58er

Really probably your best mid forward and second best forward liable to kick goals and you would waste him on a wing!! That’s what I call stupid plus dumb plus match losing!! Now really give Trac something to complain about !!!

Same difference not fit enough too much goes wrong How could you be certain of selecting him for a GF on Thursday and he be crook sick injured or any other malaise that is around to keep him pout if playing? Seriously he should go round in a bubble. Get him to go in I am a celebrity get me out of here and do all the eating weird trials to acclimatise to real life. OR Survivor for toughening up his body and attitude. Over to you Ghostwriter what excuse have you got this time?

Not quite yet this season may be his time at last. You never know.

It’s been in the paper and is on our website ( where info on MFC is published ) for about a week now.

Don’t worry Greenwave I won’t read your posts either. Well said W 1947 also.

Playing Spargs in Round1 was one of the poorer match Committee decisions to match some of the Sub decisions of 2023. He was not match fit at best and not fully recovered from injury at worst. Self inflicted injury to match the Practice Match one of the year before of Joel Smith. Even now we don’t have any real timeline for Spargs and the longer he is out the nearer he is going to be struggling to recover and rescue his career. Brutal layman’s assessment but we have seen things like this in footy that are real and the slower they go the more predictable they become. Footy does not wait long for the player with prolonged injury. I hope not in this case. Charlie has been nothing but a team man since 2018 and hopefully can overcome this set back and once again play AFL

Rubbish he didn’t flinch once last year. I think he is of a wiry ( tuck but more bulked) variety. Let them try and tackle or catch him. Swans Gulden and Warner are not musclemen and they break lines and kick goals. It’s the speed and skill of which is the Duke’s no 1 wood. Get him in where the action is and to play a starring role in our redemption. ( Another little gem for you Dazzle hope it’s not too complicated for you to understand ).

No one you would have to admit is less a tank runner than Ed. Whether the close in and strength to get free options on occasions is realistic time will tell. I know who would get free and that’s Windsor that’s why I want him in the centre for bounces and scrimmages. Like Kossie he could extricate himself. Also run freely through the middle with licence to bounce the ball then deliver. ( Do you understand now why I want The Duke in the centre Dazzle? To say that you can’t understand my posts now makes me not value your comments and judgement. Very simple explanations I would have thought. ) My back points need addressing if you are a little bit not in the know.

Oh Grundy well it wasn’t the forward ruck that we required. He can play but maybe is just past his best. Looked fairly average on that one day in September against medium to poor quality IMO.

Who !’?!?

Interested we won’t be so proud of is by 2029 ( or when Trac and Clarry and JV have retired and we only have ONE flag to our record. Top 4 finishes might be a consolation prize but not really.

Really very minor in this realm. If it’s Pies or Lions might be worthy.

Where is this published? Not in the HS. Or have you made it up?

I ought to know I am rather on the Chinky side also!!

Check JVR after 18 mths !!! Might be interestingly close.

Sam Darcy says Hi

Just tweak his position to be a centreman and he will deliver the 15/20/25 goals and many passes to our forwards. And oh a BandF or two, plus a Brownlow and a Norm Smith or two!! Just by getting him front and centre in the middle of the ground and the play from each quarter start and alap after every goal kicked in the game. ( except when on the interchange fairly briefly). Easiest move for our better version of Chad Warner of the Swans.

Our haste in resigning Marty Hore was ridiculously breathtaking. More haste less speed ( ie less Hore) We didn’t need another HBF like Hore more likely a mid like Culley or Boy ( Roy) George as a HFF/mid.

Or suspended!!!

Now your talkin WDee.!!!

Jacko had a chunky man’s body from Dsy 1 so as a comparison was successful immediately. Not sure of his prior footy but bet it was against Men rather than under age. He had do m as my skills also you couldn’t teach. Looking at Jeffo it’s not his footy skills that are lacking it’s getting the ball to be able to use them. Mow that he has started maturing in physique and moving around the forward line he will through instinct ( still the best way forward can get the ball ) think Fritta Kossie Cyril all so great to watch. Its gong yo be very interesting our forward setup but one good thing is all our magnets on the board capable of playing in front of goals are so different that we should be able to mix and match very capably yo confuse the opposition.

What a curious comment. None of our forwards are Wayne Carey at this stage!!! But you are wrong in saying Jeffo won’t make any difference in our forward line bring great or not so good. But what he brings to the table are forward finishing skills that help our goal kicking and team play in ground pick ups and handballs to assist. He is a different cat to all our others except taller and slightly more physical than Fritta. Height and marking and straight goal kicking also are the package. Like Fritta 6/8 possessions with 2/3 goals and 2/3 assists will keep the opposing defences honest. Improvement from Disco JVR and Billing’s and the new boys Harvey and Lindsay are other pluses to our scoring potential. Trac is liking among this group waiting to score big time. No not great yet but by September who knows how good we might be.

Of the first four you have returning? I gave only one if those in my Round 1 tram TRAC. IMO Chin ( lucky if he makes it as his last season half was not good enough in goals and not featured greatly since Cmas at training and plant of others at HFF could maketh grade. For exp. AMW Lindsay Sharp Bowey Salem I’ll bet all those will kick more goals than Chin yes prob not as many tackles but hey goals win matches) Shane Mac again not enough training and only rough chance of say Sub and Fullerton has had no footy yet sO Must get further base at practice and at Casey. Trac of course has done running etc all summer long and only missed some contact sessions. A blessing really and no bother to this fitness freak who will hit the season running out of his skin. A mix of mostly tried and true with some 2025 standouts Billing’s Howes and Petty will probably make it. Jeffo is warming to be favoured over AJ but it could go either way. Pretty good mix is probably the go with pace and skill the big new and the two L’s Harvey and XL could well be making their debuts together. XL is not fully match fit so could also be the Sub.

Gator. your assertion that skinny kids can make it and that it is BS that others need time is not reflected in the performances of many KP players more forward than back in reality. To say Jeffo has run out of excuses is ridiculously unfair. Like children footballers and sportsman grow up and perform completely differently. Otherwise you would have all kids walking at say 1 year then debuting at 18 yrs 6 mths . Sport is not an exact science nor is life thank goodness. We’ll always be surprised with players and their distinctive development. You are just impatient like OD. All will be revealed in 2022 and ensuing seasons.

Than who Narkle or Hill? Ridiculous decision if either are available.