Apologies, that reply was to BB's post, which Tim quoted.

Training reports are good for finding out about injuries, training focus (fitness or skills), how players are training and what position. But that's about it, you can't read into it too much about how a player will play in the upcoming season, becuase for the most part we already know how good a player is by watching them in games.

Agree, it just gives us an idea of how a particular player's preparation for the season ahead has been travelling, what sort of consistent training block they have behind them, etc.

Personally I'd much rather read Saty giving it to those who brainlessly criticise him for his contribution that the pompous righteousness of RPFC who continually wants to be the school headmaster of the posters here and set us all straight on things we don't really understand. But that's just me and I actually don't support either approach.

As for those who so boldly say they'd have no problem telling a player to his face what they think of him - well bully for you. It says more about you than anything else.

With free speech comes responsibility, something which is sadly lacking here a lot of the time and why I think this once great site has lost so many of its good posters and been reduced to an occasional read and contribution rather than something to be involved in regularly.

I wonder how long it will be until I break my resolution again.

Again, I don't know what your problem is with me - how you chose my post out of all the better nonsense I don't know.

I don't like pointless snarky asides and TDI has given out more than is deserved, he brings more value to this site than many others, but that isn't an excuse to say anything you want.

You once warned me as a mod for the very type of behaviour.

And there are plenty of excellent posters on this site, I am not aware of any decent poster that has left.

I hope TDI continues and I hope I don't have to read the bitter back-and-forth in future training threads.

If that is self-righteous and pompous then DC is right - there is a great deal of thin skin around here.

FMD, the footy season can't come quick enough.....

I reckon we should have Saty thread where people can argue about him to their hearts content for surely he must be the most discussed issue on DL. It would also enable Saty to continue to enjoy the baiting he has admitted n many occasions that he enjoys so much. It might also help the training threads not being derailed.

But life is short. I reckon a good option is to use Ignore or as suggested above by Tim filter out the flotsam and read the bits you like.

But Saty can i make a suggestion. If you film your player interviews and post them on DL you will exponentially grow the number of posters you annoy and fuel untold Saty related debate. Imagine DL posters dissecting your interviews, analyzing body language (are the players genuine or do they really want to run away?) and playing backwards to check for hidden messages. Hours of fun.

I reckon we should have Saty thread where people can argue about him to their hearts content for surely he must be the most discussed issue on DL. It would also enable Saty to continue to enjoy the baiting he has admitted n many occasions that he enjoys so much. It might also help the training threads not being derailed.

But life is short. I reckon a good option is to use Ignore or as suggested above by Tim filter out the flotsam and read the bits you like.

But Saty can i make a suggestion. If you film your player interviews and post them on DL you will exponentially grow the number of posters you annoy and fuel untold Saty related debate. Imagine DL posters dissecting your interviews, analyzing body language (are the players genuine or do they really want to run away?) and playing backwards to check for hidden messages. Hours of fun.

What a top idea!, already have a couple of things on film, including Dean Terlich but then again some therapists bills may rise, and we don't want that

RPFC, you will notice there are quite a few readers of this site, but not that many regular posters, why because they don't want to face the wrath of the less enlightened on here if they go against their mindset in a post, most who just read appreciate that I deliberately bait those less enlightened posters, I find it entertaining, it brings their prejudices to the surface

A couple of players have actually said that they have been told not to read Denonland as it is "nothing but negativity", which is sad, I have even told then that it isn't all negativity, so they will provide me with answers, and not clichés, in fact some times I am careful what I ask Daniel Cross in particular as he is so bloody honest in his answers

A couple of players have actually said that they have been told not to read Denonland as it is "nothing but negativity", which is sad, I have even told then that it isn't all negativity, so they will provide me with answers, and not clichés, in fact some times I am careful what I ask Daniel Cross in particular as he is so bloody honest in his answers

If everyone came on to Demonland to talk about how good the club is no one would read it.

If everyone came on to Demonland to talk about how good the club is no one would read it.

I agree, but the sadness lays in the fact that the Club thinks it is nothing but negativity

If everyone came on to Demonland to talk about how good the club is no one would read it.

I dunno, I do enjoy Happy Smiling North KoreaLand forum moderated by Kim Jong Un.

I agree, but the sadness lays in the fact that the Club thinks it is nothing but negativity

I suspect that with so much failure on and off the field those around the club have to cling to only positive things or they will end up in the foetal position.

The nett result is some of the brutal honesty on here means we are a no go zone for people at the club.

They will be back on in 2017 when we are playing finals

The players I've spoken to had never even heard of Demonland, and frankly it means two fifths of stuff all what they think of the place.

Anyone with even a semblance of sense in their cranium understands that this is a forum specifically catered for fans to discuss the club and its players, positive and negative, and that sharing and discussing critiques of players is part of that discussion.

The only "hero" is someone disturbed enough to take joy in baiting and abusing people who choose to take part in that forum and are motivated by nothing but interest in their football club.

I agree the thread should be closed. Nothing more to be gained.

If everyone came on to Demonland to talk about how good the club is no one would read it.

or conversely, no one would believe it.

I agree, but the sadness lays in the fact that the Club thinks it is nothing but negativity

To be fair to DL - this forum is probably less negative then the other club forums I have read ( in particular Punt Road End ) ...however.....

This little gathering of head cases is a mere reflection of what goes on at all other club fan forums - with the "woes is us" at one end, the "we can never possibly be anything other than magnificent" at the other extreme and then varying shades of posters in between. We have thoughtful, insightful posters vs the reactors who fly off from viewing a split second of football and finally we have the polite " he could do better" against the "he's a giant spit bucket of spud vomit and should never disgrace our jumper again".

The common thread is that anyone who has time to read a football forum like this let alone post is a sad football tragic. ( I am as tragic as they come)

Edited January 14, 201510 yr by nutbean

I don't personally attack, like the garbage I receive, but I am man enough to take it, I use humour and a bit of sarcasm, I hope I haven't written too much, don't want you getting your lips in a tangle whilst you read it. Don't read my posts precious

Contradicting yourself in the same sentence, that takes some skill. Love the way you habitually play the victim card while dishing out the attacks.

Back on topic, some of the comments about McDonald are just plain ridiculous

And in true Saty form, backing up the personal attacks with yet more dogmatism. So supporters are "plain ridiculous" for commenting on T-Mac's disposal?

It's a discussion forum; everyone's entitled to state their thoughts without your predictable reproach over every dissenting opinion.

Hunter S would be proud of Saty. Lucky we have firearms laws.

The players I've spoken to had never even heard of Demonland, and frankly it means two fifths of stuff all what they think of the place.

Anyone with even a semblance of sense in their cranium understands that this is a forum specifically catered for fans to discuss the club and its players, positive and negative, and that sharing and discussing critiques of players is part of that discussion.

The only "hero" is someone disturbed enough to take joy in baiting and abusing people who choose to take part in that forum and are motivated by nothing but interest in their football club.

I agree the thread should be closed. Nothing more to be gained.

This. Couldn't agree more.

Don't care whether the players read Land at all, nor what they think of our view of them.

I agree the thread should be closed. Nothing more to be gained.

Given that the same circular argument is going to continue in the next training thread, and the one after that, I'm not sure what's to be gained in closing this one down.

Everyone knows Saty's routine by now - if it really bothers you, put him on ignore, or let his responses go through to the keeper. It's really not that hard.

Edit: Actually, on second thoughts..