58er

Play players on merit and form and health ( fitness) Don't flirt with selection for selection sake!!

We don't need Tmac on the wing ! How many times have you suggested this mythical change in our structure? Isn't his form good enough ? Let the bloke do what he does best . The Mark McLure role in the forward line Marking kicking goals and making ways for and protecting our smalls. It's going well and honestly both Weid and BBB are not that same type of player to assist others. Just wanting to play certain players to fit them in is not team football. They must all gel and right now Melksham is probably the elephant in the room. Plus Angus is owning his wing with great support for the defenders and also a good feeder to the leads from Our forwards. We don't need to experiment and risk mucking up Tmac'a form and the Forward line and centre line synergy.

Not Jordon really on current form.

DD we are all liable to change our minds on this great game. Nearly every Melb player Is rewriting his CV this season. Thats why we are improving as a team and Club.

Absolutely right Cheesey !!!

Absolute rubbish. Tommy isn't a winger he is a key position player ie FF or CHF. And a beast and a competitor in the same mould that Mark McLure was in those great Carlton sides in 1979, 81 and 82: Makes Kossie ANB and Charlie play taller. Move him at your peril !! That doesn't mean BBB or Weid aren't good enough.

And it's just the start of a defence type dynasty with a couple of others on the way when we get the odd injury or suspension!

They have to make available SOME Away members tickets And it's generally a stand alone time for say 2 hours to get. We should (The Club) have the info on their MFC website earl that week. Why would it be any different under a Covid plan?

Disagree.

He finished last season with about 4/5 games where he impacted the fortunes of our team towards a win. Watch the GWS win in Round 17 and its the same as 2021 all out commitment and running for the team. Congratulations Christian.

Definitely nearer to Lovett than Whelan which prob makes Christian an A-to A+. As Brett was an A+ no doubt. At seasons end I believe he will be without doubt an A+ and may even have a medallion around his neck!

Gawny !!!! Still a babe in arms !!

You said you don't trust him yet In 1:1's. Don't back pedal because you obviously don't either watch properly or don't like Christian. Seriously he has gone from a B grader half way through last year having a small impact on our game plan to an A grader now who has added intercept marking longer kicking and more metres gained to his game. As for his 1 on 1's he is elite and no one player wins every one. Tomlinson has apparently lost only 1 individual battle since being placed in defence halfway through last season. Christian has also been elite this year look at the Coaches votes and other player awards for his votes etc from a graveyard ie Half back flank. Its like the improvement in Kossie recognise it and give credit where it's due AF.

Your opinion DrD not mine. Locky Could fiill the bill and Deakyn Smith is promising and are our best options and this week we may have needed one or both. I have to say it's hard to criticise our defence at all as even Nev was unlucky to be dropped but full of praise for Hibbo. Huge praise for Jake Tommo Riv Salo and Petty was good in 2nd half. If we can keep them to say 22/23 shots we are right in this contest.

No way would 5000 be able to attend this venue. The AFLW was allowed 1,200 approx and I would say 2,000 would be maximum. A one off Game and lucky if you get in I would say.

I reckon they switched us vs Crows from F to Air on Sat night with Dogs vs Saints from first announcement !! Ssints Are getting too much Free to Sir exposure for a poor performing team!

Ridiculous justification for this game Last years finalists vs a team with some rivalry history 2002/2010 ( A decade ago!!!)

What an ill informed comment OD The books are never full with Club membership. Get online and do the registering. Good luck.

No there is no game at Docklands that will get 40,000 or above Don't need alteration yet:

Tmac won't be dropped as long as his form is Up to scratch.

I agree also Dee 56 and Luc Hero. Tommy Mac is not suited to a wing nor is our team. He was placed there in 2018 to get a start on his mobility as I understood it. Now 3 years on he has trained a bit on the wing pre season and he runs along the wings any way BUT he is not a traditional winger in Any way shape or form. Tomlinson also did play there but he is and our team balance far better to use him as our 3rd tall defender. Either can play a cameo on the wing if necessary but why change it if it is not broke? So much so when some D/Lers offer changes or selections with Tmac on the wing I now just laugh and move on and disregard that post. We need Tmac forward and I think 2018 and 2021 are prime evidence that when he is on his game we are very hard to beat With him at CHF/FF clunking marks and converting goals. He is a big unit with endurance some pace reasonable flexibility and kicks well ( straight) and is actually a bloody good AFL footballer. Above all he is intelligent a team man and as fine as a young man in our Club who knows what the game is all about. Thats why I was so bullish about his come back this year and our chances if he returned to somewhere near 2018 form. Coincidentally Kossie ANB Spargs LJ Gawny and others have also improved and that's why we have scored all winning scores in the first 5 Rounds. We are still a work in progress but our full squad is nearly with us to give this season a serious shot at some glory in September.

Well done Tyla Eden and Karen for your individual honours. Great seasons. But really it is the evenness of the group that achieved so much this season. Couple of quality players a mid and perhaps CHF/CHB type and our best crumber who was injured In 2021 should have us right in the flag mix next year again. .

Salo is definitely under the radar. As a half back he is like an extra on baller really linking up the chain. But it's his courage and intercept marking that keep his engine and our team possession game going whether we are on top or under pressure. IMO he is really worth $600 for 4 years and AF who isn't convinced should start by watching the GWS win at the Gabba in Round 17 in 2020 to see the extra level his game has gone to. His 1:1 are good and he is having great IMPACT with his possessions and metres gained. A must signature and I wonder If he ever thinks of the name Kelly. My suspicion is never Which shows what an uncomplicated team player we are so lucky to have at the peak of his powers.

Sorry GV that is a surprising statement from you! That is the Club interview following his signature !!! You mostly don't either comment or have any info or refrain from controversial comments On the podcasts. Why would Clarry still be speaking with CFC ? Now ? Was he dragged kicking and screaming to sign? Is he Only going 2 years and has promised Carlton when he is FA he is theirs? Or do you mistrust his facts in the interview that much? Do you believe Sam McClure in his information about a Clarry being not happy and talking to Teague? I happen to believe it was badly handled by Footy Classified and if Caro had been on the panel the segment would have been much more complimentary to Clarry and MFC In getting his signature early! Sam wanted to only revisit his Original assertion about Clarry chatting to Teague and being unhappy after 2020! with his "never in doubt" comment, to back up his alleged information. Once negotiations started I have no doubt what Clarry has said. "Never in doubt" Yes the rumours were around he wasn't happy but I believe Adam Yze spoke to him early days and straightened him up. Your comments are even more damming and uncomplimentary to Clarry and MFC I believe. If course you are entitled to your opinion but my questions are very valid as a result of your comments!

Ring AFL membership but I don't think you can sit together as you both( I dont think ) can sit in each other's area unless the barcode is able to be included in your booking ( Also Check Membership at MFC) before ticket times are upon you.