dazzledavey36

I honestly think thats the biggest cop out ever. Not a dig at you btw.

No, Not only is he out of form but he's rapidly declining in speed and his ball use has gone to absolute [censored]. His disposal average has dropped significantly from last year. He is like every other player that starts to hit that 30 year old mark. He has peaked and i cant see much improvement throughout this year.

Heading down the same path as what Bernie Vince last year. When is he out of contract?

Seems like Pruess is the likely inclusion for McDonald who is in serious doubt due to his ankle. Stretch was BOG for me and has been playing really well at Casey the past few weeks so he deserves to be rewarded. Id bring him in for ANB who is just a potato. But due to Goody's love affair for him i would not be surprised if its KK who makes his way out. He's done nothing and another who just looks completely underdone. Looks like Petty was taken off and rested for the 2nd half of yesterday's game. He could come in for Oscar. Frost wont get dropped as he will likely go to Franklin.

In regards to Petty being injured, this was written in the VFL article. A positive was the team came away unscathed from the match with no injuries. https://m.melbournefc.com.au/news/2019-04-07/vfl-tough-start-to-2019-for-casey

Agree that some certain poster have just carried on their usual dribble. For those that didnt watch I'll do a player by player assessment. Baker: Played like a bloke thats missed a fair chunk of the pre season. Rusty and was quite throughout the game. Did a really good chase and tackle right in front of Casey's bench and got good applause. Other then that he didn't do much. Needed the run. Bedford: Looked lively at times and certainly shows zip in and around the contests. He's next stage of development is hitting the score board. Felt like he got himself into good position at times but was ignored. Work rate was impressive. Something to work with. Chandler: The highlight for me. Chased, harrassed and hit the scoreboard. Has a very impressive left foot that didn't miss a target. Keeps this form up and he'll be playing in the seniors sooner then you think. Smith: Playing just his 2nd game since his injury, and looked good at times. Lead hard and tried to create a target but was double teamed at times. His work rate is exceptional. Another who needed the run. Jordan: Played half back and was fairly quite. Sparrow: Like Jordan he was another who was quite. Had 11 disposals for the game and just flashed in and out. His contested marking is very impressive for someone of his size. Keilty: A poor game. Played forward and ruck and had little to no influence. His best position is down back not forward. Stretch: BOG for me! Came onto the game in the 2nd qtr and immediately had a big impact. First time i have seen him use some genuine speed to break away from the stoppages. Was clean and really ran hard. I would bring him in for ANB and leave him in the 1s for a good block of 6 weeks and see what he has to offer. Has to be picked against Sydney. Maynard: Look, it was your typical inside midfielders game. He is someone who will get you your 20 plus disposal but has no hurt factor and will get exposed for lack of leg speed. Strong around the contests and played well. Petty: Played the first two qtrs then didn't see him after half time.. anyone know what happened?? Garlett: His stats say that he had a quite game, but it was his first game back since JLT Richmond. In saying that i must admit Garlett was one i thought who tried hard. Was harrassing and pressuring right until the final siren. It was not a good day for forwards but unfortunately there were a couple of times the footy just didn't bounce the right way to suit him where he would have gotten a goal from if the footy just bounced kindly to him. I honestly thought his work rate was right up there, but needed that run and i am backing him to play well next week.

Hahah wow........ ?‍♂️

Bedford did a lot of unrewarded running and tackle and pressured amongst stoppages and also up forward. Just because he didnt kick goals doesn't mean he was varely sighted.

Bedford named in the best.. But according to old mate werridee he was barely sighted. Think he needs a new job cutting oranges instead of randomly making team changes.

He's just taking the [censored] now..

What were they??

The big thing for me was the tackling numbers of both Chandler and Bedford. I think it will get to a stage where once the season is completely out of our reach, we will blood these two. Chandler especially was very very impressive with his smarts and composure with the footy. Bedford did a lot of unrewarded running and was ignored several times. But he showed zip and tackling pressure up field. Some promising signs from both.

Got in fresh young talent who are playing with such extreme enthusiasm.

Made his TAC debut today for Dandenong Stingrays and played as ruckman/forward. 11 disposals 1 mark 15 hitouts and 1 goal

He's a dead set muppet. I remember him wanting to get rid of Hogan at any cost throughout the year. Dont know why we act surprised though.

Some player stats. Billy stretch 20 disposals 7 tackles. Toby bedford 14 disposala 9 tackles. Kade Chandler 14 disposals 7 tackles 2 goals. Corey Maynard 27 disposals 17 tackles. Tom Sparrow 11 disposals 6 tackles James Jordan 10 disposals 2 tackles

Stretch must come in

Whats happened to Harry Petty? Haven't seen him since half time???

Hore is horrible

Chandler and Stretch only ones showing they are worth games next week.

Just the 3 disposals so far....

Jeez Jack Hutchins is useless

Good thread. I'm sorry to say but the Sparrow pick was a huge blunder for me. Absolutely gobsmacked we went for another inside contested mid when clearly our needs was for outside run and speed. I am sure he will become a good player but i just shake my head at why we thought he could compliment any further to our already growing contested mids. Marty Hore was another pick that confused me.. another medium half back flanker?? Really!? Had my concerns with that drafting period at the time and nothing has changed since.

Stretch has been killing it. Showing genuine speed. I'd bring him in for KK.

Mate they are not going to drop an AFL captain. Its never happened in AFL history and never will. Some of you are so thick not to realise that.