Christian Petracca

[Guest]

3 minutes ago, KozzyCan said:

Not many of your posts.

Thank you… you answered the question way more efficiently than a ‘Yes’ or ‘No’ would’ve done 🤣

Hashtag 🤡 

[ChaserJ 5,011]

19 minutes ago, GCDee said:

I think the only Melbourne team in contention that could obtain the currency for Trac is the dogs. 
 

 Naughton would absolutely be of interest to us and potentially surplus to their needs. They will also have decent compensation coming back for losing Smith. 
 

Trac and bont in the same midfield would be scary good too.

I was thinking the Hawks are one that could find a pathway to a trade, but would require some of their young talent to come back the other way.

They have the cap space and the ambition.

[adonski 11,840]

1 minute ago, ChaserJ said:

I was thinking the Hawks are one that could find a pathway to a trade, but would require some of their young talent to come back the other way.

They have the cap space and the ambition.

Won't have a first rounder after they grab Barass

[titan_uranus 24,977]

7 minutes ago, BoBo said:

So wait hang on, either Morris had worded this poorly, or if it’s accurate this is absurd:

- Players were frustrated that Tracc went to Noosa and wasn’t at the club.

- They didn’t know the full reasons why he went to Noosa.

- And when it was explained to them, they then understood.

Tracc was in ICU 2 months ago and could have died… he’s been in Noosa for what, a month? A few weeks?

So a few weeks after ALMOST DYING, he goes to Noosa… and other players are frustrated and can’t understand why he wasn’t at the club?

They couldn’t figure out any reasons why Tracc wasn’t coming to work after what happened 2 months ago?

What?

Yeah there’s something not right here. 

IMO clearly communication between Trac, club and players has broken down. That doesn’t just happen out of nowhere though and so there must I think have been a deterioration of his relationship with the club and his teammates prior. 

It also explains his social media silence. He doesn’t know what to say, and/or knows he can’t currently say anything, because he doesn’t know what his formal position is. Right now he’s thinking about the possibility that if he picks the right destination, the club will agree to trade him. If he thinks he can make it work, he will come out and say he wants a fresh start. If he doesn’t think he can make it work, he will eventually say something like that he’s had a tough year, emotions got the better of him, needed to take time away from the game and club to focus and reset but will come back to pre-season focused and committed etc. 

[Jibroni 4,987]

27 minutes ago, adonski said:

Essendon could get it done I reckon. They have their 2024/5 first rounders and a surplus of mids

Are they big enough a club or does the Marvel stadium home ground bring them down a notch?

Saints will have two 1sts depending where Battle ends up which would be ironic.

[Ted Lasso 19,317]

It's pretty clear Tom Morris has a direct line to Tracs management and is getting one side of the story. 

it seems much more likely the only frustrations Trac and his team care about are those relating to him going to Noosa, but i guarantee the players would be filthy that the club has been thrown into the fire by the media getting hold of this information. 

I can't see any way a trade even gets close to done, one because why would we? and two because of the very few teams he might actually want to go to, none of them could afford him, and or get close to satisfying us in a trade. 

I think it would be in everyones best interersts from Trac, his management, the club, and the players to get used to the idea of Trac being at Melbourne long term, get your arms around him and welcome him back and work together to get the MFC back to grand final day in 2025. 

[Guest]

4 minutes ago, titan_uranus said:

Yeah there’s something not right here. 

IMO clearly communication between Trac, club and players has broken down. That doesn’t just happen out of nowhere though and so there must I think have been a deterioration of his relationship with the club and his teammates prior. 

It also explains his social media silence. He doesn’t know what to say, and/or knows he can’t currently say anything, because he doesn’t know what his formal position is. Right now he’s thinking about the possibility that if he picks the right destination, the club will agree to trade him. If he thinks he can make it work, he will come out and say he wants a fresh start. If he doesn’t think he can make it work, he will eventually say something like that he’s had a tough year, emotions got the better of him, needed to take time away from the game and club to focus and reset but will come back to pre-season focused and committed etc. 

And judging by how quickly and easily some folks on here are to believe anything he says, the above will work a treat for him. 

[Gawndy the Great 9,011]

1 hour ago, Jaded No More said:

So basically, our poor communication has led to everyone spitting the dummy, Trac and teammates.
Whoever is responsible for that needs to have their head on the chopping block. How could you let [censored] fester to the point where it explodes and you have a player of Trac’s quality wanting out?
 

But as the panel says, the likelihood that any team has anything even remotely worthy to give us in a trade for Trac, especially a team he wants to play for, are close to 0. 
 

Looks like a long summer of building bridges and mending broken egos. 

Jaded, communication can be poor, the club may have stuffed up his treatment post injury, but you kiss and make up. if there is a will there is a way. I don’t think that one incident has taken him from happy and settled to I want to leave to another club. Perhaps as others have said it’s been brewing for quite some time.

Trac has completely surprised me with his take on this - I just didn’t see it coming and tbh I think this is going to reflect poorly on him in the long run whether he stays or goes.

