Demons 32

Out: Robbo Jamar Bell Dunn In: Newton Meesen Valenti Maric That's what I want, won't happen. BTW, Warnock, my number one hate for years, deserves another game after a fine effort. People should personal bias aside, if they do well, actually give a [censored] etc, they deserve a go again. Give the keys to Newton, even if just for a week. Make him prove himself, no Neita and No Robbo for at least a week. We all hope great things, let's see. However I think we may see an Yze, Holland or Garland next week.

They said the same thing about Buddy. Do we really want to end up being the butt of all jokes of the team (richmond) that passed up Naitanui. I read an article saying he is going to be the biggest thing to ever hit the AFL. Bigger deal than Riewoldt was. Also heard from a mate in WA that Rich will be a superstar. But then he said there is a difference, would you rather Kerr or Franklin..... I was sold.

Interesting, thought they were going to just give it to Bruce but it seems the felt they need to show respect to the great jmac aswell. Probably the perfect decision considering both probably can't be sole captains. However it shows how weak our leadership is that we need to captains to fill the void of big Neita.

Sure does, I actually think he may not be ruckman in the AFL. If we were to get him I think he would be a chance for CHF. In future we have Meesen (don't write him off just cause he is injured) PJ, Martin, Spencer. All could be something. Best to possibly make this naturally talented freak play one of the positions we have never filled.

Hate to agree with Rhino but agreed. As I said, I think he might get a game, I really do think that. However he was not in my personal list of who should was he. I do not belive Adem Yze deserves a game at AFL right now.

After reading im thinking there is a really strong chance these two will get a game. Yze Garland Possible dropping Neitz (of course) and Moloney I would like to see these players in Meesen (for Jamar) Maric Miller Bate (for Bell So out: Jamar (drropped, Neitz (injured), Moloney (dropped), Bell (dropped) In: Meesen, Maric, Miller, Bate Sound good? great, do that thanks Dean.

In a heart beat.

Pretty certain the MCC gives MFC a one million dollar donation every year.

Won't happen but what I want is. In: Bate (he is good enough to just get a game), Miller (has played pretty well since up forward again), Martin (just try him or Meesen in ruck this week), Buckley (worth another go.) Out: Jamar (crap), Neitz (injured), Moloney (6 clangers and the free kicks), Bell ( what has happened to this guy)

Batram - is getting better Bell - over this guy Bruce - maligned but good Carroll - just play frawley Davey - starting to show Dunn - only good early Frawley - keep playing him Green - class we expect Jamar - Meesen, Martin, Grandma (better choices for 2nd ruck right now) Jones - fix your disposal McDonald - normal jmac output McLean - I was impressed Moloney - very upsetting game Morton - still so skinny Neitz - inured to early to really bag Rivers - pretty good game Robertson - a better contribution Sylvia - is definately worthy (of his spot) Wheatley - not his best Whelan - he tried hard White - better than Jamar Wonaeamirri - tackled, contested possesions

Wonaeamirri's 7 tackles and something like 10 contested posessions was good. Sylvia in backline was pretty good. Liked Green and Bruce (although that kick on the full :angry: ) Davey is getting better. Good to see Frawley. Robbo presented, still fell over to much, didn't look for his team mates and missed his shots on goal. Mclean played well. Dunn was good early leading up the ground. The way this game was shut down with no movement, could have used the ever debated Miller running up on the lead to open things up.

People bag out White but he has been a fantastic servant to our club. An All Australian, and one of the premier ruckman in the league for the past 6-8 years. We were so lucky to have him. We always took him for granted, imagine our team if we never had Joffa. While if Victoria had better rucking options than Hille White and Fraser he may not get a game. I am still very happy to see him recognised and congrats to him!! I just hope players like Robbo and Davey see that they probably could of snuck their way on to lists but blew by playing so badly. Barring Daveys Round 4 performance which was quite good.

