1 minute ago, Billy said:

Salem was non existent today & Bowey not much better, we need Hibberd imo, proven big game performer & our best lock down defender.

 

Salem had a hard tag on and Bowey played well, not sure what game you were watching.

26 minutes ago, Floody100 said:

At the end of the day you really only want to make a change if you have too when you’re consistently winning & especially leading into finals.

Tell Tommo that.........

Words can’t describe just how pumped I am for this game. 

Last time we played Collingwood in a final was 1989 at Waverley and we got the W.

3 minutes ago, OhMyDees said:

Words can’t describe just how pumped I am for this game. 

Last time we played Collingwood in a final was 1989 at Waverley and we got the W.

We also rolled them in the 88SF, a fantastic day at the G with a bumper crowd, some pre-game fisticuffs and the classic September Colliwobbles.

I can't wait to play them again, I want to see Viney and Sparrow bulldozing them and knock them off their perch.

9 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Salem had a hard tag on and Bowey played well, not sure what game you were watching.

Sorry I’m not trying to pick a fight, but you can’t be serious about Salem having a heavy tag, who & for what reason would he be tagged for, to stop those dinky little kicks 

l also thought Bowey was a bit loose today 

 

 

26 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

They'll give the job to McVee and he'll do a fine job imo.

We could play both him and McVee. Not suggesting we drop McVee but we might want to go smaller against the Pies. 

24 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

This.

In fairness, Gawn hasn't done much over the last two weeks since the Carlton game, being the sole ruckman..

20 minutes ago, Billy said:

Salem was non existent today & Bowey not much better, we need Hibberd imo, proven big game performer & our best lock down defender.

 

Salem has been non-existent for the last few months unfortunately. What's up with him?

1 minute ago, Jaded No More said:

We could play both him and McVee. Not suggesting we drop McVee but we might want to go smaller against the Pies. 

But who you are you dropping from our current defensive 6 for Hibbo?

It can't be a tall because this is a set up that Goody has decided against since half way through the year which no coincidence that we got a run on with our wins since we started with the 3rd tall defender.

Our defensive system is top 3 in most key defensive stats, its right up there in premiership credentials.

If Goody likes a system that is working for us he'll rarely change it up or risk putting it out completely out of wack.

The only reason Hibbo plays is if we lose Rivers, Salem or Bowey to injury.

In Jordon, Grundy, Hibberd & Tmac

out Hunter, Melksham, Turner & Laurie

 

3 minutes ago, Billy said:

In Jordon, Grundy, Hibberd & Tmac

out Hunter, Melksham, Turner & Laurie

 

Oh god not this again. Hunter's fine. He's one of the last players they'd drop.

Edited August 27, 20232 yr by Hopeful Demon

5 minutes ago, Glorious Day said:

In fairness, Gawn hasn't done much over the last two weeks since the Carlton game, being the sole ruckman..

That's fine, he's still playing his role. That's all he needs to do.

Goody has already admitted that Grundy experiment hasn't worked as what they thought it be, but again, that's fine. He'll only play if Gawn has to miss.

29 minutes ago, Billy said:

In Jordon, Grundy, Hibberd & Tmac

out Hunter, Melksham, Turner & Laurie

 

Internal monologue “I [censored] hate that Hunter [censorino] rah rah and I have I have long running argument with my more successful brother in law about the Grundy trade so I gotta smash him in there, and also Hibbo for that one player I forget his name, and TMac because Grundy’s not going to take a mark soigottagethiminthere…rah”

Edited August 27, 20232 yr by rpfc

4 minutes ago, Hopeful Demon said:

Oh god not this again. Hunter's fine. He's one of the last players they'd drop.

I know it won’t happen, but l seriously don’t know what he provides 

11 minutes ago, Billy said:

In Jordon, Grundy, Hibberd & Tmac

out Hunter, Melksham, Turner & Laurie

 

Dees have published their 2023 finals video - possessed. Nice.

https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/1417910/this-september-the-demons-are-possessed-finals-2023

8 minutes ago, Billy said:

I know it won’t happen, but l seriously don’t know what he provides 

What exactly does Jordon have over him though?

17 minutes ago, Billy said:

In Jordon, Grundy, Hibberd & Tmac

out Hunter, Melksham, Turner & Laurie

 

This is ridiculous 

5 minutes ago, In Harmes Way said:

Dees have published their 2023 finals video - possessed. Nice.

https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/1417910/this-september-the-demons-are-possessed-finals-2023

That’s, well, that’s just silly. This is exactly why I’m worried about the next game

Edited August 27, 20232 yr by Roost it far

27 minutes ago, Billy said:

Sorry I’m not trying to pick a fight, but you can’t be serious about Salem having a heavy tag, who & for what reason would he be tagged for, to stop those dinky little kicks 

l also thought Bowey was a bit loose today 

 

 

Unrelated but I used to like the Dana White UFC show 'Looking for a fight'. Thought it was pretty good and refreshing as Ultimate Fighter had gotten a bit boring.

Just now, Hopeful Demon said:

What exactly does Jordon have over him though?

I think he’s a better kick, better overhead, can tackle, can tag, can go into the midfield & doesn’t duck his head.

 

30 minutes ago, Billy said:

In Jordon, Grundy, Hibberd & Tmac

out Hunter, Melksham, Turner & Laurie

 

Please add May, Oliver and Fritsch to your outs to make this even more realistic. 

31 minutes ago, Billy said:

In Jordon, Grundy, Hibberd & Tmac

out Hunter, Melksham, Turner & Laurie

 

Like a dagger to my heart.

30 minutes ago, Hopeful Demon said:

Oh god not this again. Hunter's fine. He's one of the last players they'd drop.

Agree!!!!!

Just now, Jaded No More said:

Please add May, Oliver and Fritsch to your outs to make this even more realistic. 

Do you think Melksham, Turner & Laurie will play?

Hunter won’t get dropped I’ll admit that & Grundy won’t get another gig, it’s a forum so let’s not all get to angry over people’s opinions