Sparrow, Jordan and Nietschke

[In Harmes Way 7,869]

Yesterday wasn’t the best day to judge the emerging draftees when we got an all round smacking and the senior players we fielded didn’t shine. I don’t expect a break in player to be best on ground under those circumstances. 
 

Didn’t see this level of negativity when we beat Richmond last week. I’d find a worst three on ground thread after a good win a much more balanced set of view points.

[Cheap Seats 3,310]

3-4 years in the system before you see real results.

I'm still bullish on Jordan and Sparrow, looking forward to watching them develop in 2021

[rjay 25,424]

3 hours ago, DeeSpencer said:

Sparrow’s a very strong kid with some explosive attributes. He ripped the ball free to set up one goal, and shrugged off a tackler at another stage. He’s also taken a number of very decent marks in his career. He was a half back at state level, that’s the next step to try him if he doesn’t start winning more ball. But he did his job when he played last year so I wouldn’t give up on him just yet. 
 

Been saying this for a long time now 'Dee', but he isn't a mid. He's not a natural ball winner...needs to be tried in defence if he's going to make it.

[Canplay 635]

Sparrow doesn't cut it -  hard and tought but for a bloke with average speed and average skills (at best) he needs to be a massive natural ball accumulator -  ball magnet like the crouch brothers -  but he's just not -   just doesn't read play well enough to compensate for average elements in game.  

 

[titan_uranus 25,255]

I'm far from convinced in either Sparrow or Jordon but I'm not going to write them off based on yesterday. The entire side was flogged by the competition's best midfield.

4 hours ago, Turner said:

discounting the academy picks, i highlighted who i woulda taken instead, notice a distinct lack of inside bullocking types. obvioulsy mosquito showed a fair bit as has jarrod cameron and the two rucks briggs and williams look decent too but don't fit a need for us

You mean who you would take if you knew what you knew now and could go back in time and do the draft again.

Which is not how it works.

[defuture15 902]

Didn't these players also miss a year of development last year as well?

[goodwindees 2,586]

22 hours ago, TeamPlayedFine39 said:

Not a lot of world beaters there.
Who do take..?

 

2	27	Melbourne Demons	Tom Sparrow
2	28	West Coast Eagles	Xavier O’Neill
2	29	Collingwood Magpies	Will Kelly
2	30	Adelaide Crows	Will Hamill
2	31	West Coast Eagles	Luke Foley
2	32	Fremantle Dockers	Luke Valente
2	33	Melbourne Demons	James Jordon
2	34	GWS Giants	Kieren Briggs
2	35	West Coast Eagles	Bailey Williams
2	36	Brisbane Lions	Tom Berry
2	37	Western Bulldogs	Laitham Vandermeer
2	38	Essendon Bombers	Irving Mosquito
2	39	West Coast Eagles	Jarrod Cameron
2	40	Brisbane Lions	Tom Joyce
2	41	St Kilda Saints	Jack Bytel
2	42	Brisbane Lions	Connor McFadyen
2	43	Richmond Tigers	Jack Ross
3	44	Sydney Swans	Justin McInerney
3	45	Western Bulldogs	Ben Cavarra
3	46	North Melbourne Kangaroos	Curtis Taylor
3	47	St Kilda Saints	Matthew Parker
3	48	Geelong Cats	Ben Jarvis
3	49	North Melbourne Kangaroos	Bailey Scott
3	50	Geelong Cats	Jacob Kennerley

 

Will Hamill is a beauty and just what we need and Tom Berry would have been a much better selection. 

[Elegt 872]

Just now, goodwindees said:

Will Hamill is a beauty and just what we need and Tom Berry would have been a much better selection. 

Latham vandermeer looks great too, fantastic pace with clean skills, would've looked good running the opposite wing to langdon

[Turner 1,516]

25 minutes ago, titan_uranus said:

I'm far from convinced in either Sparrow or Jordon but I'm not going to write them off based on yesterday. The entire side was flogged by the competition's best midfield.

You mean who you would take if you knew what you knew now and could go back in time and do the draft again.

Which is not how it works.

ok well yes and i get inside types take longer to develop and we've rotated a lot of smaller types off our list in the last two years and at the time i didnt see an issue with either selection, but it's always good to put the hindsight glasses on sometimes