dazzledavey36

In: Sharp, Lever Out: Spargo, Turner

He doesn't need too. I've done it for him No need to lie and make up things and now you look like a [censored] fool because you have been caught out doing so. You said it was done after the 2020 review and I provided evidence that clearly shows that it was never mentioned nor did it happened. So yes, you made it up. Im all for the criticism of Goodwin, but to lie and make things up to suit your narrative is pretty poor. I mean, im not surprised. Take a walk and have a breather mate.

Hey @KozzyCan here's the 2020 review findings. Can you find me the part where its states that Goodwin would be relegated to the bench as per what Macca says here? https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/833378/club-update-a-letter-from-gary-pert

I think McQualter was meant to be his replacement but that was obviously short luved. Even in his role as our midfield stoppage coach last year, he didn't exactly set the world on fire i. That area. Our mids fell apart last year.

I have done my homework. You made it up like you always do. He didn't get relgated champion. It was part of his personal choice as part of what I had already mentioned. He was back in the box at the start of the year and initially part of that plan for 2025 was to alternate in between but that fwll on its sword due to the early season losses. Its okay to L and move on.

Imagine leaving Byron Bay to play for a rabble. Stay where you are Joey and enjoy retirement.

Agree. But after Yze, hes still on the bench..

Where was he told this? Unless you can provide quotes, Goodwin has been on record to say that it was his personal choice to be on the bench as he gets to engage with the players and provide direct feedback and instruction on the spot.

Guess what SONS.. you're not going to enjoy what's coming our way this week. Yeah it may be repetitive, but once again, we have ourselves to blame. Because you mentioned Saints, we are pretty much wallowing those depths as we speak now. So yes, we deserve every single heat that comes our way in the media this week. Weakness, vulnerability.. whatever you call it, we are ripe for the picking.

I never once said it was the reason we lost today.

I never said Sharp was the right option nor should he play again this season. But your response that Spargo was the right sub choice because hes a defensive forward is a simply a poor choice. Hes a genuine slow plodder who added nothing when he came on. He either plays a full game or hes at Casey. There is no in between. I've been just as scathing on the mids post game. Im not letting anyone off at all. They were a shambles in the last quarter and for a couple of guys that have cabinet drawer stack full of individual awards, they sure did go to water when the pressure went up.

Take note @DeeSpencer A reminder that your sub should never ever be a slow defensive half forward plodder at all times. We butchered this big time.

This pretty much sums it up exactly how im feeling.

That would have hurt more i bet..

Didnt anyone else just feel no emotion when the siren sounded? Funny enough I just sat there for a good 5 minutes and just reflected on what actually just happened. Stunned, but yet not one bit surprised. It was just the Melbourne way to lose unfortunately. Then the influx of text messages and what's app group blew up from my mates just rubbing the extra salt in the wound.

Nailed it @Dr. Gonzo lol.. Kind of trash I'm talking about right here.

Defensive forward that is incredibly slow and a plodder. Oved that he came on fresh in the last quarter and immediatelyturned it straight over on the wing.

You that say about Jefferson but Petty was absolutely rubbish and has been for the best part of two year. How you can defend him on today effort by saying he played his role is laughable. Most funniest part was Liam [censored] Stocker out bodied him in a one on one contest up forward and then waltzing away whilst Petty lagged behind. He wasn't playing on their best defender in Wilkie, that was Melksham so he clearly didn't have a defined role. Was his role today to drop an easy mark right on our goal the line with 2 minutes to go?

One of the all time list blunders was not trading Harrison Petty for that first rounder Adelaide were offering. I dont think ive seen a worse player since Tom Gillies. And to make it sweeter, we dropped Jefferson for him. Let that sink in.

If anyone comes on here and tries to justify why Goodwin should because "oh but the players love him!" then you are every bit part of the problem. The club cannot sell any positive spin unless its to say that hes been given the flick. Until then, its all just trash and spin.

That was disgraceful. Our core senior players were atrocious. Petracca and Oliver can leave for all our care. Goodwin can pack his and their bags together and take a one way ticket to join the Bali Geckos football team and never return. Sunk to a whole new low. Worse then 2019.

That was disgraceful. Our core senior players were atrocious. Petracca a s Olive can leave for all our care. Goodwin apack his and their bags together and take a one way ticket to join the Bali Geckos football team. Sunk to a whole new low. Worse then 2019.