thaipantsman

Big Call Fat Tony. Not possible now after signing? Jamar is a little overrated. Very slow. If you can arrange this we'll do it. Spencer and Gawny with back up from Martin and Clark IMO is best.

how many bags of goals did Al Jacovich kick before he was eventually selected in the ones?

nO! thanks

Sellar is Rubbish seriously! Would rather see Leigh Williams given a crack

I would like to see us roll the dice a little. Must balance between rolling the dice of form. very sad about Bennell. Is Grimesy injured? Outs: Bennell, Grimes (if injured), Jamar. Ins: Watts, Jetta(if permitted re the Couch selection), Jurrah even with a sore leg! Moloney Martin to Ruck on all night!!!!! How bout giving Leigh Williams a Crack?

How true! The more you all keep crying highlights just how bitter you still are. Why constantly bag out on a 20 yo kid that took 6 mill. Melbourne were always going to be a basket case under Neeld and he could see that.

Mr Curry you are a very bitter Man! Much prefer playing under Sheedy than in this pathetic rabble called MFC.

Hi Face your Demons, Yourself and many other in this forum need to step back and judge from an unbiased viewpoint. In other words come into the real world. Tired of hearing " oh if only we played 4 quarters" "ran out of legs". Fact is Freo played ONE quarter and won easily. Melbourne were always average. Consistently kicked Out on the full under Neeld's "Collingwood Model". No rudder, no leadership and going nowhere. Melbourne are worse off now than way back 66, 67 and 68. Daniher and Bailey were far more superior to the current Coach who by the way will not Coach into 2014. He will not succeed next year. Not his fault. Blame and shame on Lyon for giving him the job after a Late with Malthouse. The Guy is a great Suburban Coach and not in the Calibre of Malthouse or Buckley. Thank heavens for GC and GWS otherwise we would be absolute rock bottom. Anything but a win v PA is not acceptable and nor should it be. The Grimes/Trengove Captaincy set up is laughable along with leaving Rivers our best defender at FF all day. So depressing!...Yes and Save the injury excuses!!

Ditto Sylvia is a match winner and a class act. also noted Moloney was easily BOG today v Bendigo.

Straight in!! 94K and a good swap for Marely Williams

Magner or Moloney. Hope Magner stays in only because of my Super Coach prospects. Bennell?

sadly this is true

are you guys all on lunch break or what? Calm down Jose!

Neitz and Robbo very differento as well!! Clark fits the Neitz mould with the added bonus of playing ruck. Howe fits the Robbo mould (coming soon). Agree with comments re Huddo and Lockett add Dunstall Mckenna to that

BUMS ON SEATS! SIGN HIM UP...going to be a star! will cost $ though.

AHHHH, UMMM, BUT UM, SO I THINK ....NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

SCOOP OF THE YEAR!!=JURRAH WON'T PLAY AGAIN.... let's all copy and paste this back to Norm Smith after Jurrah's next game.

and get him in your Supercoach by round 3!

The deals done! He's going to be a Demon stop worrying.

Hei PMan, Clokey's not bad. Remember what we were saying about Clark after Round one? And before that?? Freo is busting arse to get him and Magpies want to keep him...BIG TIME...if he does get to Melbourne next year watch everything turn around. Would suit RR and Neeld's game plan

an ummm, it's about balance. Short and long term. With Free Agency blooding all short term will become a problem because by the time they get good, 3- 5 years they will move to another club offering big$$. This is why we need to consider some mid 25'rs that are good, i.e., Clokey. Why do you think Maggies are busting arse to try to keep him within the cap

Ahhh, by the way, ummmm, thought this was a Garlo thread:) Garlo is a big Guy! Anyone know how big he has to be to go into the ruck...at least once. Have seen Sylvia do it, ummm, and ahhh, um....ammm.., Dunny 'S had a crack, but why not Garlo...ANSWER...=SOFT

and um, and ahhhhh, but um, so ammm, think it should be a great game v Freo.

IMO, Shuey would oF struggled at Melbourne given the lack of dominant good big players to support and give out easy possessions. . Kennedy, Darling, Cox, NicN Lynch...same goes for a lot of the other names bandied around. We had one in Neitz a few years back and now Clark but that's it. Watts is burning IMO> If West Coast had him would be almost bronwlow material by now. Players of the Ilk of Gysberts, Morton Bay, Moloney, Sylvia even Aaron Davey and Bennell would by absolute stars if they played for West Coast.

Hei Bandicoot that's all a little Simplistic. Melb are instructed(game plan) to ignore short passes to corridor and preference longer kicks to a boundary contest. This uncertainty is a large reason for the poor kicking accuracy. All players that make AFL standard can kick very well. Comes down to the coaching , confidence and if that's all good the kicking will be fine. Not sure if you attended the Tigers game? Did you notice Melbourne rarely now handball "over the top" to the loose player. Luke Hodge commented on this. The loose player is wasted. Melbourne kick long as possible to Contest. Did you also notice several Out on the full free kicks against us? So it's more about certainly or uncertainty that leads to the poor kick not necessarily the player is generally a poor kick. Makes sense?