jacey

haha. The victors team song will be drowned out by the oppostion singing their own theme.

what a load of bull. It will be forgotten within 2 seconds when they wheel out Kruzer, Palmer, Selwood, Murphy, Gibbs, Kennedy, Simpson, Waite, Fisher, Carrazzo, Walker to their next press conference.

Correct. Cotchin, Morton and Ebert are all worthy of pick 2. Masten, Palmer are also very exciting and worthy to be pick 4. But having Ebert, Bellchambers & Pears or Morton, Greenwood & Simpson running around in the preseason is that much better then having just Ebert and Pears or Morton & Selwood.

short sighted. Rather 5 minutes with Megan Gale then marrying Jennifer Hawkins.

More like White doesn't tap. He just thumps it forward. White does not feed our midfielders.

Anyone who considers White in the top ten ruckmen are seriously deluded. He's ineffective in the ruck and gets ragged doll. He is effective around the ground but he does pick up a few cheap possesions cruising by looking for a handball. He's a ruckmen so provide contest downfield rather then looking for the cheap possessions. I'm not calling for him to be dropped or delisted as i do believe his got talent and got something to offer but not in the ruck or fwd line. belzebub59 is right. the lad tries but just isn't big enuf to go with the big boys.

As much as we need a ruck coach, we are in more desperate need of a RUCK. It's time Jeff for u to go and play a KPP in the backline or have a crack as a pure midfielder. Jamar and PJ must take full responsibilties now. C'mon Riley. Show some adventure and maybe we could solve two problems in one go.

Geelong: B: Milburn, Scarlett, Harley M: Green, Neitz, Robertson Green to play a more defensive role but has the ability to hurt Milburn on the scoreboard. HB:Enright, Eagan, Wojinski M: Newton, Bate, Davey Newton and Bate to play the CHF role. C:Mackie, Bartel, Corey M: TJ, McDonald, Bruce McDonald and Bruce to play a run with role. Bruce n JMac will rack up them up anyway. HF: S.Johnson, Mooney, Chapman M: Whelan, Carroll, Bell F:N.Ablett, Ottens, Stokes M: Rivers, White, Wheatley White to play a KPP in defense. CHB role. Will suit Ottens more then Mooney. R:King, Ling, G.Ablett Jamar, Mclean, Bartram Ling will go to Mclean cause he is our best midfielder. Jamar and PJ to take the rucks and Bartram gets first dibs as a tagger. B:Blake, Selwood, Kelly, Hunt M: PJ, Jones, Dunn, Sylvia E: Frawley, Yze, Moloney, Petterd.

My 22 v Carlton. B: Miller White Bode HB: Garland Warnock Neville C: Brown Ward Wheatley HF:CJ Newton Pickett F: Bizzell Carroll Ferguson R: PJ Buckley Godfrey B: Jamar Sylvia Dunn Weetra

No lasting damage. If Maggies run with that argument, they will be thrown out faster then u can say Ben. U can't wait for someone to get severely injured b4 throwing the book at him. As for the Carroll's leg doing the damage (some maggies really do believe that) - It's like being hit by the bus and then being run over by a toy car. - Hughesy. Should have been intentional. U r lucky bEn and if ur smart, u should just cop ur medicine.

6 weeks with a early plea. U made a mistake and u will serve your time. Just cop ur medicine.

I think there's no point. Having Neitz and Chook as co captains looks weak. It makes us look indecisive as we want Chook as captain but we aren't so sure so we split it down the middle. Either bite the bullet and make Chook captain or let Neitz have one more year. I'm not in favour of interm captains. It's all the way or not.

Teams target these playas to let them loose. Godfrey, Holland, Ward, Brown, Miller. Even one of the Saint boys admitted it. We let them get the ball.

Keep in mind, Jamar looked promising last year and did squat all first half of the year. Give him first ruck and tell him to get to as much contests as possible. Give him the responsiblity. Jamar and PJ must ruck in tandem. And STOP playing White in the ruck for the love of god. Play him as a tall midfielder or CHB. He gets ragged doll too easy.

Why do ppl even respond to him. Brock however has a problem where he tries to do too much and gets caught. Sometimes u just gotta kick it. His work ethic and attitude will see him through. Neita will go on next year but i still have him next in line.

I know it already. All 18 of the Blues to line up in their forward 50. Pagan's Paddock in reverse.

We do need to keep a few as depth but the real problem is we have too many depth playas on our list and not enough of the "best 22 playas". Cut them. Reality bites but we can't win with depth playas playing 22 rounds.

With their future superstar Pendlebury out and Swan carrying an injury, we will win the midfield easily. Scott Burns can't carry them forever.

WE have too many depth playas. They need to be cut 6 of these depth playas. Bizzell, Brown, Ferguson, Godfrey, CJ, Miller, Neville, Ward, Warnock, Wheatley, Pickett, Holland. Bizzell's gone. Dropped when he wasn't playing bad doesn't bode well. Brown's gone. Sorry. Ferguson gone. I know Rhino doesn't agree but IMO MFC are playing him in hope someone will trade for him. Has played pretty good so far. Why else would Ferg be playing? Rhino. Neville gone. Holland/Warnock? One will go Wheatley. Safe barring trade. Pickett. ?. The ball's in his court. He needs to make a convincing case. Ward/Godfrey/CJ. One, prob 2 will go. Miller. ?. Trade or keep. Will be on a AFL list only for the pure fact his KPP.

His had a good couple of games but i just hope to god MFC are just playing him so other clubs can have a look at him and get suckered in into trading for him. The boy can play but he's a third floating tall and we've got plenty of them. Rivers numero uno. No strength as a KPP.

When we draft Shane Valenti. Foley's a gun.

I'll lay off for the week but ur wrong deeboy. Congrats Whitey for 250 and ur career.

what's with the love affair with Ryan Murphy. I haven't seen much Freo play but he hasn't exactly set the world on fire this year. He was brilliant in the finals against us but grgic's also played some good games against geelong and was then traded to them. Mcdougall's also played a few good games n was a top draft pick too so is Murphy that good or is he overrated cause he killed us.

White is worthless come trade time. I wanted to traded White the last 2-3 years where clubs like St Kilda, Sydney, WB would have given up their first round draft pick for him. Everyone can see him struggling against bigger ruckmen and with his age, his values gone. Bruce n Johnstone will still attract mid - low first round draft picks. Do the deal for one of them. Green to stay DEF cause we won't get better then 2nd round draft pick. Symes, Byrnes, Woods would be good pick ups.

A big fat NO. Neitz's still got plenty in the tank but he's made to look worse atm by poor delivery. Captain for the next year n Brock's ready to roll. Jones, Bate and Rivers to deputy.