dazzledavey36

Pretty sure forwards coach is Rooke?

Can you post the link Dirts?

Agree. Easy to name your top 40. This is where Cal Twomey is very good at his job. Cal will predict where most players will go by talking to recruiters weekly and digest information he receives. Mat Burgan' s phantom draft back in the day was one of the best reads at the time before all the bidding and academy stuff was introduced.

Daniel Rioli at 2? Spare me Johnson.. I'd easily have the likes of Dunkley, Gresham and Hopper ahead of Rioli. Harry McKay is also stiff not to be on that list. Would easily have him ahead of Milera and Rioli. 204cm key forward who kicked 30 goals in 20 games this year. Can see him heading towards Tom Lynch territory in a few years time.

Out currently having a coffee with some of the under 16's Murray Bushrangers development coaches to start planning for our up coming pre season. Just got told that Demon recruiting officials are up in the North East Border and Golburn Valley region to interview a couple of bushies boys. Lachlan Ash will most likely one of them and along side Ben Kelly and Cam Wild.

From someone who's worked with the likes of Tim English who is becoming one of up and coming talented rucks in the game. So yes I will gladly take his opinion of these rando's who have watched a 2 minute highlights.

He's changed his ball drop. In 2017 he wasn't dropping it as high and was hitting them quite flush. Something has changed along the way.

This is from Mark Seaby who is his ruck coach. “I had the privilege of working with (Western Bulldog) Tim English as well. “Tim at the same stage was probably a bit more of an all-rounded footballer because he’d been playing for longer, but Luke’s probably got greater physical attributes than Tim at this stage. “He’s probably got the greatest potential that I’ve seen come through, in terms of where he’s at now and what he can achieve in the future. “He’s got similar traits to those ruckmen that act almost like an extra midfielder at stoppages. Peter Sumich who last year said that that Sydney Stack was the most talented WA kid in the draft also had huge wraps on him when I listen to him on the radio few weeks ago. I will trust the judgements of these guys that have worked and seen first hand how they operate rather couple of rando's on the internet.

For?

@Pennant St Dee

Well I must be the only one that actually don't mind trading pick 8 for 14 and 17? The beauty of this draft is that whoever is picked at 14 or 17 will be just as talented as 8. At 14 the likes of Robertson, Serong or even Kemp could all slide. The top 25 is quite a talented crop.

Was it? Those are some big words you are using for something that's incorrect. I have no issues with his training reports at all. As he has already said he doesn't go into depth like Kev does, but that's fine, some might like that better which is perfectly fine. I like Kevs because he does go into a bit more depth and will call it as he sees it. What I don't like is that when Kev does say that he will stop reporting training because you have one idiot who has a slight dig at him because he sees things different to him, then he needs to be called out on it. If @kev martin decides to stop reporting training on this board purely on the back of someone having a crack for looking at it in a different lenses then that'll be it for me. Not everyone has to see training in the same context as Saty you know... Again, I am not here to derail a training report. I am happy for all contributions that are done in training reports whether that's saty or kevs. Especially when I am based in Albury and can't get down at all.

I hope Tmac goes into coaching or a career in media. I could honestly listen to him all day.

Wow never seen someone get triggered quite easy over a comment that has has nothing to do with them. And I am sorry, but point out where anyone on this thread has been derogatory towards a player? Everyone is having a fair discussion without being nasty towards a player or poster. But yet AGAIN you try and make this all about you ya big sook. Some of us are allowed to enjoys who make fine contribution to training reports and are willing to engage in a mature and healthy discussion. Then there's you. Let's not derail this thread please.

Because they haven't seen him properly play. He's a right footer, but he also uses his left foot to get himself out of trouble around stoppage. He is a whole different breed of a ruckman. His upside is scary.

Yep agree 100%

Don't ever change what you do Kev, your reports are articulated and at a measured standard. I anticipate reading your reports at every training session.

Where are you basing his poor kicking at?

Brilliant as always Kevie!

Training gallery https://m.melbournefc.com.au/news/2019-11-15/training-gallery-november-15

@kev martin make it down mate?

Advertise as of 10:30am but out on the track at 9:05am? Seesh... you really do need to get there at 2:30am.

He was officially measured at draft camp at 199cm.

Which Jackson is exactly. So you're already wrong. You've already made a stupid statement not long ago questioning Harley Bennell mental state on the back of no evidence. I'll back our recruitment team any day over some random who clearly has no idea.

What a stupid and silly statement. While we have had some hits with the likes of Davey and Farmer, we've also had some big misses like Weetra, Wonaeamirri, Lawrence, Bennell, Johnstone etc. Bedford is still an unknown so far. Let's keep things in perspective first before we start making silly statements like you've just done.