I'm tipping Magner is playing on the ball today? Wonder if he will get a run through there during the season? Seems to play better as a ball winner/midfielder than a defensive forward.

sylvia has more talent that everyone out there but yet again disappointing

been a long term supporter but im losing the faith after watchin him have little interest last week as well

lacklustre

sylvia has more talent that everyone out there but yet again disappointing

been a long term supporter but im losing the faith after watchin him have little interest last week as well

lacklustre

At half time, Sylvia has not had a single handball.

Magner has 5 tackles and I bet you didn't know Terlich has 4!

Magner can get a lot of it, but his kicking can be very ordinary.

I'm tipping Magner is playing on the ball today? Wonder if he will get a run through there during the season? Seems to play better as a ball winner/midfielder than a defensive forward.

I couldn't work out why Neeld tried him as a defensive forward when was doing so well as a mid.

Why are there so many whingers on this forum??? The commentators are giving Melbourne a wrap saying that we are moving the ball well and putting on good pressure. It's just that they don't know our players names.

Let up on the complaining for a change ! Turn off if you don't like it! Or even better some of the people that are on this forum could actually say something positive.

Sylvia has 6 possessions and 1 handball. His name has not been mentioned ONCE!!!!!!!

Commentary not too bad. They don't know all our players but they aren't anywhere near as bad as previous years.

Joel McDonald has 8 possessions. His name has been mentioned ONCE!!!!!

I'm tipping Magner is playing on the ball today? Wonder if he will get a run through there during the season? Seems to play better as a ball winner/midfielder than a defensive forward.

Always has. Definitely putting his hand up today. Good to...hear.

I heard them mention Sylvia twice.

I couldn't work out why Neeld tried him as a defensive forward when was doing so well as a mid.

Probably trying to teach him the defensive side of the game. He wouldn't be the only ball winning mid in the comp with ordinary disposal by foot. Brad Sewell & Shane Tuck come to mind.

The commentators have no intention of mentioning (or even knowing) melbourne players, other than those recruited from SA. Unprofessional!!!!! Anywhere in the world (except Argentina!)

Sylvia has 6 possessions and 1 handball. His name has not been mentioned ONCE!!!!!!!

I have heard him called.

If Sylvia doesn't murder them in this second half he shouldn't play Round 1. Sick of it.

I apologise condemmed 84... I may have blinked!

"Undefined" turned it around in that quarter, he now has 3 possessions

At least they wont need to go far to get the oranges

I'm tipping Magner is playing on the ball today? Wonder if he will get a run through there during the season? Seems to play better as a ball winner/midfielder than a defensive forward.

Magner is another in and under mid and last year with Jones,Beamer,Mckenzie and Magner it was too much of the same. I agree he is a better ball winner then anything else but we need someone to handball it to out of the pack. He was tried as a bit of a tagger too last year and that didn't work.

Frees Port 12 Melb 9

Wines has a third of Port frees

I had Couch ahead of Magner after last week. I was wrong!

Dead set, the Sylvia talk on this forum is nothing short of ridiculous.

Sellar 4 goals, Magner 14 touches.. encouraging