Just the player the Demons need, out of contract at the perfect time. Yet our club sits around doing nothing while an already strong Freo looks to get even stronger. We could offer way more money then Fremantle.

What the hell is going on down at the MFC?

How do you know we havent offered anything?

You do realise that although Freo put in the official offer to the AFL it doesn't mean that we didn't make a play for him. What the lodgement by Freo means is that they probably have the best offer on the table, or Pearce just prefers them as a destination. It is unlikely that a formal proposal would be put forward without the players approval.

How about thinking things through before blindly having a go at the club.

I move that the thread be closed on the basis that the if the O/P is not a member of the staff responsible for managing the list of the MFC then it has no basis in fact.

If the writer of the O/P can provide evidence which supports his statement or can provide evidence of actually being an MFC member of staff then I may be prepared to accept his statement.

so much for leaving no stone unturned...

Freo have put an offer on the table. Has Pearce accepted it? The FA gets to declare the club he wants to go to, it's not just up to who puts up the biggest bid.

You do realise that although Freo put in the official offer to the AFL it doesn't mean that we didn't make a play for him. What the lodgement by Freo means is that they probably have the best offer on the table, or Pearce just prefers them as a destination. It is unlikely that a formal proposal would be put forward without the players approval.

How about thinking things through before blindly having a go at the club.

Spot on pm24 this trading period is 18 days I don't think it serve much good getting worked up 3 hours into the first day.

Lets see what has happened at the end of the next 18 days.

I live in SA and watch a lot of port if there is a spud its Pearce, total front runner who continually turns the footy over

Silly season is here at last.

I live in SA and watch a lot of port if there is a spud its Pearce, total front runner who continually turns the footy over

If there is a type of player we really don't need it's a front runner.

We do not need Pearce, would be a handy pick up for an evolved team, but not for ours.

If this system is going to work in a similar way to the NBA then a formal offer isn't sent into the league for approval unless the player has approved it. It in no way suggests that other teams haven't tried to recruit that player.

It would just be a circus if every team that had an offer for a player had to officially submit that offer to the AFL in order for the player to accept it. In that case we would have multiple clubs officially submitting offers, but which offer would the team who currently has that player have to match. It's nonsensical. I firmly believe that no formal offer would be submitted unless the player/player agents have signed off on it.

Therefore, we never know who formally made an offer to the player because we only hear the final transaction.

Look at the following article on afl.com http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/148928/default.aspx

It seems to support what i'm saying in respect to the offer process. There appears no capacity for another team to lodge an offer with the AFL once one team has lodged it's papers. Therefore this suggests that it is the offer that Pearce/Pearce's management has deemed the best.

Edited October 1, 201213 yr by pm24

I've been hearing all morning on SEN that Lynch has signed a 2 year deal with Melbourne and will be announced later today but there is nothing on the web about it.

God I hope It true, Lynch would be great for our club.

I've been hearing all morning on SEN that Lynch has signed a 2 year deal with Melbourne and will be announced later today but there is nothing on the web about it.

God I hope It true, Lynch would be great for our club.

But how could that possibly be true???? I thought we were sitting on our hands and not putting any effort into getting players to the club, just like the OP said.

Lynch > Pearce

Danyle Pearce can run, that's about it. He is an average player in a very average side.

Lynch on the other hand is a decent key forward in a top side. Offers finals experience and a winning attitude. Apparently has good leadership qualities too. Hardly a spud.

Very interesting, Luke Darcy certain that Lynch is to Collingwood... Eddie not too happy sounding, maybe trumped.

http://www.triplem.com.au/melbourne/sport/afl/news/blog/quinten-lynch-heading-to-collingwood/20121001-hb1a.html

Silly season is here at last.

its been here a while...at least a month !!

EOS... School holidays.... Idiots/TROLLS/bored let loose with a kb... recipe for ....umm... well this kind of thread actually !!

But how could that possibly be true???? I thought we were sitting on our hands and not putting any effort into getting players to the club, just like the OP said.

yeah that's what everyone seems to think

Unless the club say that they have not offered him something then i don't think you can say that!

Just the player the Demons need, out of contract at the perfect time. Yet our club sits around doing nothing while an already strong Freo looks to get even stronger. We could offer way more money then Fremantle.

What the hell is going on down at the MFC?

Just the player needed? Are you serious?

There's already more than enough inconsistency and erratic on the list.