Diamond_Jim

Thank you Drunkn on so many levels. I was lucky enough to meet you at a VFL match and like Dec with his football you with your heartfelt postings have enriched all our lives. Please don't be a stranger and enjoy the journey. When the time is right share a little of Dec's life post MFC. To you both and the family... best of luck

The appeal question is an interesting one. Not really sure. When DRS first came in I thought it made the batsman's role harder as it removed the concept of benefit of the doubt that used to be given to the batsman. Must say I do wonder how they can get the algorithms for ball height and spin right on day one when they have no empirical data for a particular pitch with variable weather conditions.

This is good. Straight through the PSD and #$^& Freo. AFL have done us over by giving GCS a priority pick so it's time to play hard.

restricted free agency does not involve compo picks. It gives GWS the right to match any offer made by another club. The idea is good but Whitfield will have the pick of the comp if he wants to leave

yep... in the sense that four is better than two and then trade their high second round pick for a player

perhaps but as an aside and following the logic on this thread why wouldn't you split them for two more etc etc Brings back memories of Sylvia and McLean not to mention the dynamic duo of Scully and Trengrove

No... one will go to GC and one will go to a power club who will trade a 28 year old to GC and get salary cap relief at the same time. You have to love this game.

Not impossible for every ball to be reviewed automatically in the bunker. Cricket is not a fast game so you would only be one or two balls behind. Effectively that is how VAR works in soccer but admittedly there are far less VAR possibilities. It will never happen as India who control world cricket are massively against DRS.

Remember this is just the start... The CEO of GCS was interviewed on this subject mid year and he was saying they needed systemic preferential treatment. Priority picks and then salary cap relief (think COLA) so they can keep their players. Given that its AFL money which pays the salaries this is so ironic. Plus they have asked for NT to be their exclusive zone/academy.

okay... who is our 27-28 year old player who is paid very well that we could move on in such a trade. Essendon have Hurley for example and I am sure we can go through each of the power clubs and list similar players. Even our magnificent crop of youngsters...Oliver Brayshaw and Petracca are being questioned. Last years draft does not look like world beaters. May and Lever are well they're May and Lever and one could go on. 2020 is a BIG year.

made this point on the trading thread. Over there they seem to think splitting the pick is the smart thing. I think its the dumb conservative move.

and so they take a mature player that a big power club or a GWS can afford to move on and the power club gets salary cap relief and a chance to refresh at the pointy end of the draft. Is it any wonder the power clubs dominate. Ripples and flow ons

didn't work too well with Tyson and Salem v Josh Kelly. It's the conservative approach for a desperate team which as usual we are. Frankly we have known for a long time that we will be picking in the top ten so there is no excuse for not having a very detailed plan going forward. The fact that we have pick 2 or 3 should make it easier

Wants to leave GCS could he fit in and what is the price? https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-trades-2019-gold-coasts-jack-martin-set-to-ask-for-a-trade-this-week-with-six-victorian-clubs-interested/news-story/0624c46a1dfcfd5ae19177dd54687d94 several clubs reported as interested in him

Oliver needs to kick more. Wasted season development wise for him. If we had some depth I would have played him on the hff post bye just to develop his kicking game.

well that was a bit of a let down

The Night King has delivered better on asecondwatching

I'm heading off to watch the battle against the Night King on G of T for the second time. Never know they may turn the lights on. Shall I return to hear the sweet song of victory?

yeah !!!!!!!!!!!!!

Must confess that I was open to having Scully back on the basis of minimum pay and a one year deal which is what I understand Hawks paid. Okay he didn't star but he was a very useful player. We took KK instead as our project player and well..............

That's the unknown... they were on a third day wicket yesterday and it didn't look like deteriorating for at least the first two sessions today. By that time it could be game over for us. Definitely need one if not two wickets in the first hour

Big "if"

Jake Lever well what can you say... I suppose he came back from his ACL but his AFL form was ordinary. Probably should have had one or two more runs at VFL level on his comeback. Expecting a lot more in 2020 if he is to justify his salary and trade price. Jury well and truly out.

played 6 games for the year at 27 years of age. Big question mark with him for 2020

nah... we don't review and /or look back