Changes v St Kilda

[stuie 7,374]

7 minutes ago, stevethemanjordan said:

Interesting.

That's one forced change but still doesn't give us any indication of who will come in.

A number of guys could play half-back.

Matt Jones? If we're going for a similar role.

 

[jnrmac 20,185]

Would like to see 3 in a row. First time since rds 17/18/19 in 2010.......

[Gator 17,449]

Teams thrive on a player playing their first game.  It's often said groups are "up" with the injection of a new player.  

No better way to tackle a team that has had the wood on us than by unleashing Petracca and his unbridled enthusiasm in our bid to win 3 in a row.  The perfect opportunity against the team that overlooked him.

[dazzledavey36 55,319]

56 minutes ago, ashdemons22 said:

Leg issue soft tissue type. Nothing serious pulled up sore won't make short turn around for Sat.

IF that's the case then the right decision for sure.

Who replaces Salem at HBF now?

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

29 minutes ago, ProDee said:

Tmac, Dunn, Lumumba, Wagner, Hunt, Jetta, Vince

The defence is pretty well covered by this group of 7.

I reckon it gives Petracca every opportunity if they manage Brayshaw

Out: Brayshaw, Salem

In: Oliver, Petracca

It is. Which is why I'm excited by the thought of it being Petracca or Trenners.

I'd be happy with those ins. 

I reckon we could move Jeffy or Kent up to a wing for periods of the game with Trac playing either deep forward or HF.

Vince to a back flank at times, Oliver into the middle.

Can't remember having an injury list this healthy in my time as a supporter.

Hoping Salem (the Ectomorph) will only miss the one week.

Edited April 26, 2016 by stevethemanjordan

[Redlegs Too 106]

If the selectors deem a change is necessary, and it looks like it will be, JT not Traccs is the in form player Imv that earns the place. 

[stevethemanjordan 6,952]

32 minutes ago, stuie said:

Matt Jones? If we're going for a similar role.

 

I know you want a response from me because you think I speak ill of Matt Jones.

I think he was really solid whilst in the side but honestly I think it'll be hard for him to get his position back this week only because of the quality we have to choose from.

He was doing absolutely nothing wrong whilst in the side. But I'd still rather Petracca, Oliver and Trengove as I see they offer everything that he does and then some. 

The only exception being outside run. 

But I can't see that being a problem against the Saints.

Edited April 26, 2016 by stevethemanjordan

[stuie 7,374]

1 minute ago, stevethemanjordan said:

I know you want a response from me because you think I speak ill of Matt Jones.

I think he was really solid whilst in the side but honestly I think it'll be hard for him to get his position back this week only because of the quality we have to chose from.

He was doing absolutely nothing wrong whilst in the side. But I'd still rather Petracca, Oliver and Trengove as I see they offer everything that he does and then some. 

The only exception being outside run. 

But I can't see that being a problem against the Saints.

No, not at all, was a genuine question and I honestly had no idea you'd spoken ill of him or anything like that.

Just thinking role wise he seems the obvious replacement for Salem, but that's mostly because in my mind I have Oliver coming in for Gus and Trac coming in for either Pedo or Frost.

Wouldn't normally expect 3 changes after a win, but with the short week I don't think it's beyond the realms of possibility.

Speed and outside run is going to be vital this week though, our best performances at Etihad have been with smaller lineups.

 

[old dee 23,872]

5 minutes ago, stuie said:

No, not at all, was a genuine question and I honestly had no idea you'd spoken ill of him or anything like that.

Just thinking role wise he seems the obvious replacement for Salem, but that's mostly because in my mind I have Oliver coming in for Gus and Trac coming in for either Pedo or Frost.

Wouldn't normally expect 3 changes after a win, but with the short week I don't think it's beyond the realms of possibility.

Speed and outside run is going to be vital this week though, our best performances at Etihad have been with smaller lineups.

 

There have been so few that I am not sure how you can come to that conclusion stuie.

Edited April 26, 2016 by old dee

[Redleg 41,428]

1 minute ago, old dee said:

There have been so few that I am not sure how you can come to that conclusion stuie.

By using a small sample.

[stuie 7,374]

1 minute ago, old dee said:

There have been so few that I am not sure how you can come to that conclusion stuie.

Last year - Massive loss to the Dogs with a tall lineup, win against GWS with a small lineup.

Different teams granted, but Roosy definitely changed his Etihad selection criteria after the Dogs game.

 

[Redleg 41,428]

Just now, stuie said:

Last year - Massive loss to the Dogs with a tall lineup, win against GWS with a small lineup.

Different teams granted, but Roosy definitely changed his Etihad selection criteria after the Dogs game.

