The next Round 2 game sees a Ruck vs Ruck matchup as Jim Stynes takes on Jeff White.

You can either vote by going to our Facebook or Twitter pages or for convenience you can vote in the poll above.

Jim Stynes:
264 Games
130 Goals
1991 Brownlow Medal
4 x Keith Bluey Truscott Trophy
2 x All Australian
MFC Team of the Century
AFL Hall of Fame
MFC Hall of Fame

Jeff White:
236 Games
95 Goals
2004 Keith Bluey Truscott Trophy
2004 All Australian

loved jeff white, but he can't hold a candle to jimmy

Jeff whites early career was fantastic,  taking pack marks around the ground.  But 2nd half of career was less.

Jimma,  by virtue of consistency across his fantastic footy career.

46 minutes ago, whatwhatsaywhat said:

loved jeff white, but he can't hold a candle to jimmy

he could certainly hold a candle to jimmy

but no doubt jimmy wins this one

Just realised you missed his continuous games record from his stats  

2004 Jeff White beats a regulation Stynes year.

 

Stynes was truly one of Melbourne’s best ever. 

White was a great ruckman until they changed the rules.

Jimmy was Jimmy. No contest.

Stynes for me. White to repechage.

 

Jimmy was a great player and the reason I started going for Melbourne.

Absolutely idolised the man.

With that said, Jeff White is a massively underrated player in the AFL for the past 20 years.  He's very much overshadowed by the emergence of Cox and Sandilands toward the end of his career, and now with Gawn and Grundy, he doesn't really rate a mention by most.  He was a gun.

 

Stynes... but I did have to think about it.

 

Jeff White was certainly a high jumping ruckman with great agility sometimes punching the ball forward at will also his tapouts to the Mids was   of quality.   He could take a great mark and knew how to kick an important goal as he did against the Bulldogs at the G.     Played with a  shin injury which he carried for a number of years in games. He was our Premier ruckman for 11 seasons You can go on and on. Yes he was underrated in IMO as well.  

Jimmy Stynes the great man .....I saw that Brownlow  comiing.....seasons before when he started playing some consistent footy as he started to revolutionize the Rucking position..............

Jeff white was a Great Ruckman  for our club.   However Jimmy was   Great in many ways on and off the ground.

I don't need to elaborate.    Jimmy for me.