NOT EASY BEING GREEN

[Kit Walker 225]

While I would hate to see Robbo wearing another jumper, I would be happy to see him succeed elsewhere. If he doesn't, well at least he can say he tried.

He is not as horribly past it as some seem to think, and in a better side, would be a decent contributor.

It would be interesting to see how he would go in a side like Geelong. Unlike Hawkins and Mooney, he's not afraid of having a shot...

On basically a free transfer, he probably should be considered but I don't think he would be.

[H_T 3,043]

It would be interesting to see how he would go in a side like Geelong. Unlike Hawkins and Mooney, he's not afraid of having a shot...

On basically a free transfer, he probably should be considered but I don't think he would be.

I'm sure Matthew Scarlett might be whispering in Bomber's ear.

If the sides at the top are considering him, he might be traded, unless they were confident he'd get through to late in the PSD.

[beelzebub 23,347]

My understanding is Robbo is efectively out of contract come seasons end.The club cant really have its cake and eat it by not extending an offer and then wanting recompence for any sort of trade. Robbo will walk into the PSD if he wishes to elongate his career. I cant see how or why we would get anything... thats life

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

You cannot begrudge a guy who at 30 wants to continue his career.

You can only query his better judgement.

Had he taken the Dogs offer 2 years ago, he'd still be playing next year ....

But where?? VFL?

He is not as horribly past it as some seem to think, and in a better side, would be a decent contributor.

Sorry he is. His issues are not who is around him so much as the player himself.

[H_T 3,043]

Not again.

[beelzebub 23,347]

Not again.

sit ya self down...get comfy... pie with that beer??

[Jaded No More 68,898]

You can only query his better judgement.

But where?? VFL?

Sorry he is. His issues are not who is around him so much as the player himself.

He's be playing because he'd be contracted, where he would be playing is another matter. The issue here is that at 30, he wants to look after his long term future and you cannot begrudge him that.

You realise that your underhanded, subtle digs at him is no better than the rubbish we had to delete about Wheatley. Just because you are not coming right out and telling us he's rubbish, doesn't mean that the disrespect you are showing him by questioning his talent and judgment is any better.

Pull your head in. If he wants to keep playing, that should not concern you in the slightest. Wish him well and bloody move on. FFS!

P.S.- he has been a great servant of this footy club and gave us many many years of enjoyment. You may no longer be a fan, but how about you afford those who are some time to reflect on his great career instead of cutting it down to shreds. All 3 deserve to be remembered fondly and I find it very sad that grown ups who should know better, are using this opportunity to stick the boot in.

[Scully The Tank Engine 0]

I could see Robbo maybe being useful for a team like Geelong for 1 more year, as they could really do with a tallish player that can convert some opportunities.

I think he was never really able to get full fitness after the achilles injury last year, which may be partly responsible for his poor workrate in games this season.

With a full pre-season, I could see Robbo kicking 40-50 for the Cats next year with all their class. He's kicked 20 this year in 10 in a poor season with mostly awful distribution into the forward line.

If a club in a premiership window is interested in picking him up in the PSD then good luck to him. A fit and committed Robbo is still capable of kicking 50 goals next season in a good side...

[jacey 333]

In: McLean, Rivers, Jurrah, Robertson

Out: Bruce (Wrist), Bail (Quad), Newton (Achilles), Spencer

[Forest Demon 4,681]

Final Melbourne Team

Backs: S.Martin, J.Frawley, K.Cheney

Halfbacks: C.Bartram, J.Rivers, R.Petterd

Centreline: J.McDonald, L.Dunn, C.Morton

Half forwards: B.Moloney, B.Miller, N.Jones

Forwards: N.Jetta, M. Bate, L.Jurrah

Followers: P.Johnson, A.Davey, C.Sylvia

I/C From: T.McNamara, S.Valenti, B.McLean, R.Robertson

Emg: J.Spencer, M.Jamar, J.McKenzie

[Jaded No More 68,898]

In: McLean, Rivers, Jurrah, Robertson

Out: Bruce (Wrist), Bail (Quad), Newton (Achilles), Spencer

The killer ruck duo of PJ and Martin strikes again! :D

Very harsh on young Spencer, but good to see Robbo back for a final farewell tour. With him and Jurrah in the forwardline we might even kick some goals!

[Rogue 585]

Each to their own really isnt it. If a player stil has yards in him..they bully for him ..all power..and good luck. Sadly not al recognise the sign at teh enf of an illustrious walk etc. Personally have no problem with anyone going anywhere, its their life and career. Footy is relativley a short time in the sun so youd be a mug not to try and wring it for all its worth.

Indeed.

Why run a guy down for trying to get another year or years of AFL?

[todd 0]

If you can't get a game at Melbourne now I think you are in big trouble. Buckley you are in big trouble.

McLean and Jamar have been injured for a while so I can't why they shouldn't have a run at Casey.

Hopeful interchange : McNamara, McKenzie, Valenti, Spencer. P.J is still getting a game. What does he have to do to get dropped?

Well If they played PJ in the right position (ruck whole day) instead of him playing full forward and at full back then he would play some good games like he did last year. PJ is a great moblic ruckman and is better then Jamar around the ground but Jamar is a bit better at the ruck contest. I would like to see PJ and Jamar both in the team being number 1 and 2 ruckman they compliment each other.

[titan_uranus 24,993]

Disappointing that PJ gets a game over Spencer. Jamar mustn't be fit enough atm. Nice for Robbo to get a send-off.

