly they always find a way.

Lever was okay today. The live for Frost amuses me. Remember the Frostballs.

The song was very similar to how the NRL teams do it. Not having the captain there is not a good look and the second time they did it didn't have the same feel. I have seen players miss out on winning celebrations and as much as they say it didn't matter, it still leaves a bad taste in their mouth.

First game back, hope they can iron out the creases this week leading into Essendon. Carlton are probably kicking themselves they weren't switched on from the start. Goodwin showed us that when things go bad he can do nothing.

Ralph is going for shock. He has named decent players in each team and their supporters are going to say the same as us. Jon Ralph doesn't deserve this much conversation.

Are we going back to state leagues, the players will be amature and have to work a day job. They will play because they love the game and not because of how much they get paid.

I have a firm hatred for Geelong and Hawthorn. Something dodgy in the way Geelong always find diamond players. Maybe i am envious of their playing culture. I can't stand sitting amongst Hawks and Cats supporters at a game. I don't hate Collingwood as much as I used to but I cannot stand Eddie. But I would live him too if he was our President. Why are North supporters so arrogant? Essendon. The son only a mother (the AFL) could love. The AFL loves Essendon but just wishes they were better behaved. Still no hatred for Richmond after their recent success. I still remember their supporters spitting on their own players.

2 more years in the gym and he will be a monster of a player.

Melbourne had to win that and running the legs off Adelaide like they did in the last quarter will give them belief that Burgess knows his stuff.

I only saw Nathan Jones as Captain previosly. Not out of protest against Viney, just saw Viney as a kid and I think he was made captain too early. Max is a top bloke, I hope the players have made a good decision. If Max inspires the players to rally behind him, then so be it.

Yes, right you are Daisy. I had both grounds in my mind and I backed the wrong pony.

If Eddie likes it so much, he should take Collingwood to Port Melbourne. Port Melbourne also have something in common with Collingwood. Verticle stripes. Pies have invaded our territory and should go back to VFL Park. Pies can then do up VFL Park to AFL standard and they get their own ground to play and train on. If we ever got approval for Jolimont, Eddie would vomit.

Wasn't it 2006 Bomber Thompson faced the chopping block? I am pretty sure there were calls out for his head.

At least the Saints have a place to call home.

Fisherman's Bend was tossed around by the MCC to make it a sporting central. All their sports in 1 place. Not sure what happened in the end, I know the MCC Hockey division spent alot on the ground and facilities at Melbourne High School in the last 4 years so I can't see them moving out of there any time soon.

Fan knowing more about a players injury helps more how? I am starting to understand and prefer the NHL's direction on injuries. NHL clubs only specify Upper Body, Lower Body injuries and you don't have the expert doctors at home giving their 2 cents on how the injury should be treated and how long they should be out for. Also stops future teams targeting that players past injury to take him out of a game.