Tom Lynch smacks Laidler in the guts - fine.

Ceglar throws an elbow to the face of Hogan - 1 week.

 

You think Tom Hawkins is feeling a bit hard done by...?

 

Just now, Juicebox said:

Tom Lynch smacks Laidler in the guts - fine.

Ceglar throws an elbow to the face of Hogan - 1 week.

 

You think Tom Hawkins is feeling a bit hard done by...?

 

zero rhyme or reason to the MRP's thinking.....

5 hours ago, Gorgoroth said:

I think 2 weeks is about right. Its more a forearm than a point of the elbow. Just in comparison to Hawkins its a farce. 

I think 2 weeks is the minimum but it should be two weeks out, not one. Missing one game for that is laughable. 

It was right in front of me, Hogan was not expecting it, was caught off guard and was down for quite a while. He could have bumped him without lifting the elbow to his head. It was a filthy act, and he certainly deserved 2 weeks. 

1 hour ago, jules7 said:

It was right in front of me, Hogan was not expecting it, was caught off guard and was down for quite a while. He could have bumped him without lifting the elbow to his head. It was a filthy act, and he certainly deserved 2 weeks. 

It was despicable...absolutely.. Whats even more so is the chorus of silence from those who should be outraged

Id really like to see the Dees go out and "muscle " the Hawks next game. Really hurt them, make every contest HARD 

Bernie to bury Mitchell .. Viney ought to be back.. .Bet he'd revel in this game

10 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

Id really like to see the Dees go out and "muscle " the Hawks next game. Really hurt them, make every contest HARD 

Bernie to bury Mitchell .. Viney ought to be back.. .Bet he'd revel in this game

not even sure what "muscle" someone means.

I have no problem with every contest being as hard as possible - hard but fair. What Ceglar did was not hard  - it was a cheap shot to a player that wasn't expecting it.

I don't want our team going down the same route as Ceglar or what Vince and Viney did earlier. I want our team going down the route of what Viney did to Weller last year. 

My issue is that the MRP should take care of ensuring cheap shots and illegalities in general get what they deserve.

Compare what Hawkins and Ceglar did and one must ask  - in what universe do these two acts deserve the same punishment.

I have no faith at all in the MRP.

2 minutes ago, nutbean said:

not even sure what "muscle" someone means.

 

Never played contact sport ?? 

6 minutes ago, nutbean said:

I have no faith at all in the MRP.

You would if you were a hawks supporter, then it would always seem to work out nicely

2 minutes ago, ArtificialWisdom said:

You would if you were a hawks supporter, then it would always seem to work out nicely

Remind me...Evans from which club ?

1 minute ago, beelzebub said:

Remind me...Evans from which club ?

shhh dont say things like that! There will be a line of dark SUVs parked outside your house within minutes and we'll never here from you again.

2 minutes ago, ArtificialWisdom said:

shhh dont say things like that! There will be a line of dark SUVs parked outside your house within minutes and we'll never here from you again.

wondered who they were out there !! 

1 hour ago, beelzebub said:

Never played contact sport ?? 

My daughter plays footy - they call her bruiser - not sure about her genetics though as i played very much like Michael Young who came to us from Carlton ( muddy grounds for 4 quarters  - walked off the ground with pristine white shorts.) 

Edited June 7, 20169 yr by nutbean

4 hours ago, jules7 said:

It was right in front of me, Hogan was not expecting it, was caught off guard and was down for quite a while. He could have bumped him without lifting the elbow to his head. It was a filthy act, and he certainly deserved 2 weeks. 

Mongrel act.

53 minutes ago, nutbean said:

My daughter plays footy - they call her bruiser - not sure about her genetics though as i played very much like Michael Young who came to us from Carlton ( muddy grounds for 4 quarters  - walked off the ground with pristine white shorts.) 

I hear you

Trust me though when I say you can always ramp up the physicality if one wishes

I look forward to the square off at Round 20.

3 hours ago, nutbean said:

My daughter plays footy - they call her bruiser - not sure about her genetics though as i played very much like Michael Young who came to us from Carlton ( muddy grounds for 4 quarters  - walked off the ground with pristine white shorts.) 

better than walking off with brown shorts

Same penalty as Nev Jetta! Outrageous.

How is that  only 1 f''''ing week?

Edited June 7, 20169 yr by dieter