[beelzebub 23,347]

might be "show time " for PJ

[Carn dees 108]

I recon robbo will see the year out, round 22 will be his final game for th dees

[Guest JACKtheRIPPER]

Disappointing that PJ gets a game over Spencer. Jamar mustn't be fit enough atm. Nice for Robbo to get a send-off.

agreed,PJ had his chance hes simply not up to it, id play spencer before him.

[Its Miller time 6]

I think PJ is our best option for Freo. Tap work has absolutely no relevance for any player on our list when opposed to Sandilands.

Hopefully he can run around get a few touches and make the big fella accountable.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

He's be playing because he'd be contracted, where he would be playing is another matter. The issue here is that at 30, he wants to look after his long term future and you cannot begrudge him that.

You realise that your underhanded, subtle digs at him is no better than the rubbish we had to delete about Wheatley. Just because you are not coming right out and telling us he's rubbish, doesn't mean that the disrespect you are showing him by questioning his talent and judgment is any better.

Pull your head in. If he wants to keep playing, that should not concern you in the slightest. Wish him well and bloody move on. FFS!

P.S.- he has been a great servant of this footy club and gave us many many years of enjoyment. You may no longer be a fan, but how about you afford those who are some time to reflect on his great career instead of cutting it down to shreds. All 3 deserve to be remembered fondly and I find it very sad that grown ups who should know better, are using this opportunity to stick the boot in.

On the contrary I have continually wished him well and recognised his career achievements.

I have never questioned his desire to keep playing. Just that he is no longer good enough and he cant see that. He is not the first player and I have evidence others.

Spare us the childish melodrama. You're once more off the mark, trivial and completely two faced in your judgements. Shouldn't expect much more than that on past form. Good grief.

Your acidic condemnation of players like PJ makes your overblown defence of your protected species laughable and ridiculous. But you would be the last to see that as usual.

[LITTLE STINGA 1]

The killer ruck duo of PJ and Martin strikes again! :D

I think we are still tanking. Bartram's gonna play on Pavlich.

[LITTLE STINGA 1]

I think PJ is our best option for Freo. Tap work has absolutely no relevance for any player on our list when opposed to Sandilands.

Are you kidding? You didn't watch last year's game at the g. You have to smash into Sandilands so he doesn't tap it to anyone he likes, Jamar does this well. We may as well have Valenti in th ruck instead of having PJ prancing around playing like a pounce.

[Its Miller time 6]

Are you kidding? You didn't watch last year's game at the g. You have to smash into Sandilands so he doesn't tap it to anyone he likes, Jamar does this well. We may as well have Valenti in th ruck instead of having PJ prancing around playing like a pounce.

Sandilands is going to win the taps regardless of whether we put Valenti or Jamar agianst him. Its up to the midfielders to make sure it doesn't go to advantage.

PJ picks up more possessions around the ground than Jamar which is why i think he can be more dangerous. Sure some of his possessions are more dangerous to us than them but what can i say i still like PJ and hope he can turn it around.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Sandilands is going to win the taps regardless of whether we put Valenti or Jamar agianst him. Its up to the midfielders to make sure it doesn't go to advantage.

PJ picks up more possessions around the ground than Jamar which is why i think he can be more dangerous. Sure some of his possessions are more dangerous to us than them but what can i say i still like PJ and hope he can turn it around.

Bstars is right about playing Sandilands. Make him hurt for every tap which makes him slower and less agile as the game wears on. PJ trails Jamar by a mile ATM.

[Jaded No More 68,898]

Your acidic condemnation of players like PJ makes your overblown defence of your protected species laughable and ridiculous. But you would be the last to see that as usual.

Nobody is a bigger hypocrite or player condemner than you, and I doubt you would have a clue about whether Robbo can or can't go on. You may have wished Robbo well, but you've then decided to undermine your well wishes with telling us all that he is practically delusional for thinking he can go on, when in fact you'd have no clue.

Branding me melodramatic does nothing to suggest that your opinion is anymore worthy.

But hey, let's not waste our time here. You will obviously continue with your underhanded, passive aggressive, narcissistic remarks towards both players and posters since you are a protected specie on this site, and I will have to continue to ignore you.

[DemonDan... 77]

He's be playing because he'd be contracted, where he would be playing is another matter. The issue here is that at 30, he wants to look after his long term future and you cannot begrudge him that.

You realise that your underhanded, subtle digs at him is no better than the rubbish we had to delete about Wheatley. Just because you are not coming right out and telling us he's rubbish, doesn't mean that the disrespect you are showing him by questioning his talent and judgment is any better.

Pull your head in. If he wants to keep playing, that should not concern you in the slightest. Wish him well and bloody move on. FFS!

P.S.- he has been a great servant of this footy club and gave us many many years of enjoyment. You may no longer be a fan, but how about you afford those who are some time to reflect on his great career instead of cutting it down to shreds. All 3 deserve to be remembered fondly and I find it very sad that grown ups who should know better, are using this opportunity to stick the boot in.

So we're frowning on people that bag out players now.. nice!

Beautifully said jaded. Good luck to all 3 boys in their future endeavours.. stay close to the club!!

Hey Rhino,

You're THE KING OF CHILDISH MELODRAMA! Oh Dear!

The way you speak about Robbo throughout the threads.. Well your true colours shine thru. Oh Dear!

Oh Dear Rhino..