There is no way he goes to a Victorian Powerhouse. It just won’t happen. Neither the Pies, Blues or Bombers have what it takes. Hawks and Cats are neither here and are 2nd rung clubs in VIC with us anyway. 
 

 

[Jaded No More 68,867]

7 minutes ago, WalkingCivilWar said:

And judging by how quickly and easily some folks on here are to believe anything he says, the above will work a treat for him. 

To be fair I think we should acknowledge the trauma he went thru. Thinking you’re going to die, having surgery without anesthesia, being in isolation, having complications and then also needing to have your appendix removed, is incredibly traumatic. And like Gus and Clarry, Trac has a lot of his identify tied up in football, so to have it taken away for such a long period of time would be very difficult.  

I hate the way he/his team have gone about this, but I also think that being alone with your thoughts is a dangerous thing sometimes. Feeling scared, weak, and vulnerable would heighten emotions, especially for someone already so emotional. And just as he might blow up quickly, he might also calm down quickly. I’m of middle eastern descent, I know a thing or two about being a hot head. Italians are the same.

I think in time he will regret his handling of this situation, just as I’m sure the club has regrets of their own. There are definitely two sides to this and both would have valid arguments. 

In the end there are no winners if Trac insists on leaving. We all want to see our club succeeds and there’s no doubt Trac playing good footy for the MFC makes that more of a possibility.

Edited August 18 by Jaded No More

[praha 11,236]

This is all very bizarre. There must be more to it. And tbh it's leaning towards not looking good for Petracca. Maybe it's just me but it seems like his management is using this whole thing to help drive and justify a trade request. 

If I were Petracca's publicist right now I'd be strongly encouraging him to come out and either make a commitment to the club or make a trade request. 

Allowing Tom Morris to control the narrative here is doing huge damage to his brand.

[cookieboc 776]

1 hour ago, adonski said:

 

makes no sense, does the club inform all of the players about their personal stuff? Does CP not talk to ANY other players at the MFC? 

anyway, he is clearly annoyed with something, leaking through management doesn't help his cause, I wouldn't think

[Gawndy the Great 9,011]

22 minutes ago, ChaserJ said:

I was thinking the Hawks are one that could find a pathway to a trade, but would require some of their young talent to come back the other way.

They have the cap space and the ambition.

But do you consider them a powerhouse club? Will they be flag ready in 3-4 years? 

[Guest]

2 minutes ago, Jaded No More said:

To be fair I think we should acknowledge the trauma he went thru. Thinking you’re going to die, having surgery without anesthesia, being in isolation, having complications and then also needing to have your appendix removed, is incredibly traumatic. And like Gus and Clarry, Trac has a lot of his identify tied up in football, so to have it taken away for such a long period of time would be very difficult.  

I hate the way he/his team have gone about this, but I also think that being alone with your thoughts is a dangerous thing sometimes. Feeling scared, weak, and vulnerable would heighten emotions, especially for someone already so emotional. And just as he might blow up quickly, he might also calm down quickly. I’m of middle eastern descent, I know a thing or two about being a hot head. Italians are the same.

I think in time he will regret his handling of this situation, just as I’m sure the club has regrets of their own. There are definitely two sides to this and both would have valid arguments. 
 

True. I guess what’s upsetting many people is his silence on the whole thing. I know that’s his right but he must also understand that his silence isn’t helping the cause. 

[NO MERGER 20]

Trac hasn’t been the same since the KB incident - with good reason.. his frustration and emotions clear on AFL360 when he broke down. Is he annoyed with the Melbourne medicos for not getting him off the ground sooner? Are his parents and partner dirty on the club for what happened? Wonder whether we would be having this conversation if Trac wasn’t injured and the club continued their average performances? 
 

Trac timed his “coffee” date with Lachie Neale perfectly too. The silence from Trac has been deafening and only he can put this all to rest now. Pert, Roffey and Goodwin can’t be trusted. 

[Guest]

5 minutes ago, praha said:

This is all very bizarre. There must be more to it. And tbh it's leaning towards not looking good for Petracca. Maybe it's just me but it seems like his management is using this whole thing to help drive and justify a trade request. 

If I were Petracca's publicist right now I'd be strongly encouraging him to come out and either make a commitment to the club or make a trade request. 

Allowing Tom Morris to control the narrative here is doing huge damage to his brand.

⬆️ 👏 

[JJJ 1,220]

It’s really incredible. As I mentioned months ago, players weren’t happy with some of the going ons at the club. Senior players. 

It’s not like Bailey Laurie and Jefferson were on hunger strike until selected or anything like that. We had multiple senior players who drove us to a Premiership wanting change. 

How we have not reassured them that they were heard and kept them in a good headspace is mind numbingly stupid.

Also, the leaks could be from the management group, but Connor’s and his bunch of handbags don’t usually do this. It’s weird. 

Last point, StKilda didn’t like Petracca’s attitude and maturity prior to his draft year. Maybe they were right 10 years later?!?

Thats a joke by the way.

