Steve13

Morton has to stay, good size, can find the footy and his disposal will improve as his and the teams confidence grows. Warnock could be and probably will be an exelent full back in an established back line. Once again he lacks confidence. I suspect he will end up at Carlton and will be very valuable. Bate can go, hopefully for a second round pick. Dunn I would keep, showed last year he could be effective as third or forth tall. Sylvia if he wants to stay should be given the chance under a new coach to become the A grader we know he can be. Maric, I like, needs a new coach to give him a rev up and he needs to work harder. High draft choice with alot of natural talent. Worth another year. Bennel is a worry for mine, has showed very little and can probably go. Newton is done, clogged our list for one or two too many years. Aussie should stay, put family issues aside has shown he has all the attributes to be a very handy small forward at AFL leavel. Barty I would keep. (I'm biased I love him, poor kicking and all, always been one of my boys)

Im to tired to deal with a thumping first round of the finals. I have never said this before but i cant wait untill the end of the season, we can start again and leave 2011 behind us. bring on the cricket!!!

Milne Stevie Johnson Crowly

Luke Ball did not want to play at Melbourne, what kind of leader would he have been when he didnt want to be there. Tappy will be a 200+ game star, so fair to say very happy with the decision to take Tappy rather than gamble on Ball.

I would love to see Melbourne have a real look at Brenton Sanderson. Coming from Geelong he knows success and has been close to a senior job a couple of times. We have seen how both Scotts have brought youth and excitement to their respective clubs. Melbourne need new blood with new ideas.

If he goes he's no good, but if he stays he's the next Judd, I'm sick of this sh*t. When he goes and yes I said when, we will be duly compensated, we will be loseing a bloke that has played all of a handful of games and we will get two guys that will be at the same leavel in less than two years. Go or stay this will not make or break our club. Move on and let the poor bloke be.

David Schwatz said on SEN, Melbourne should do every thing they can to get Neil Balme back to the club as the Director of footy. We have seen what a great job he has done at Geelong. Agree?

Im Leader by three in my comp and there is no doubt that you have to pick Carlton. i will be over the moon if we get up, but come on its very unlikely, just quietly Carlton go alright.

Good article, well worth the read. Sounds to me that Dennis would make a good Director of coaching, we have all seen that Geelong has benifited haveing Neil Balm all be it as footy manager being the hard arse who is the face of the tough decisions.

Green should go toe to toe with Judd, he may get beaten but at least we will once and for all find out what he is all about. LEAD FROM THE FRONT or stand down.

Not one of the so called "leadership" group dropped. Great statement "pi*s weak performances are accepted at Melbourne". Nicko dropped?? the only one who went into battle for Dunn when Chappy lost it!!

Jeff being Jeff. Thought it was funny though that he said "Gary should butt out", Is Jeff the pot or the kettle i always mix those two up.

is Worsfold a chance? really?

Here is an ultimatum. Stop baging him or pi*s off. When did we become Essondon and start eating our own. Until he states otherwise he is a Melbourne player and I for one don't partake in this petty bull sh*t.

1. MM 2.MM 3.MM Don't settle and don't stop till we get him.....(may have to employ his wife as an assistant)

I like it. Laidley said he would not coach at another club with poor facilities and poor football department spending, Melbourne has neither of these. Would be a good duo.

Judd will have a massive influence no matter whos on him, let him go. Jordie Mc to Murphy, JT to Simpson and Beamer to go head to head with Robinson. Judd is a champ but he cant do it by himself. stop the others, stop Carlton IMO.

Todd Gary and Jim should dissolve the leadership group now, there are 5 games to go, let the natural leaders come to the fore. take those who rise to the top and present them to the new coach whome ever that is and let him decide. With a new coach on the way no big decisions should be made in regards to the playing group.

All Melbourne suporters and members have Jims best interests at heart, but surley Jim knows Jim best and what ever he dose....stay on, take leave or stand down is Jim decision and his alone. The Melbourne family should stand behind him no matter the decision.

Sorry, just getting sick of the doom and gloom, trying to talk some footy.

How do we get Jeager O'Meara?

with free angency silvia will soon realise that he is not worth as much as some have been saying. if Scull goes we get two first rond picks and if he stays we get scully its win win for the dees. if he dose go two compensation picks puts melbourne in a very strong pozzy to nab a big name during trade week.

Jack was one of the few that actually looked angry last weekend. play him deep alongsid a resting Jamar/Martin!

What would hurt Carlton the most is being crushed by a passionate and hard team that are willing to give anything for the red and blue. And as supporters we should except nothing less.

My 5 Bate, Dunn, Bennel, Maric, and Morton.