I note Collingwood did not make a big deal about him when he was there. We milked the whole story for everything and looks like another of Schwab's hair brained promotions which as usual back fired badly.

As i understand it, Jurrah was never recruited by Collingwood, so why would they have made a big deal of him? But one thing certainly does become evident in your final sentence...just another CS hater.

is anyone surprised at whats happened here? the Australian legal syetem is one of the worstr in the world, and the judges are absoutely pathetic and gutless

Just ask the families of Jill Meagher and Sarah Cafferkey, and others who have had their families toirn apart by human filth that is allowed to walk the streets among us thanks to the [censored] wig wearing clowns that fail to take rape and murder seriously and continually give out soft sentences for brutal crimes

Don't see the similarities between a rapist/murderer and a reckless/agg assault. But yeah , hang em high and throw away the key and all that.

BTW the Judges dont set the punishments, they just apply them.

Speak to your local politician if you want the death penalty brought back.

If we hang 3 or 4 killers a year it saves the community millions over their lifetime.

I would introduce it for white collar crimes as well.

Liam just needs a slap over the face .

It sounds like you Muvver Jones would not be aware of the MFC`s glaucoma program which accompanied Jimmy`s trip to Yuendumu and which has helped reduce infection rates by 30 per cent over two years AND which is continuing and being maintained into the future.

It`s interesting that you invoke the name of a famous US progressive journal in your id but express such blunt, inflexible views.

I have read the book. I believe BHM (Rudeboy) was entirely genuine in writing it, but the title is the problem. It is more about BHM`s encounters with Liam than a comprehensive life so far tale.

Not the journal, the old lady that inspired it.

Read this article, the treacle could not have been trowelled on any thicker. Not much mention of Glaucoma.

http://www.theage.com.au/news/rfnews/stynes-delivers-on-promise/2009/11/13/1258043793893.html

Edited March 29, 201312 yr by Muvver Jones

I don't recall that but wouldn't he have been referring to Jurrah's celebrity status in his family / community ? This was certainly raised by his defence - the tactic of targeting the tall poppy in the community.

The point I'm making is that Jurrah didn't create - and certainly couldn't stop - the hype about him.. he was a star on the rise, and the story was a fairytale that was always going to accompany his career.

Yes I'm pretty sure it was in that vein regarding the 'tall poppy' that Liam had become in the eyes of his community.

I agree with you to an extent that a lot of that wasn't of his making. But those who 'adopted' him - particularly Rudeboy as his chief 'minder' - should have been less naive (kindest way I can put it) about that aspect of the Jurrah 'phenomenon' and resisted fanning the flames of it. I think it's beyond dispute that the book was premature and counter-productive.

Muvver Jones may also have a point regarding those feel-good junkets to Yuendumu, well-intentioned though they were.

Edited March 29, 201312 yr by Range Rover

Geez there's some silly posts here. Never heard so many judgmental braggarts in one place. Everyone seemed happy with the book at the time, so all you Captain Hindsights coming out saying "rah rah Rudeboy's book ruined everything" sound like absolute fools. It's unbelievable how many here who seem to have no understanding of Liam's community and background now seem to know exactly what should have been done and are so gleeful in their ill-informed tut tuting and finger waiving. NONE of us truly understand Liam and his family. All of you trying to show just how much you know are only serving to highlight your ignorance.

This is a terrible situation no matter who you believe is at fault, and it's an absolute indictment on certain posters here that they are trying to use it to push agendas and place themselves on the moral high ground by constantly putting things down rather than contributing anything constructive.

This thread should be closed again and only opened for news updates posted by a mod. It's an embarrassment.

Edited March 30, 201312 yr by stuie

Geez there's some silly posts here. Never heard so many judgmental braggarts in one place. Everyone seemed happy with the book at the time, so all you Captain Hindsights coming out saying "rah rah Rudeboy's book ruined everything" sound like absolute fools. It's unbelievable how many here who seem to have no understanding of Liam's community and background now seem to know exactly what should have been done and are so gleeful in their ill-informed tut tuting and finger waiving. NONE of us truly understand Liam and his family. All of you trying to show just how much you know are only serving to highlight your ignorance.

This is a terrible situation no matter who you believe is at fault, and it's an absolute indictment on certain posters here that they are trying to use it to push agendas and place themselves on the moral high ground by constantly putting things down rather than contributing anything constructive.

This thread should be closed again and only opened for news updates posted by a mod. It's an embarrassment.

Outrage suits your ranting ,raving style Stu.

Go with it .

However,the moral indignation and "embarrassment" are a bit hard to take.

Outrage suits your ranting ,raving style Stu.

Go with it .

However,the moral indignation and "embarrassment" are a bit hard to take.

You're a big man Biffen. Takes a brave man to constantly bring others down while not actually contributing anything. Back to being blocked for you funny man.

You're a big man Biffen. Takes a brave man to constantly bring others down while not actually contributing anything. Back to being blocked for you funny man.

Devastated.

When did i ever say the release of the Jurrah book was a good idea Stuie?

I have always said it was about 30% completed.

As we can all see the story is still unfolding.

(BHM) Rudeboy made a bad error there, it may have been innocent but it was done.

But keep ranting Stuie if it makes you feel better.

Geez there's some silly posts here. Never heard so many judgmental braggarts in one place. Everyone seemed happy with the book at the time, so all you Captain Hindsights coming out saying "rah rah Rudeboy's book ruined everything" sound like absolute fools. It's unbelievable how many here who seem to have no understanding of Liam's community and background now seem to know exactly what should have been done and are so gleeful in their ill-informed tut tuting and finger waiving. NONE of us truly understand Liam and his family. All of you trying to show just how much you know are only serving to highlight your ignorance.

