demon3165

The answer is simple let Viney go and keep Gus, more upside than Viney.

I can understand the love for Viney but he is a one trick pony if the game is fought in close he goes alright but once the game is played on the outside where he cannot make tackles he is slow as not a great mark, kicking to position not good let him go as a free agent but get him to where he wants to go.

In Gawn out Tmac pretty simple.

Worst coaching from the forward and backline line coaches how come we always start from behind our opponent in the forward line and the backline always kick out to the left we are so predictable it frustrates the hell out of me.

Hell of a call early but the more they play the better they will get.

If this club ever gets it's forward line right Kozzie will be the icing on the cake.

Pert was asked to do a PD review at Collingwood at the request of the Collingwood board that is how the changes began even Eddie acknowledged this on air at MMM and said at the time because of this he left shortly afterwards so lets get this notion of him going rouge out of the discussion.

Would trade Salem, panics, not a good thinker when confronted.

Sorry Red and Blue but Viney is a one trick pony can't kick, mark or run time to him to move on and get the best deal we can.

I agree that Viney is one dimensional lacks depth in his kicking not a big mark and for a so called top midfielder does not kick hit the scoreboard enough the thing is if the opposition plays a similar game (contested) he is all right, when they play a outside game style that is where he fails badly so lets see how he goes.

Absolutely spot on!! well said.

Would like to see Max have it on his own time to give away the co captain idea, last year showed that, Jones did the right thing so should Viney.

Is it my eyes or memory but does Petracca look like he has leaner legs as well as body?

Never thought that we one games at training if you go by training as match standard then we are in real trouble.

Would not be in the best 22 at the top six sides from last year and yes I am a Dee supporter I just don't wear rose coloured glasses.

Well the sky was all rosy last year by your reports and we know how that went as for B&F's 1 best and fairest in 7 years, 35 brownlow votes in 7 years, 31 goals in seven years guess that puts him in the top bracket. Max Gawn 60 votes in 5 years. Clayton Oliver 40 votes in 4 years.

Now if only Viney could Mark, Kick, have a football brain and sprint we could have a good footballer on our hands.....

Here is a position that whoever is the coach is on a hiding to nothing, players kick well gee what a great thing to do, players still miss and who appointed that spud as kicking coach good luck on this one.

Be very helpful to boys at Casey next year and may fill in if we have a few injuries during the year.

Now that I can agree with..

Now that I can agree with.

Oh I do you watch every game......thats my opinion you may disagree and thats ok.

Suggest you watch the north game again then you might have some idea...

Salam is as soft as butter, does not like the hard contest and looks for an easier option even before he gets the ball, Viney is a one trick pony lacks skill and football nouse time to clean out.

Delist ANB, JKH, Stretch, Garlett, Keilty and Jones. Trade Salem, Viney