I say yes

Both cant get game time at WCE

Both are best mates

Bring Them to Melb

Is this just your fanciful thinking, or have you heard something?

On second thoughts, silly question.

This is going to be great - if perchance we win a game next year will any of the players actually know the club song ?

Would love both of them.... however this is not reality.

I actually have heard a few rumours

They are both in the fashion industry owners of https://www.facebook.com/kluminaticlothing and looking to move it to Melbourne as in the CITY

Both handy players.

Lets make a play for them

Is this just your fanciful thinking, or have you heard something?

On second thoughts, silly question.

It's that time of the year. People sit around at work and do nothing but make up trades and then post them as if it's the greatest deal anyone has ever heard of. 1% of them will make any sense or be a fair trade for both teams. The other 99% will be "Ricky Petterd for GCS Pick 2, get it done Demons!" or a trade that is so grammatically incorrect with horrendous spelling that you can't understand a word of it.

Lets make a play for them

Let's! What time are we meeting?

It's that time of the year. People sit around at work and do nothing but make up trades and then post them as if it's the greatest deal anyone has ever heard of. 1% of them will make any sense or be a fair trade for both teams. The other 99% will be "Ricky Petterd for GCS Pick 2, get it done Demons!" or a trade that is so grammatically incorrect with horrendous spelling that you can't understand a word of it.

You"re so right

I bet Josh Kennedy and Ben McGlynn for Draft picks No. 39, 46 and 70 sounds crazy and grammatically incorrect if you look at it now .

What else is there to do at work??.

You just must of had a bad day at work champ.

You"re so right

I bet Josh Kennedy and Ben McGlynn for Draft picks No. 39, 46 and 70 sounds crazy and grammatically incorrect if you look at it now .

What else is there to do at work??.

You just must of had a bad day at work champ.

I love irony.

So you're not interested in Jack Viney as FS with our 2nd round draft pick?

The fact here is the bloke who started this thread would rarely have seen these two blokes play. So how the hell would they know if they are any good!!

Big Pass!

Jack Viney will be 2nd round pick.

And, I dont like what i have heard about Koby. Sounds like a [censored]. Not a door one either! If Smith is his friend I would worry about him too. No wonder either cant get a game.

Better out there in my opinion!

So you're not interested in Jack Viney as FS with our 2nd round draft pick?

Exactly right. I'm fairly sure one Jack Viney will be our pick in the 20s

Jesus guys lay off the thread starter..... Just raising a topic of debate.

Even if you think posts are crap or not what is wrong with someone stating their opinion? Or what they would like to see?

It's an oldy but a goody, but if you don't like something, don't read it.

Or better yet, if you have nothing nice to say.........

On the basis we don't have to use pick 3 on Viney, then yeah its a great idea and great move... of course allowing us to pick up Viney in the high 40's. Although are both out of contract this season or are you just throwing wild ideas around?

On the basis we don't have to use pick 3 on Viney, then yeah its a great idea and great move... of course allowing us to pick up Viney in the high 40's. Although are both out of contract this season or are you just throwing wild ideas around?

Ummm...can't trade the pick after bidding.

Is Ash Smith from Vic and has a twin brother Alistair?

Ummm...can't trade the pick after bidding.

Hey mate, sorry I may have got it confused "The nomination of father/son on 5th Oct" prior to trade period.

Say if he is nominated and our next pick is in the mid 20's, does this lock us in to use this pick (prior to the finalized draft list) OR are we allowed to trade it and therefore our next available selection would be say the 3rd round pick.

F/S rule 3:

"If a bid is made, the club that nominated the father-son player must use its next available selection if it wishes to retain its hold on that player. If a club nominating the father-son player declines to match the selection nominated, the club with the successful bid must use that selection at the Draft to select the player."

Can anyone verify this please?

Good call. Swap Smith & Stevens for Morton and pick 45.

My point being this "next available selection", where is this cut off? after the nomination period OR the end of trade period?

cheers

Ash Smith if I remember the right kid, was a rangy winger type mid, with good run & fair skills.

Is he looking seriously to come back?

Hey mate, sorry I may have got it confused "The nomination of father/son on 5th Oct" prior to trade period.

Say if he is nominated and our next pick is in the mid 20's, does this lock us in to use this pick (prior to the finalized draft list) OR are we allowed to trade it and therefore our next available selection would be say the 3rd round pick.

F/S rule 3:

"If a bid is made, the club that nominated the father-son player must use its next available selection if it wishes to retain its hold on that player. If a club nominating the father-son player declines to match the selection nominated, the club with the successful bid must use that selection at the Draft to select the player."

Can anyone verify this please?

If he get past Pick 3 our 2nd Rnd pick will be locked on him.

But that doesn't mean we won't have another 2nd Rnd Pick thru the trade period.

It's that time of the year. People sit around at work and do nothing but make up trades and then post them as if it's the greatest deal anyone has ever heard of. 1% of them will make any sense or be a fair trade for both teams. The other 99% will be "Ricky Petterd for GCS Pick 2, get it done Demons!" or a trade that is so grammatically incorrect with horrendous spelling that you can't understand a word of it.

Just heard Buddy wants to come to us, we could swap bate for him. Wot bout tri get footy baller now soon wen he good not to later wen he no so good animore at doing it footie yes ok.

Just heard Buddy wants to come to us, we could swap bate for him. Wot bout tri get footy baller now soon wen he good not to later wen he no so good animore at doing it footie yes ok.

Bate? He's too important to our structure going forward. Send them Cook, tall forward for tall forward.

Just heard Buddy wants to come to us, we could swap bate for him. Wot bout tri get footy baller now soon wen he good not to later wen he no so good animore at doing it footie yes ok.

Batter Up! Your out!