I hate to say it cause I don't like CJ and I know they won't get dropped. But they are 2 very hyped players, who have seriously not delivered so far, Bartram gets a pass because he is just getting back. Id drop Bell for Frawley in a heart beat.

Personal bias shouldn't out way fact. He ain't as bad as Demonland say he is at all.

No one gave that line. Simply stated he was one of very very few who gave it a go. Look past bias of him please. Got to drop duds like Robbo, Bell and Jamar. Would be good news for the club. Great news to show that you can't be completely lazy and self centered player on the MFC (like Robbo) Bell needs a run at Sandy, he is lost out there and his ok form from last year shouldn't save him for now. Jamar is pathetic. Play Martin in ruck with White.

I was lost when you decided to drop Neitz or White and keep Robbo.

Guess your hoping someone retires in the next few weeks to get Valenti in. Id love that as well. Would love that side, get rid of Bell though, he is useless.

I want to just see a team that isn't what I have seen for to many years. Not going to happen but ever. But still. BP: Bartram Frawley Carrol HB: Petterd Rivers Bruce C: Morton Jones Green HF: Davey Meesen Bate FP: Newton Neitz Wonaeamirri R: P Johnson Mclean Sylvia INT: Buckley, Jmac, Martin, Maric EMG: Wheatley, Whelan, White Drop a lot of guys that you would say are right now best 22. One of few who like White still but want Johnson to play, and think we should play Martin or Meesen in the ruck too. Neitz in only because it's Neitz. Try Meesen or Martin at CHF, worth a try for a year we aint going to win a premiership in. If White must play, use White. Drop Russell "it takes two" or 3 goals in junk time to warrant selection Robertson. I want to play Wheatley, but can't stand to drop Macca. Bell isn't going to be what we all think he is. Very open to any other teams. Mine will most likely change considerably after hearing some views.

Plays just as stoned as Mitch was. R.I.P

There isn't really a need for Moloney. Then we would have Mcdonald, Mclean and Jones with him, not enough pace. I know I want those 3 before Moloney.

Don't give them stupid nicknames no one understands. Morton is Cale. Call Wonaeamirri cause its fun to say, write wona when on here. Don't get technical, the best nicknames are the easiest.

Im pretty certain Bailey isn't playing Petterd because he didn't warrant selection, lets face it he was a big let down in round 1, he had friends but he was pretty poor. He is still so young and will need a fair bit of time to be re-introduced to footy. Just give him time, I don't want him slammed back into the 22 anyway. Bate will either get a game for the Dees this week or will have one week at Sandy expect to see him this Saturday for Melbourne, or the Sunday after.

Cale Morton? He doesn't need some flashy nickname, just call him Cale. PJ? Is PJ, or hightower. Aussie? Wona, or just say Wonaeamirri, its way more fun to yell. Bartram? Barty

Who is this stretch guy? Never heard so much crap on Demonland, the most biased arguments, second only to YM's rants about Bruce (but his are funny, these are just dumb). Miller is not the most talented guy in the AFL but to think that we would drop him when he played quite well is ludacris. 1. Strong leading 2. Took steady marks 3. Actually kicked the ball 4. Used his strength fairly 5. Continually made a contest As if he doesn't deserve another game. He isn't going to be an All Australian but lets face it, who the hell is from our side? His position is a role, nothing more. He is asked to play as a lead up CHF, when it comes to his position and the structure of the team, he is perfect for the job. Before you rave on about a guy who obviously has great leadership qualities. Have a think about other people in that group, Robbo and Yze both shouldn't be in there. Your captain doesn't and shouldn't be the most talented player at the club, if that was the case we should have had T Johnstone as captain. The captaincy, leadership group should be given to people who work hard for the team, does his job and bleeds the club. Wake up.

Would love this side. Bell Carrol Whelan Bruce Rivers Bartram Morton Mcdonald Green Davey Miller Bate Robbo Neitz Wonaeamirri White Mclean Jones Johnson Dunn Sylvia (im forgetting someone??)