2020 List - Trade period, signings and draft

[Dees_In_October 3,415]

The vast majority of our big names have signed on for 2020! The expansion teams can take up to 4 players total from us, so this is great news.

Locked in are:

Paxman (now a Club B&F winner and 3X All-Australian), O'Dea, Scott, Lampard, Cunningham, L.Pearce, Mithen, Newman, Hore, Emonson, Gay, Cordner, Smith, Zanker, Hanks, Guerin, Sloane, Sherriff

Yet to sign:

Jakobbson, Downie, Heath, Radan, Guest, Phillips, Kemp, Patterson, Woodland, Whitfort, Brancatisano, Hickey. And I guess technically Daisy?

The only other trade news of note for us is Libby Birch of the Western Bulldogs supposedly requesting a trade to Melbourne.

 

[chook fowler 19,464]

The way we are going we may get a priority pick

[dl4e 5,851]

Good to see some of our best players are locked in.

[58er 6,471]

Good list of retained players 

What about the Coach?

Pies have moved their man on and our same old same old positions finish on the ladder plus the failure to develop a real forward plan to ensure scores enough to make Finals plus win the close  games at Casey has hurt us 3 years in a row.

Our ladies team lacks at least a couple of flexible faster and skilled flankers and/or on ballers to break lines and assist scoring heavily, in short X factors ( like the Crows forwards) to go the next level and challenge for the Finals and flag.

We should be chasing Bec Goddard  if she is available to get a really aggressive and urgent game plan not the staid one that has failed for 3 years.

No doubt Mick Stennear is a popular coach but team needs should over prioritise popularity.

[poita 3,902]

Draft picks only sign 1 year deals? Downie would be good to keep and presumably they have hopes for Brancatisano. The rest are probably all expendable.

And yes, a decision should have been made on the coach by now.

 

[Meggs 595]

17 hours ago, Dees_In_October said:

The vast majority of our big names have signed on for 2020! The expansion teams can take up to 4 players total from us, so this is great news.

Locked in are:

Paxman (now a Club B&F winner and 3X All-Australian), O'Dea, Scott, Lampard, Cunningham, L.Pearce, Mithen, Newman, Hore, Emonson, Gay, Cordner, Smith, Zanker, Hanks, Guerin, Sloane, Sherriff

Yet to sign:

Jakobbson, Downie, Heath, Radan, Guest, Phillips, Kemp, Patterson, Woodland, Whitfort, Brancatisano, Hickey. And I guess technically Daisy?

The only other trade news of note for us is Libby Birch of the Western Bulldogs supposedly requesting a trade to Melbourne.

 

Agree, our better players have been locked in which is great news.  I assume Daisy will too.   

Of the Yet to sign group Jakobbsen, Downie and Phillips are good foot soldiers but the rest have not (or are yet) to prove themselves.  Of course Hickey is at Geelong.

[58er 6,471]

4 hours ago, poita said:

Draft picks only sign 1 year deals? Downie would be good to keep and presumably they have hopes for Brancatisano. The rest are probably all expendable.

And yes, a decision should have been made on the coach by now.

 

Can be 2 years from now on

Dint agree about expendable players !!

List if retainees  is good but needs an injection of class forwards quick and flexible to match goal scoring potential that has hampered us in the 3 years so far.

Next issue is why our game plan really doesn't stand up vs the top 2 or 3 teams.

Need more aggressive and urgent style IMO and that's the Coaches job do this is why I am saying a Change of Coach is necessary.

 

[Clintosaurus 7,858]

Meg Downie and Bianca Jakobsson have signed on for next season. This is good.

[Dees_In_October 3,415]

1 hour ago, Clintosaurus said:

Meg Downie and Bianca Jakobsson have signed on for next season. This is good.

I was sure that at least one of these would go, given the expansion, but here we are. Good news!

On 4/11/2019 at 1:57 PM, Meggs said:

Agree, our better players have been locked in which is great news.  I assume Daisy will too.   

Of the Yet to sign group Jakobbsen, Downie and Phillips are good foot soldiers but the rest have not (or are yet) to prove themselves.  Of course Hickey is at Geelong.

A different Hickey! Yet to play, so another of the unproven ones.

All up we have 20 signed, which leaves 7 places plus 3 rookies. I think the rookies can only be cross-coders.

[Meggs 595]

Yes of course you meant Jordann Hickey.  I’ve only seen her the one time playing as a key forward in the practice match against North. Didn’t impress enough to warrant selection during the season.  Better options elsewhere.

[Lucifers Hero 40,143]

That the new teams are able to plunder existing teams is having a horrendous affect.  Bulldogs have lost their captain who is their heart and sole player and also lost their current B&F.  Carlton have lost their captain and the Lions have been plundered. 

This is unacceptable in a fledgling competition.  The AFL should have done more to protect existing teams.

I don't know where Rich is getting all the money to attract big name players.  It has been suggested that some players are being offered 6 figure sums to change clubs.

I am very grateful that our core players are sticking with us.  But what is happening elsewhere is not good for the competition and does little to engender fan loyalty to a particular club.

[Clintosaurus 7,858]

Richmond are going down the Norf path. That worked out well.

[poita 3,902]

https://womens.afl/news/17845/second-chance-beckons-for-delisted-free-agents

Surely we need to find another decent forward - I hate to suggest it, but would we consider Moana Hope as a delisted free agent, although Richmond or St Kilda is more likely.

Am I right in thinking we don't have either a first or second round draft pick this year? Hence delisted free agents might be the only way to go, as our first pick is likely close to pick 50.

 

[poita 3,902]

https://womens.afl/news/17858/trade-and-signing-period-who-your-club-picked-up-plus-our-verdicthttps://womens.afl/news/17858/trade-and-signing-period-who-your-club-picked-up-plus-our-verdict

24 on the list, presumably not too many spots left to fill. Not sure that Libby Birch was worth pick 8, but perhaps the draft is weak. Cat Phillips is an interesting departure.

[Moonshadow 17,676]

Our women's team is looking towards Ireland as a potential recruiting ground...

https://www.theage.com.au/sport/afl/dees-pull-off-aflw-coup-20191002-p52wyw.html

Edited October 2, 2019 by Moonshadow