manny100

Agree, no doubt his manager has been talking to the Power and the Crows. Contracted to 2026 so we would want better than the pick 28 we gave for McAdam. ANB has given his all to our club and he will be a great get for another club.

Pick 28 for McAdam. I would say given ANB's consistency we would do better.

ANB has been a great clubman and player for us. Now it's all about maximising our return. We paid a 2nd rounder for McAdam and ANB is way better Imo.

Straight swap for Houston?

ANB plays a tough role and is under rated IMO. He will be very hard to replace. Straight swap for Houston if ANB really wants out. Houston is a good player but does not play the high pressure role that ANB plays.

Jeffersen for Melks

That is a good reason we need to use our earlyish 1st rounder and back in we get another A Grader.

Damm, meant Nathan Jones on commentary. I knew someone would be on the ball and pick it up. Cheers

IMO the best thing out of last night was the performance of Petty and Turner. Both ventured high and impacted. Good to see Turner taking a few marks and getting hands on a few ground balls. If Jeffo comes in and becomes a regular then Turner may go back if required. According to Nathan Brown Kolt is rated very high internally. Give him a pre season or 2 and he should be really good. Like to see more of Riv and McVee in the mid.

Zero hanger reports Nth Melbourne making a bid for Jack Viney.

Its game playing ATM. No way we give up an early 1st rounder. The MFC would clearly understand that. We may split our early pick. May was traded for a pick 6.

Dan plays well at HB. A pick early to mid 20's at best for a 28 year old HB.. Spending 1st rounders on 28 year old HB's a few years before Tassy comes in borders on stupidity. ANB is a way better player and does it in tougher field positions. Would you expect 2 1st rounders for ANB? Just some perspective.

Take TMc, B Brown, Melks and Tommo out and it will reduce the age factor a fair bit. None of the above are now guns. Probably BB and maybe Tommo or Melks out? We are definetly going thru list/AFL side churn with a lot of younger players getting games this year. Jeffo still waiting in the wings with big wraps on him. The issue is whether the new kids are as good as the guys they replace? Also are we developing young players that will be elite to replace our mid aged elites? That is why I would prefer we retain our 1st round pick this year. Dan Houston will finish up around the same time as some of our current elites. We ideally want players who will replace them in due course.

I doubt Jeffo will get a game this week. Goody hinted he is close but also hinted Taommo will get a gig in May's place. Plus a 1st gamer KPF up against an in for PA. Tough. If we lose this week and can't make the 8 and he plays well in the VFL i think he would be a reasonable chance to come in against GC. The club would constantly be the VFL players on where they stand etc. so Jeffo would firmly know where he stands.

Port are just posturing. Perspective required. Geez, we got pick 13 plus a future 1st round pick from Freo for Jackson. We just got lucky Freo had a [censored] season and we got an early 1st rounder. Jackson is a young "generational player". With respect as Dan is a good player he is really at 28 years old next season and a flanker not worth more than a mid to late 1st rounder. " Fremantle have secured generational talent Luke Jackson in a blockbuster trade with Melbourne, sending two first round selections to the Demons plus a swap of later picks. As well as Jackson, Fremantle receive picks 44 and 67 in exchange for pick 13, Fremantle’s 2023 first round pick and 2023 second round pick."

May likely out for season, same ribs broken twice = extended time out. Might sneak back in against Maggie's last round. Petty to defence. Either McAdam or Jeffersen to come in. Draft mid this coming draft. Get a big preseason into Jeffersen and persevere with him next season. Get a big preseason into Pwtty and Oliver. Perracca back next season.

Its probably been mention a hundred times but perspective sees that the bullies in this for are going to beat most. A reminder of our best in 2021. Looks like we are done now for this year. I hope we use our 1st rounder on a kid. No trades. With Tassy getting closer i note with our young players coming in we are preparing for the Tassy draft pick drought to come . Maybe we will be adding Yze and Mentha this draft as well. 2025 wee might see Kalani White F/S and an Academy tall.

I have seen Jeffersen play and he hits the packs hard going for marks and gets around the ground pretty well. I think he will make AFL for sure. Not saying he will be a Cameron but i reckon when he gets going he could hold his own against Port's Marshall and even if he goes really well the over rated Kings. I am pretty bullish on what Jeffersen is capable of.

Great report. Some superlatives through the summary. showed great speed and composure under pressure His silky skills, pressure acts and decision making were all features Mentha showed great pace If he continues that form we may have to cough up a pick in the 40's.

If Jeffersen comes up next year we have Petty or Turner to go back.

If he continues that form he looks like a lateish pick. I expect Yze to be a very late pick or rookie. Should be a few spots available on the list.

Since when is a medium half back worth 2 1st rounders? Its just huff and puff stuff. He is likely 27 years old or thereabouts. He is good and can play most medium positions but 2 1st rounders - no way. We got Landon who is a gun for pick 22 and he was way younger. The question is do we go to the draft with a reasonable pick this year or do we already have enough kids coming through and a lack of quality players around 27 years old. I think we have heaps of kids coming through and probably need a good quality experienced player coming in. Rivers looks like stepping up to a mid role on a permanent basis so a spot for an experienced half back opens up. Rivers plays above his age. I think its probable we will make a play for Houston or someone of that quality to complement our younger players coming through.

When any team gets beaten they look slow. We do have some quick players. Some of these are young and will only get better if not quicker - the names of our speedsters have already been mentioned

Good post, posters need to be mindfull that some unthoughtful repetitive scathing comments can have unwanted harmful effects on players. Choice of words is a precious commodity.

He looks huge for a bottom ager. AFL body like JVR on drafting for sure. Lets hope his footy matches JVR.