JackVineyForPresident

How can anyone say he hasnt been a failure. Colin has achieved at Freo so far: 0 Premiership season games Crappy NAB cup performance/s Got suspended when the team actually needed him Not exactly dominating the WAFL Was deemed to not be fit enough when he arrived and had to play catchup for a while He may come good, because he is extremely talented.. But at the moment, he has been a total flop

This thinking is pre-meditated. He put off contract talks, this is already the same situation as Scully, Sylvia and Rivers. It is not a fault that some people think like this, we are used to it.

I think that we'll probably have Hogan for atleast another re-sign. Surely he wont just walk out on us

That would be a bigger loss than Frawley. But in all honesty he's probably just working on the dollar side of things. Hell sign on, we need him to

He is a rare blend of skill, class, footy smarts and grunt. I think we have a real good one here

The whole of Frawley leaving is based on going to a club for success? Personally, i'd rather be at Melbourne than Stkilda.

Look i'd be hoping for finals next year and well take it from there

Honestly, this is just a poll to see what some of you guys think. No comments about this being an overused topic, all i want is a simplistic poll.

Dunnyboy has re-signed!!

Dunny is off the market! yewwwwwwwww

That is a good idea, but i just saw his article and wanted to vent my distaste

The Viney incident wouldnt even be my preferable example. The Hannenbery incident is the perfect example to be using, yet he has to use Viney.

I dont understand his vendetta against us

It's not really about matchups, it's more about pressure and getting numbers around and to the contest. The matchups will sort themselves out

Viney verdict a bad break for football Barrett back talking about the bump and the 'unfair' decisions following it. I have no doubt that he relishes using the Viney incident as at any opportunity he will negatively associate issues with Melbourne. I cannot stand this man.

He looks really good, but plenty of players have been just as comfortable or even more impressive at such early stages. Gysberts, Selwood, Viney, Wines.. just to name a few. I believe he is more creative then these players, which is a huge bonus. But yes, he does look comfortable

I think the reason why Tyson is performing so well is not only about the fact that he's unbelievably talented. Tyson has real support that he didnt have at GWS and funnily, we didnt have last year. N Jones, M Jones, Cross, Vince, Viney (he is so so so much better than last year) and possibly Grimes are giving eachother support that actually allows players to improve and thrive.

i had him at 5, lol. I was able to look past a few clangers. He instantly got in the votes for his tackle, steal and goal from 55/60 metres

Freeman in my opinion has a ridiculous amount of upside. I feel as if he plays like Dangerfield, being explosive and a tough player. I do agree though that Kolodjashni is a better prospect than Kelly. But Salem is majestic, he is like Yze, just all class

i think we actually need a goal square monster. Obviously he has to move around abit, but when you go long and deep into the forward line, some like Patton is useful. He is actually a real good chance at taking those marks.

I truly believe that Tyson will be elite by this time next year. He is going to be absolute freak and is getting better each match

Not to mention Trengove

Salem or Zach Merrett in my opinion. Both are deserving

I want Patton, he's an absolute unit, we need another Unit. Dawes, Hogan and Patton. Wowweee

what the [censored] is the "talent industry" hahahahaha. It is going to be nasty, for GWS. They missed out on Dom, this kid will be a star of the game