 

Are you suggesting one of Frost/Pedersen gets rested?

[binman 43,761]

17 hours ago, ProDee said:

Teams thrive on a player playing their first game.  It's often said groups are "up" with the injection of a new player.  

No better way to tackle a team that has had the wood on us than by unleashing Petracca and his unbridled enthusiasm in our bid to win 3 in a row.  The perfect opportunity against the team that overlooked him.

Good point. I suspect they will pick him and a large part of the rationale will be the injection of energy to the team and the excitement for the fans. That and his head will probably explode if they don't! 

Edited April 26, 2016 by binman
PD is not the messiah

[stuie 7,374]

Just now, Redleg said:

Are you suggesting one of Frost/Pedersen gets rested?

In my opinion there's a decent chance one will be left out. Undecided which, Frost has the better speed which is important at Etihad, but Pedo is a better backup ruck option at this stage I think.

 

[old dee 23,872]

4 minutes ago, Redleg said:

By using a small sample.

If the sample is too small Mr. Leg it tells you bugger all.

[Redleg 41,428]

Just now, stuie said:

In my opinion there's a decent chance one will be left out. Undecided which, Frost has the better speed which is important at Etihad, but Pedo is a better backup ruck option at this stage I think.

 

Assuming Salem is out, I would rest Bugg, if Brayshaw is not rested and bring in Oliver and CP5. 

Brayshaw just doesn't look right ATM.

[old dee 23,872]

5 minutes ago, stuie said:

Last year - Massive loss to the Dogs with a tall lineup, win against GWS with a small lineup.

Different teams granted, but Roosy definitely changed his Etihad selection criteria after the Dogs game.

 

I think we would have lost to the Dogs no matter who we played, the problem in that game was injuries had reduced our options to near nil.

[stuie 7,374]

1 minute ago, Redleg said:

Assuming Salem is out, I would rest Bugg, if Brayshaw is not rested and bring in Oliver and CP5. 

Brayshaw just doesn't look right ATM.

Why would you rest Bugg?

 

[Bang Bang Bang 5,839]

I think Matt Jones will come back in. I'm guessing the coaches rate him higher than most Demonlanders (including me) because he was named in the starting 18 every week from Rounds 1-4. He'll be over his general soreness and will slot straight, perhaps for Salem if the information above is accurate.

Petracca will surely come in, probably at Brayshaw's expense. Regardless of his role, I don't think 10 touches and a goal is good enough for Gus to retain his spot. 

Oliver carved the Saints up in the practice game and a refreshed Oliver is best 22. I don't know who makes way for him though. I wasn't a big Frost fan at the start of the year but I think he offers a lot. Pace, strength, good hands in close, bobs up for the occasional goal (and many points). Harmes would be stiff, his kicking has been a real weapon in our two recent wins. 

I think the changes will be:

In. Petracca, Matt Jones

Out. Salem (injured), Brayshaw

Edited April 26, 2016 by Sylvia Saint

[old dee 23,872]

Just now, stuie said:

Why would you rest Bugg?

 

A very good question!

[stuie 7,374]

1 minute ago, old dee said:

I think we would have lost to the Dogs no matter who we played, the problem in that game was injuries had reduced our options to near nil.

Yeah, not in any way saying we should/would have won, but we were destroyed in that game, and if you look at the teams we selected for Etihad games after it we went small, including when we beat GWS. It seemed that Roosy decided that was the way to go, and I don't reckon a victory would have made him question that.

[beelzebub 23,383]

What an amazing position to be in with the likes of Clarry, Trenners and Truck all lurking wanting to join in. 

Selecting the side is now a very difficult thing.

Be great to see CP get a run if for no other reason than the headache it gives the Saints trying to judge his impact and who/how to stop it.

Have a funny feeling he'll get a debut on the G

[old dee 23,872]

3 minutes ago, stuie said:

Yeah, not in any way saying we should/would have won, but we were destroyed in that game, and if you look at the teams we selected for Etihad games after it we went small, including when we beat GWS. It seemed that Roosy decided that was the way to go, and I don't reckon a victory would have made him question that.

The sample size will increase on Saturday.

I am confident we can win with however we pick.

 

[old dee 23,872]

2 minutes ago, beelzebub said:

What an amazing position to be in with the likes of Clarry, Trenners and Truck all lurking wanting to join in. 

Selecting the side is now a very difficult thing.

Be great to see CP get a run if for no other reason than the headache it gives the Saints trying to judge his impact and who/how to stop it.

Have a funny feeling he'll get a debut on the G

Very pleasant problem to have bb.

It is very long time since we were in this position.

[beelzebub 23,383]

9 minutes ago, old dee said:

A very good question!

I wouldn't.... He's hitting his straps