Grimseyisgod

judging by that picture, i take back anything i said as i was oblivious. We'll pass, he'd be good for Carlton though.. they love those players and collingwood

you should not cop it for that comment. Alot of people sit on here waiting for arguments. That is a fair comment, nothing that Mark Neeld has done (except for Mitch Clarke) has proved to be a match winner. I mean we won 4 matches for the year and 3 of those 4 were again new sides. Although i like Neeld's grand plan (what it appears to be) we do not know. So good on you!

is it possible to work someone into becoming one? personally i think it is, but what do you think?

Maybe we can work out a deal :ph34r: Ben Jacobs x2

I actually so agree. There is no way in hell that Scully is worth what we got for him. Than the fact they backed it up and didnt take Toumpas is a joke, he's a freak! from what i've seen. We are so going to make them eat their words. Although Scully is a gun and will progress probably into something really good. What we got is better

we should rookie list him. Get Neeldy down his throat. He might potentially be worth the risk.. although we dont usually do great with Aboriginals (wona, Jurrah), granted Wona was a different issue. Just cant secure the good ones. Lets give him a go i think

Neeld would like the fact he worked on his tackling and defensive pressure , no surprises we picked him up

From what ive read of him, he sounds pretty good!

It seems as if there may be a small array of players to get. Wines, Toumpas potentially, O'rourke? Plowman? Menzel? I know we all had our hearts set of Wines, but it is as clear cut as we think?

you're a shmeg. He played great footy in 2011, for about 8 games in a row. and a solid 5-10 this year. clearly wasnt cut out as a forward so that slowed down his development. Perfect half back, Goddard here we come

the picture of the the "I" in team, sums up Col's attitude while he has been at Melbourne

I am hopeful and confident that Watts will not turn into a Colin Sylvia. So Much potential.. Lets go Jack! massive season

I belive the definition of people like that is "keyboard warriors"

+1 The fact that people got into Trengove this year is a joke. He was actually pretty good. Sylvia did also show some good patches in the middle of the year

Lets be honest, half a dozen is about right. If he doesnt brake out again

Could be an awesome fivesome. Wines, Trengove, Viney, Jones and Grimes #fingerscrossed

Becuase i am not sure where i read it, but Wines has exceptional disposal and i read that it was his speciality. But i think im just comparing apples with apples

I actually think Wines is a tad better. But who cares, if we get both.. Cannot wait for the "explosions" that are going to eventuate between these two guns out of the centre. Gives me shivers down my spine

I agree that one of the downsides with Sylvia is that he should be leading. I think that you are talking out of your other end because players like Joel Selwood are not the players that they are without the supporting cast. You cannot judge Sylvia when he has never really ever had a star to shadow. Because i am sorry, we havent had a star midfielder in so long i cannot think. Colin with a good supporting cast can become a leader.

I think Colin could seriously become a really good player if he actually gets an opportunity with a half good midfield around him and a good supporting act

do you think we shouild be going to pick him up? or do you reckon well miss our chance?

I think all of you are pretty harsh on Colin. Almost everytime he gets the footy, i feel as if something positive is going to happen. I believe that with some consistency, Colin could bring his game to the next level in 2013, setting himself up for a HUGE 2014

you asked me to find 3 games. implying that he wouldnt have put 3 good games together.

I see we have a keyboard warrior here. Why would Neeld bring in experienced players if he didnt want to make finals as soon as possible?

Atleast he put it together once thoughand won something huge?