Cross- 3 votes?

One for each kick on the full ?

This is the Player of the Year thread. Save your player bashing for every other thread just like the rest of us do.

6. Vince

5. McDonald

4. Prince

3. Jones

2. Hogan

1. Garland

Stiff Jetta

6. Vince

5. McDonald

4. Prince

3. Jones

2. Hogan

1. Garland

Agree with top six but thought Jetta, whilst beating Betts, lacked his usual kicking control.

Howe also could have snuck a vote, while Cross is very unlucky.

PS: The guy who gave the best players for the Herald Sun is a new guy in Adelaide and didn't actually know most of the Melbourne players - hence they are out of touch with reality.

6 B Vince

5 T Mcdonald

4 H Lalalalamumba !!!

3 J Hogan ... 10 year contract offer

2 J Gartlett ...though if he kicked straight

1 N Jones

Edited April 19, 201510 yr by spirit of norm smith

This is the Player of the Year thread. Save your player bashing for every other thread just like the rest of us do.

This is for hand wringing whiney poster of the year.

Save your snark!

You're comfortably in Front!

Progressive totals after Round 3 and the T Mac juggernaut rolls on:

53. Tom McDonald

22. Jack Viney

17. Nathan Jones

16. Jesse Hogan Bernie Vince

11. Christian Salem

10. Colin Garland Neville Jetta

7. Daniel Cross

6. Jack Watts

5. Jeffrey Garlett

4. Mark Jamar Ben Newton

3. Aaron vandenBerg

2. Heritier Lubumba

1. Angus Brayshaw Colin Garland Lynden Dunn

I'm liking the settled team and the votes are showing that everyone is putting their hand up. Only Dawes, JKH, Kent, Toump, Frost and Howe don't have votes this year.

Progressive totals after Round 3 and the T Mac juggernaut rolls on:

53. Tom McDonald

22. Jack Viney

17. Nathan Jones

16. Jesse Hogan Bernie Vince

11. Christian Salem

10. Colin Garland Neville Jetta

7. Daniel Cross

6. Jack Watts

5. Jeffrey Garlett

4. Mark Jamar Ben Newton

3. Aaron vandenBerg

2. Heritier Lubumba

1. Angus Brayshaw Colin Garland Lynden Dunn

You've listed Garland twice. But interesting tally so far.

Edited April 19, 201510 yr by Demon Jack

I'm basing my votes on Kevin Bartlett's call on SEN:

6: Him

5: He

4: He's

3: Himself

2: His

1: Them

Gee, it's hard work listening to his commentary. Half the time it's unclear which team the "Him" refers to. So I might have just given votes to someone in the Adelaide team.

6. Vince

5. McDonald

4. HL

3. Jones

2. Brayshaw

1. Watts

6-Vince

5-McDonald

4-Garland

3-Jetta

2-Jones

1-Lumumba

6. T Mac
5. Vince
4. Lumumba
3. Brayshaw
2. Hogan

1. Salem