Grimseyisgod

JACK VINEY IS OFFICIALLY A MELBOURNE PLAYERR!!!!!!!!!!! WOOOOOOOO source: Melbournefc.com.au

if he hates us that much... well than maybe not

I reckon Melbourne could atleast match or outdo the offer Brisbane have given him

Footballnation.com.au according to them MELBOURNE WILL select Jack Viney with their 3rd pick

and has about as much consistency as Richmond

also has shown consistency this year in the second half of the year..

dont think there is even a chance we are looking at him. Would be a horrible pickup anyway, so inconsistent and shows in patches what he can do

It would really make me happy if we could sign and secure Clinton Young in the red and the blue next year and the years to come. Young's left boot is a real highlight and i know he would fill the gap at Melbourne that Davey used to do, the person where you give the ball to, so they can hit the target spot on. Young is a silky left boot, reads the game well and i think with some more hard discpline under Neeld could really star for us. I understand the match he played in the Grand Final wasnt his best one, but neither did Roughead and Cyril Rioli, doesn't mean he isn't a potential gun. Melbourne could benefit a lot from Young ... and would fit perfectly on our half back flank.

The mini draft cant enable us to get Viney at pick 26. With the mini draft it is still counted as using your first round pick on a player. Example: we have pick 3 and go for Martin. GC nominates Viney pick 2. We lose Viney, because we used pick 3 on Martin

As much as i would love to see Melbourne getting him... i just cannot see it happening

just imagine what Colin could do with a full pre season. Sylvia is one of the only players at Melbourne who can completely singlehandedly bring Melbourne into games. NOT THE ONLY ONE, but one of the few that have that ability. Others include Mitch Clark, Jack Grimes, Nathan Jones and Sam Blease. Hopefully Trengove develops into that

Remember something.. Although Jack wants to come to Melbourne with his heart.. if he lets GWS or Gold Coast take him, we (melbourne) will not be forgiven. Jack will not do everything to get to Melbourne... we wants to prove what his worth, because Jack is competitive

Not only would it be a disaster if we lost Sylvia or traded him.. it was seriously put Melbourne fc behind the 8 ball. If Melbourne are going to make finals or vie for a premiership in the next 2-4 years.. Sylvia willbe heading that up in my opinion

its becoming very clear to me that we are going to take him.. we cannot pass this one up.

If we were to trade Sylvia, i would cry. In my opinion, in Melbourne's top 3 players and when on his game, top 10 in AFL. unless we no joke traded our pick 13 and Sylvia for Pendlebury, i wouldnt be happy

i think that Weller would be a good pickup. I cant even understand why he isnt getting a game at Gold Coast. Hopefully we pick him up.. id be really pleased. maybe Martin for weller

DAWES and WELLINGHAM will most likely cost us pick 4.. there are rumours circulating from that (source: social media) That is if we are willing to give up pick 4. Brynes comes for free My next say is that Martin to collingwood for 2nd round pick. Rivers and Moloney for compensation picks. Viney is only a maybe to take pick 3. I have been edging further and further away to thinking melbourne will take Viney with our first pick. but i dont believe we will get Wellingham

He is a very very good player. regardlesss of his gf performance, would be top few at the dees

are you sure that Viney is worth his pick? I mean that Pick 3 is VERY HIGH. personally i would take Viney pick 3 and than go and take Nathan hvorat pick 4

YES DEMONS!!! lets go Caddy!!! hopefully we can secure him and Wellingham (:

i think that we should take a good look at Clinton Young? unrestricted agent. offer him some dolep, he would dominate in red and blue

As much as that is ridiuclous (that Bartel can be paid the same as Moloney) its the way it needs to be, because it can enable players to go to other clubs for more money

I am very happy to hear and see this. If Cale wants i will pack his locker for him and arrange the flight or bus to where ever he goes. Thank you Cale for a complete waste of a top 5 draft pick. In all your years at the club you put on next to no bulk and showed the workrate of a peanut. Whoever he goes to, i apologize in advance.

Those points are slightly fair. The salary cap itself makes it not like the premier league

Mark Neeld said so in an interview, was from Melbournefc.com.au