POLL: Do you want Mark Neeld to remain coach in 2013?

[Range Rover 1,935]

Nail biting.

[bing181 9,194]

Respect for all players is not good. Some are preferred over others ....

You're a few years out of date. If ever there was a "earn your place, no matter who you are", it's Neeld. Bailey never dropped Moloney, Green and Davey. Not even going to start on Daniher.

Poor post.

[McQueen 17,864]

Just watched the coaches office with Robbo and Neeld. I was trying to make out what picture Neeld had pinned up on his notice board over his right shoulder. Pretty sure it's one of the earliest pictures of him and Neil Craig in deep thought at Gosch's paddock.

I wonder if he has a caption on it.

[thaipantsman 180]

Yes such excitement!

You can just feel the solidarity! mmmmm inhale and exxxxhaaaleeee!!! ahhhhhh!

Hang on ... Is that RR peeing at the front gate again!

[Range Rover 1,935]

Just watched the coaches office with Robbo and Neeld. I was trying to make out what picture Neeld had pinned up on his notice board over his right shoulder. Pretty sure it's one of the earliest pictures of him and Neil Craig in deep thought at Gosch's paddock.

I wonder if he has a caption on it.

"What the f...k have we got ourselves mixed up in?"

[thaipantsman 180]

You're a few years out of date. If ever there was a "earn your place, no matter who you are", it's Neeld. Bailey never dropped Moloney, Green and Davey. Not even going to start on Daniher.

Poor post.

Common now boys. Green was Captain under Bailey. I do recall him as a sub?? Bailey at least won a few games . He was hands tied to some point to the extent ..a la the TANK. Thus the need was not as great to drop Moloney. Not sure Moloney should have been dropped under Bailey's reign anyway.

Stop defending Neeld. Let him show something. All agreed apart from RR (who only wants to commit to next year 2013) that Neeld will coach to at least 2014. No sense in bagging out on Bailey or Daniher. Finals were nice under ND so not sure what that's about!! Can recall one Finals game V Crows at the G . UP WHITEY we would chant!! Went close but lost.

If Melbourne plays finals under Neeld will be 2015 or later...new contract necessary and that's too far down the track.

See how we go Sunday. No excuses if we can't beat GC.

[thaipantsman 180]

Heaven forbid someone should come into this club with the balls to take some punishnent. I just wish we had more players like him.

It was Melbourne or Ocean Grove for Neeld. Try to understand this concept. No other club wanted him including Collingwood. Buckley also wanted a clear out.

[binman 42,683]

It was Melbourne or Ocean Grove for Neeld. Try to understand this concept. No other club wanted him including Collingwood. Buckley also wanted a clear out.

I only have the one block, though i have to say posts like this certainly make me consider doubling the blocks. I tend to not read your posts in full thaiman but this being unusually short and sharp i got to the end of it before skipping it.

How on gods earth can you say with such confidence that no 'other club wanted him including Collingwood'. If you have evidence of this please share. If not and it is just your opinion then give us a spell - i mean 'try to understand this concept'? Pleeeease!

[bing181 9,194]

How on gods earth can you say with such confidence that no 'other club wanted him including Collingwood'. If you have evidence of this please share. If not and it is just your opinion then give us a spell - i mean 'try to understand this concept'? Pleeeease!

He has no evidence of anything.

Yet another barrow-pushing poster. The fundamentalists are making this site unappealing, and I visit less and less. Tedious, just tedious.

[titan_uranus 24,975]

This poll confirms that there are 9 idiots on this site.

[old dee 23,781]

This poll confirms that there are 9 idiots on this site.

Only nine!

[thaipantsman 180]

Only nine!

hey Old Dee! Can you ask Rangey what colour Fisherman Pants he wants ? Tell him I'll send him a pair with my love and appreciation of his most informative Polls.

[thaipantsman 180]

I only have the one block, though i have to say posts like this certainly make me consider doubling the blocks. I tend to not read your posts in full thaiman but this being unusually short and sharp i got to the end of it before skipping it.

How on gods earth can you say with such confidence that no 'other club wanted him including Collingwood'. If you have evidence of this please share. If not and it is just your opinion then give us a spell - i mean 'try to understand this concept'? Pleeeease!

ok

[thaipantsman 180]

ok

but you have to answer this bin man.

Why on earth wouldn't Neeld Coach into 2013? Not even media are suggesting he won't?? Very strange.....Again ...Who said he shouldn't and why the ridiculous poll? Isn't his contract end of 2014? It's a chunder poll we call it. RRover panicked!

[Demonsterative 3,020]

Stupid Question!!! And 8 people said 'No'.

Im sceptical of Neeld's ability, but give the man a go. Its un Australian not to!!!!

[binman 42,683]

but you have to answer this bin man.

Why on earth wouldn't Neeld Coach into 2013? Not even media are suggesting he won't?? Very strange.....Again ...Who said he shouldn't and why the ridiculous poll? Isn't his contract end of 2014? It's a chunder poll we call it. RRover panicked!

I have no idea Thaiman, it wasn't my poll. You're right there is no way he's not going to not be at the dees next year and we would have to have a year worse than this one for him not be there in 2014. But if a weeks along time in football a years an epoch.

[machine11 142]

looks like the no's are taking a caining

[Range Rover 1,935]

Hardnut you really should lodge your ballot.

One more vote will get your lads into the double digits!

[Hardnut 327]

Hardnut you really should lodge your ballot.

One more vote will get your lads into the double digits!

I don't believe in polls or contribute to them or search for supporters - you're not friends with the PM are you - she finds a positive in any poll result in some form or another.

[beelzebub 23,313]

This poll confirms that there are 9 idiots on this site.

probably a few more but they couldnt figure out how to vote...

[baysidedave 246]

Seems a few noisy numpties are carpet-bombing the site with anti-Neeld diatribes at the moment.

Let's see what kind of support they have among Melbourne supporters.

Simple yes or no poll.

one more year but there has to be improvement or he can go

[Range Rover 1,935]

one more year but there has to be improvement or he can go

We will improve.

[7-UP 107]

To those 9 people that voted against Neeld, really should watch Coaches office this week.

One of the questions by a fan is how come we seem to win 3 games this season when we won 8 games with our playing list last year? and apparently according to neeld our list is less experience than our list last season, please watch full interview http://www.melbourne...50/default.aspx

Edited August 8, 2012 by Dees

[stinga81 210]

Are the "no's" tanking?

[Devil In Disguise 2,278]

Yes for 2013 & if he fails see ya later & bring back The Reverend.

I want to see us playing finals again even if it is one year in & next out!