[H_T 3,043]

3 hours ago, Jaded No More said:

Look who liked Gawn’s post of his re-signing  

Paging @H_T

Thank-you! I read titans post earlier, very pleasing thank-you for the page lol. 
Now I’ll need to get over Tom’s big call tonight which had Lethal stunned. 

[Flowergirl 539]

Tom Morris seems only too delighted to report on this stuff too. I know he's a journalist, but it does seems like he has a special vendetta against the club. I think it's pretty significant that he's the one they are leaking to, considering his history with the club. 

[Jaded No More 68,867]

Just now, WalkingCivilWar said:

True. I guess what’s upsetting many people is his silence on the whole thing. I know that’s his right but he must also understand that his silence isn’t helping the cause. 

I’m in the same boat as you. I dislike the way he’s disengaged and letting Morris that weasel drive the story. It’s definitely not worthy of a leader of a club. You don’t spit the dummy in public like that. It’s very unnecessary and unprofessional and has rightly upset a lot of people. 

I note that today he liked Gawn’s shared post with the club about his contract extension, which is nice to see. Perhaps he needs to cool down before he says anything because he knows he can’t hide his emotions. He’s a good public speaker, but he doesn’t know how to fake it IMO. He wears his heart on his sleeve. 
He might also be holding out hope of a trade, so can’t say anything for fear it’ll come back to bite him. 

Either way, this unnecessary circus is not good for anyone, but after this weekend I think it’s looking worse for Trac’s brand than ours. 

[Flowergirl 539]

3 minutes ago, JJJ said:

It’s really incredible. As I mentioned months ago, players weren’t happy with some of the going ons at the club. Senior players. 

It’s not like Bailey Laurie and Jefferson were on hunger strike until selected or anything like that. We had multiple senior players who drove us to a Premiership wanting change. 

How we have not reassured them that they were heard and kept them in a good headspace is mind numbingly stupid.

Also, the leaks could be from the management group, but Connor’s and his bunch of handbags don’t usually do this. It’s weird. 

Last point, StKilda didn’t like Petracca’s attitude and maturity prior to his draft year. Maybe they were right 10 years later?!?

Thats a joke by the way.

Leaders that include Petracca, ANB and Viney or just Petracca? 

[Ted Lasso 19,317]

1 minute ago, Jaded No More said:

I’m in the same boat as you. I dislike the way he’s disengaged and letting Morris that weasel drive the story. It’s definitely not worthy of a leader of a club. You don’t spit the dummy in public like that. It’s very unnecessary and unprofessional and has rightly upset a lot of people. 

I note that today he liked Gawn’s shared post with the club about his contract extension, which is nice to see. Perhaps he needs to cool down before he says anything because he knows he can’t hide his emotions. He’s a good public speaker, but he doesn’t know how to fake it IMO. He wears his heart on his sleeve. 
He might also be holding out hope of a trade, so can’t say anything for fear it’ll come back to bite him. 

Either way, this unnecessary circus is not good for anyone, but after this weekend I think it’s looking worse for Trac’s brand than ours. 

Where are his management in all of this? Are they actually on board with a strategy that serves to only damage relations with the club he's almost certainly going to have to return to in 2025? 

 

[Jaded No More 68,867]

1 minute ago, Flowergirl said:

Leaders that include Petracca, ANB and Viney or just Petracca? 

ANB asking for a trade has NOTHING to do with anything of this nature. Like absolutely nothing. Just FYI. 

[Guest]

5 minutes ago, melbournefc said:

Trac hasn’t been the same since the KB incident - with good reason.. his frustration and emotions clear on AFL360 when he broke down. Is he annoyed with the Melbourne medicos for not getting him off the ground sooner? Are his parents and partner dirty on the club for what happened? Wonder whether we would be having this conversation if Trac wasn’t injured and the club continued their average performances? 
 

Trac timed his “coffee” date with Lachie Neale perfectly too. The silence from Trac has been deafening and only he can put this all to rest now. Pert, Roffey and Goodwin can’t be trusted. 

Your first post in over 10 years and it’s a doozy. Don’t know what the last sentence has to do with any of this, but maybe that’s just me.

I’m surprised the mods allow you to post under that username. Again, maybe that’s just me.

🤷‍♀️

[Demonland 71,626]

 

[Nascent 9,111]

7 minutes ago, JJJ said:

It’s really incredible. As I mentioned months ago, players weren’t happy with some of the going ons at the club. Senior players. 

It’s not like Bailey Laurie and Jefferson were on hunger strike until selected or anything like that. We had multiple senior players who drove us to a Premiership wanting change. 

How we have not reassured them that they were heard and kept them in a good headspace is mind numbingly stupid.

Also, the leaks could be from the management group, but Connor’s and his bunch of handbags don’t usually do this. It’s weird. 

Last point, StKilda didn’t like Petracca’s attitude and maturity prior to his draft year. Maybe they were right 10 years later?!?

Thats a joke by the way.

You mention multiple players, may I ask if that's still the case or has it whittled down to just petracca now?

Edited August 18 by Nascent