This is a terrible situation no matter who you believe is at fault, and it's an absolute indictment on certain posters here that they are trying to use it to push agendas and place themselves on the moral high ground by constantly putting things down rather than contributing anything constructive.

This thread should be closed again and only opened for news updates posted by a mod. It's an embarrassment.

Stu, you are fast developing a track record of imploring mods to close down threads which contain views you disagree with.

It's not a good track record to have.

Edited March 30, 201312 yr by Range Rover

When did i ever say the release of the Jurrah book was a good idea Stuie?

I have always said it was about 30% completed.

As we can all see the story is still unfolding.

(BHM) Rudeboy made a bad error there, it may have been innocent but it was done.

But keep ranting Stuie if it makes you feel better.

Sums up Demonland a bit lately, everyone just wants to bring down anyone trying to be constructive.

Stu, you are fast developing a track record of imploring mods to close down threads which contain views you disagree with.

It's not a good track record to have.

It's not about disagreeing, it's about the absolute ill-informed rubbish starting to show up in this thread and what it is turning into.

Devastated.

You’ll no doubt require intense counselling to recover from such a loss Biffo –

perhaps even a weekend at Hepburn.

However,I reckon it’s time to close this thread and let the Jurrah issue go -

permanently. As far as I can see 99.9% of what is being written here is either

pure (impure?) opinion, guesswork, speculation or simply drivel. The reality is

that only Liam and those closest to him can sort out the mess he finds himself

in. Nothing written here will change anything and in fact, only adds to the

acrimony. Some of the Demonland “journalism” on this issue makes Kero look

Pulitzer prize material.

Good luck to Liam but footy (for us) starts tomorrow – thankfully. Let’s argue about that and other serious issues

such as how many bananas an alpaca can consume.

Christ.It seems I’m at least partially agreeing with Stuie. I’d better find a counsellor– no hang on – I already have a counsellor.

You’ll no doubt require intense counselling to recover from such a loss Biffo –

perhaps even a weekend at Hepburn.

However,I reckon it’s time to close this thread and let the Jurrah issue go -

permanently. As far as I can see 99.9% of what is being written here is either

pure (impure?) opinion, guesswork, speculation or simply drivel. The reality is

that only Liam and those closest to him can sort out the mess he finds himself

in. Nothing written here will change anything and in fact, only adds to the

acrimony. Some of the Demonland “journalism” on this issue makes Kero look

Pulitzer prize material.

Good luck to Liam but footy (for us) starts tomorrow – thankfully. Let’s argue about that and other serious issues

such as how many bananas an alpaca can consume.

Christ.It seems I’m at least partially agreeing with Stuie. I’d better find a counsellor– no hang on – I already have a counsellor.

having an alpaca as a best friend doesn't count as having a counsellor

stick to the drugs and bananas

oh, yes, close this thread before i bust my screen

Edited March 30, 201312 yr by daisycutter

Yeah ,

I agree with Stu too.

PM me the counsellors details.

Shutdown 66.

The only concession I'd make to Stu is that this thread probably doesn't need to be on the footy board. The issues surrounding it more suit the general board given we're neither discussing an MFC player or even a current day footballer.

It's more politics and sociology than sport.

Leave it where it is. It is a relevent discussion.

If Stuie has such strong issues with the discussion then he shouldn't ipen the thread.

It's that easy.

Leave it where it is. It is a relevent discussion.

If Stuie has such strong issues with the discussion then he shouldn't ipen the thread.

It's that easy.

You may prefer the head in the sand option when it comes to ignorance WYL, but not everyone does.

Arested AGAIN!?!

Surley this cant be another fresh news

You may prefer the head in the sand option when it comes to ignorance WYL, but not everyone does.

mate i have lived up in the top end for a few months, so i do have a little insight.

Have you travelled?

Keep your ignorant comments to yourself. Getting a little tired of you deciding what is right or wrong on this site Stuie.

Liam is in the news weekly at the moment, bouncing from one disaster to another.

It is my opinion that the book that was written on Liam was published way to early and has contributed to the situation that is still unfolding.

Bad decisions were made, some innocently & some just plain bad.

mate i have lived up in the top end for a few months, so i do have a little insight.

Have you travelled?

Keep your ignorant comments to yourself. Getting a little tired of you deciding what is right or wrong on this site Stuie.

Liam is in the news weekly at the moment, bouncing from one disaster to another.

It is my opinion that the book that was written on Liam was published way to early and has contributed to the situation that is still unfolding.

Bad decisions were made, some innocently & some just plain bad.

Do you even understand irony WYL?

I'm not making judgments about what has happened and who is responsible, I'm just saying there's some dumb comments here by people who think they know.

Do you even understand irony WYL?

I'm not making judgments about what has happened and who is responsible, I'm just saying there's some dumb comments here by people who think they know.

yes and i am saying some of your comments are ilinformed too Stuie so yes i do understand irony.

yes and i am saying some of your comments are ilinformed too Stuie so yes i do understand irony.

Which ones exactly WYL? Show me.

Meanwhile, and just to take our minds of the sad state of affairs, another sad state of affairs:

http://www.alicespringsnews.com.au/2013/04/02/court-told-liam-jurrah-kicked-woman-in-the-head-is-denied-bail/

it's just very, very sad.