durango

A couple of years ago he was asked to look around for another team and there were no takers but now who knows how many might ask the question?

Petty is just now coming into his prime as a footballer so the compensation will mean we have to recruit a replacement of the same quality and age. We should make an offer he cannot refuse.

As MFC has lost Angus Brayshaw he has now stepped up to be the midfielder he was recruited to be.

Don Cordner was 188cm and 89kg which in modern day football would be used as a ruck rover.

I think he is playing more midfield time so he can use his gut running to make more opportunities to get possessions and has improved his disposal.

I would try him as a HBF and maybe he would get more confidence with the ball in front of him rather than trying to lead and turn.

John was only 189 but weight 105kgs, Alan Morrow was 183 and 89kgs.

He has more pace than Robbie and is taller but he has a long way to go to be as good, maybe when he has played over 200 games we can then say Caleb Windsor was a great player in the mould of Robbie Flower.

When I played football in the 1950-60 kicking anyone was punished harshly by the tribunal but we seem to have gone woke on etiquette of the game where brutality and disgusting behaviour towards your opponent is ok.

He is 191cm which in the old days 1950's would have been a key position player not a flanker, I have been impressed by his composure when gets the footy. The MFC backline last week was tall and yet did not lack the speed to keep smaller players in check. He should get a rising star nomination this year.

Norm Smith was always defence whilst Hayfey was attack it always depends on the cattle you have. I thought TMac was very good and his disposal was spot on. Generally our backline players were very good. Players sitting in the rehab group McAdam and Hunter, will put alot of pressure on current group. Fullerton and Petty may be need soon?

I looked at the photo's taken during training and they look much better than the video. His development has been hindered by injuries hoping he gets a good run now.

If he had retired at the end of last season then I think the MFC would have retained Harmes.

If you add both results the Melbourne win by 2 points not the other way around.

Unfortunately injuries play a big part in success in September what would have happened if Brayshaw stayed on the park against Collingwood and Maynard had been knocked out? We will never know since it happened the other way.

At this stage teams talk about making the finals so far only NM and West Coast have not been mentioned therefore early season wins will take on a new meaning as clubs jockey for the place in the 8. All the talk is about how good Carlton and Collingwood are but they forget Brisbane and GWS played in the Preliminary finals, had Melbourne on the other hand scored 2 more goals against Collingwood in the Semi-Final then who knows who would have been premiers?

Pickett is suspended for round zero/one

I have looked at the first 6 rounds and this will setup the whole season because if we get a good start then top 4 will become easier but if we start poorly then it will make it that much harder.

The MFC has tried the 2 ruck system since 2019 with Preuss, Jackson and Grundy. It only worked 2021 when Jackson played one of his best matches in the Grand Final. Both Grundy and Preuss were tried working with Gawn but only worked when Gawn got injured. I understand that we don't have a quality 2nd Ruckman but we will never know how good Fullarton or Schache are unless Gawn gets injured. How many teams can afford a quality Ruckman playing in the 2nd 18's. Our major weakness last year was not getting the quality ball into the forward 50.

I think his downward spiral occurred when they tried him on the HBF.

I just looked at the pictures from training on Friday and was amazed at the change in Sestan's body?

We supporters forget he is now in his 3rd season and has only played 20 games which are very good for such a young player. With another pre-season his fitness should improve and his running capacity will make him a better player this season. I believe we should compare him to the Saints version of Riewoldt (Nick) who was a more aerobic player than Jack.

His body has matured and will put his name forward to be an elite player this season.

I think people forget that Jake Bowey played in the 2021 premiership team on the HBF which means you know who your opponent is unlike a forward/midfielder. Judd worked on his fitness in WA and came back a much improved player because he was super fit, maybe Bailey who also worked on his fitness may do a McVee? I still think AMW will be a surprise packet this year like Bedford?

He has this year to show a lot of improvement otherwise he will be delisted.