Coming up now..

Anything noteworthy?

16 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Coming up now..

Not sure we learnt anything did we? - except that we will not be trading the picks, up or down....

Nothing of note, though was quite firm on now trading picks and going in with 7&8. Very relaxed as always. Was probed about the same names we've been hearing and talked up Farrow and Nairn when asked. When they asked about midfield options he mentioned Robey and Cumming immediately before rolling into the other touted names, so think he rates them the most but feels they won't make it to us. Also said we've added to midfield the past few years but we've just lost champion midfielders also...

No idea who we take based on that interview.

Whilst we don't know who JT rates what seems clear is that no matter the combination ahead of us we are happy with what's left, hence no trading of picks. That gives me a lot of confidence.

Not very interesting in terms of our first 2 pick, which is unsurprising.

In saying that he did seem fairly confident Kalani would get through to the Rookie Draft, which could mean we have a couple of train on players (Sinnema included) vying for our last list spot over preseason. Something for the track watchers at least.

Intrigued to hear he said no trading up or down. Would've thought it made sense to talk that up as a live option in order to keep Essendon honest so they don't manipulate their picks, regardless of whether we were actually ever going to do it or not.

Still, there's a reason why he's very good at what he does so just have to back him in!

Edited November 17, 2025Nov 17 by Dee Boys

Interesting that he had no hesitation is saying Kentfield is player on our list already that fans should keep an eye on this year. Had big wraps for him

10 minutes ago, Dee Boys said:

Intrigued to hear he said no trading up or down. Would've thought it made sense to talk that up as a live option in order to keep Essendon honest so they don't manipulate their picks, regardless of whether we were actually ever going to do it or not.

Me too. He must be confident that no matter what happens above us, we'll get two he really likes.

21 minutes ago, Slartibartfast said:

Whilst we don't know who JT rates what seems clear is that no matter the combination ahead of us we are happy with what's left, hence no trading of picks. That gives me a lot of confidence.

When he said "no trading of picks" was he referencing our picks 7 & 8 or was he ruling out all trading of picks including a possible trade to an earlier pick further into the draft in order to select a player the club's interested in?

I'll post the audio/video when it becomes available shortly.

17 minutes ago, Blistering said:

When he said "no trading of picks" was he referencing our picks 7 & 8 or was he ruling out all trading of picks including a possible trade to an earlier pick further into the draft in order to select a player the club's interested in?

I haven't listened to it yet, so this is just my opinion, but it reads as though he's talking explicitly about 7 & 8 (I stand to be corrected). I'd imagine we're still looking to move another pick into the mid first-round, likely from next year.

Of course, that would also be an interesting move if we genuinely see ourselves in the hunt for Bailey.

Just now, BLWNBA said:

I haven't listened to it yet, so this is just my opinion, but it reads as though he's talking explicitly about 7 & 8 (I stand to be corrected). I'd imagine we're still looking to move another pick into the mid first-round, likely from next year.

Of course, that would also be an interesting move if we genuinely see ourselves in the hunt for Bailey.

Twomey said yesterday that Carlton hadn't received any offers which included a future first for their pix 9 & 11 🤯

I wonder if we are interested in Sharp after all or if there is another player we rate in the top 8 live picks.

JT clearly doesn’t see the need to play games with Essendon.

52 minutes ago, Colm said:

Interesting that he had no hesitation is saying Kentfield is player on our list already that fans should keep an eye on this year. Had big wraps for him

Watched him at training yesterday, and he covers the ground well for a big guy. He did impress me with his aerobic work and repeated efforts. Definitely will be playing in 2026.

18 minutes ago, adonski said:

Twomey said yesterday that Carlton hadn't received any offers which included a future first for their pix 9 & 11 🤯

That's strange, I would've thought that those picks would really hit the mark with the general vicinity of first round picks we'd want to target.

I could be wrong, but I thought I heard it mentioned somewhere last night that although nothing had agreed on, it was likely those pick selections would be formalised today?

24 minutes ago, BLWNBA said:

I haven't listened to it yet, so this is just my opinion, but it reads as though he's talking explicitly about 7 & 8 (I stand to be corrected). I'd imagine we're still looking to move another pick into the mid first-round, likely from next year.

Of course, that would also be an interesting move if we genuinely see ourselves in the hunt for Bailey.

I haven’t seen any link from anyone to us wanting to get another later first rounder?

Or do you mean shifting one of them back a bit to get another pick next year?

8 minutes ago, inanunda said:

Watched him at training yesterday, and he covers the ground well for a big guy. He did impress me with his aerobic work and repeated efforts. Definitely will be playing in 2026.

Jason Taylor take a [censored] bow

constantly picks up diamonds in the rough

2 minutes ago, Dee Boys said:

I haven’t seen any link from anyone to us wanting to get another later first rounder?

Or do you mean shifting one of them back a bit to get another pick next year?

The Gold Coast pick from next year has been on the table, along with Pick 37, in order to get back into this years first round.

Edited November 18, 2025Nov 18 by BLWNBA

21 minutes ago, BLWNBA said:

The Gold Coast pick from next year has been on the table, along with Pick 37, in order to get back into this years first round.

Oh right. Haven’t seen that anywhere in the media.

I wouldn't get too excited yet about Kentfield. He's a very good contested mark, but he hasn't shown he has the athletic requirements yet to cut it at AFL level.

He was also a very low production guy even in juniors.

Now, he may progress to become a star, but I'll certainly temper my expectations based on his output to date.

4 minutes ago, Dee Boys said:

Oh right. Haven’t seen that anywhere in the media.

I'd love to see a source for that because I don't think anyone has seen it.

I'm almost certain that, if that were true, we would already have an extra first round pick (plus some extra picks) in this draft. It would also shock me if that were the case.

2 minutes ago, Axis of Bob said:

I'd love to see a source for that because I don't think anyone has seen it.

I'm almost certain that, if that were true, we would already have an extra first round pick (plus some extra picks) in this draft. It would also shock me if that were the case.

Yep it doesn't seem to make any sense.

Norf are getting this year's pick 11 from Carlton with their pick 25 and a future 2nd.

GC's first rounder and this year's pick 37 would appear to be more valuable than that.

1 minute ago, Dee Boys said:

Yep it doesn't seem to make any sense.

Norf are getting this year's pick 11 from Carlton with their pick 25 and a future 2nd.

GC's first rounder and this year's pick 37 would appear to be more valuable than that.

Could the value of 37 be too low?

In a points sense for Carlton