JackVineyForPresident

9/10. Career high disposals and would be seriously pushing All Australian. Is finally elite He'd be my number 1 at Melbourne. Probably top 20 in AFL at this stage

Fantastic news. 3 years under Roosy is already exciting me

I'd like to sign Kent up for more than 2, also Spencer

I am going to leave Frawley out of this one. But im abit concerned about Mcdonald and Dunn. Heard nothing about it. At what point do we get worried? Both are completely imperative to our team moving forward

Nic Nat is not a spud, and i cant believe people are saying that. But he definitely is abit disappointing, especially at the moment

I can't see Tom Mitchell leaving, he is very much a part of Sydney's future. Just developing

We'd have to pay way too much for him. I'm question marking that. That is not a culture that Roos will want to inspire

David Mckay sound ok for that role?

But we got Salem and Tyson. It was basically: Salem- Kelly Tyson- pick 20 Hunt- Pass now that combo, i'm happy. I cant even begin to tell you how silly your comment sounded to me

Swallow has been fine. Also having a GREAT year

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHHAAHAHAHAHAH Speechless at your comment

I would definitely not drop Riley. He was not subbed out due to poor performance. Like any other player coming off a serious injury he is being managed. Give him a fair go. I'd probably be looking at giving Salem a rest, but i wouldnt argue if he stayed in the team. In: Frawley, Michie out: Dawes, Salem Toumpas looked ok on the weekend, worked his way into it. I'd give him another game, but also wouldnt be surprised if he went back to the two's. If so, i'd bring Kent in

Even when you're wrong you still back yourself up with baseless evidence. Dawes we keen to get around him for an inspiring effort to keep up relentlass pressure. Dawes was also being a leader. Youre [censored] clueless

It was just a silly thing to do.. plain and simple. Whether the intentions were there or not, it was reckless. Cop the week and unleash him against the Pies

Surely All Australian this year?

all i want is steady improvement and he certainly is doing that

We have Kent, JKH and Bail. Bail is more of a mid though. We have 2 very young forwards though, i think we could be ok

All this means is that we are going to need Frawley, Gawn, Watts and Pedo to all have big ones, tackle and goal wise

I am as sad as anyone. But i think it is probably fair, very very reckless

For demons supporters, we have always questioned or raved that we need certain players in certain positions. I think finally, since Daniher days we have a really solid spine of players. I think we need another midfielder, key position forward and defender. Not sure about rucks either. Here is my spine. Defenders: Toumpas (can go fwd, not actually sure of a set position for him), Frawley, Garland, TMac, Clisby, Dunn, Strauss, Grimes (can go mid), Howe (can go fwd), Terlich, M Jones, Georgiou, Jetta Midfielders: Vince, Viney, Trengove, N Jones, Tyson, Mckenzie, Michie, Cross, Nicho, Riley, Hunt, Harmes Rucks: Gawn, Fitzpatrick, Jamar, Spencer, King Forwards: Kent, Hogan, JKH, Salem (can go mid), Watts (can go everywhere), Dawes, Pederson (can go back), Byrnes, Blease, Evans (can go mid), Barry, Tapscott, Bail I have named basically everyone to try and sort out players. (Sorry if i made a position mistake or two.) But i do think that the spine has improved, but i still see alot of gaps. There are a bunch in the forward line who are questionable (bolded) and highlight a certain gap in our team. I think that the midfield group has certainly improved, but we still need another good midfielder and a replacement for Cross, who has been great but is getting old. Our back line is actually solid, especially if Frawley stays, but we might still need back up.

no. I am saying when you have 2 players who are abit down on form, you dont just rage drop them, rather play them into form. Howe and Watts are also too important to drop, we have no one to replace them and their positions. I am glad Roos keeps faith in players

If we had dropped Howe and Watts like some of you keyboard warriors called for we would have no way won against Adelaide or Richmond

You know what i love, he kicked a ball out on the full, only a minute later to smother a kick off the boot. The kids got endeavour

Lets not get excited

Love him, always makes me laugh. Such a cheeky smile when Dom's ball bounced sideways yesterday for a goal