http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/valenti-seizes-second-liston-20110912-1k632.html

Shane Valenti won his second consecutive Liston Trophy for best VFL player last night.

I think we should seriously consider giving him an another chance.

Surprised to see Matthew Bate finished the tally as the runner up.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/valenti-seizes-second-liston-20110912-1k632.html

Shane Valenti won his second consecutive Liston Trophy for best VFL player last night.

I think we should seriously consider giving him an another chance.

Surprised to see Matthew Bate finished the tally as the runner up.

Valenti is at his level IMO. Clint Bizkit will disagree.

Needs to play in the guts, it's his only position. Too slow and small to be accountable for an opponent anywhere else on the ground. Perfect for GWS and would do very well there I reckon.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/valenti-seizes-second-liston-20110912-1k632.html

Shane Valenti won his second consecutive Liston Trophy for best VFL player last night.

I think we should seriously consider giving him an another chance.

Surprised to see Matthew Bate finished the tally as the runner up.

Only after we give Simon Godfrey another run.

Valenti is a good VFL player...period.

I am not surprised Matthew Bate was up there.

He has also proven to be a good VFL player as well.

I was really surprised when Valenti was delisted by the Dees. I thought he was ok at AFL level when he got the chance.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/valenti-seizes-second-liston-20110912-1k632.html

Shane Valenti won his second consecutive Liston Trophy for best VFL player last night.

I think we should seriously consider giving him an another chance.

Surprised to see Matthew Bate finished the tally as the runner up.

Your last line should have been ringing alarm bells in terms of the legitimacy of this award in terms of indicating ability transferrable to AFL.

Valenti is at his level IMO. Clint Bizkit will disagree.

Absolutely.

Out: Scully

In: Valenti

That should have Rossy Lyon breaking down the door.

been there done that !! two different worlds.

Not quick on his feet but very quick above the shoulders, gutsy and strong. Holds his ground in the clinches.

I would have him in the team way way ahead of #10, as a clearance mid. He gives his all.

Valenti is at his level IMO. Clint Bizkit will disagree.

I, and many others, disagree as well. But there are just as many who are of the view that Valenti was not good enough. Lets not go over old territory again.

Nasher, maybe you can pin one or 2 of the old threads for others to look over.