demon3165

I am in two minds about Brown but the facts are he can kick goals and if they can tweak the game plan and execute, it could work out, Sam and Jackson would the have the second and third best opponents on them which would then bring Pickett in line to clean up up the ground balls so if a deal could get done go for it.

Spot on Cards great post.

The problem with Viney is is not quick and lack of football awareness if his role was one of doing what Harmes did in 2018 he would be a complete liability to the side as for putting him forward well they would just run off him all day.

It wont rip the heart and soul of the club players come and go these days players accept it and fans eventually accept it but lets face it Viney is a one trick pony would sooner develop another player or put Harmes back in the guts and play the role he did 2018.

Viney - pick Carlton, Geelong

Please Viney chose Carlton or Geelong.

That's been happing all year!!!

Post of the day we ask for the club to play pace but play a contested game style have a look how many time Langdon screams for the pill to be switched when he is on his own in the guts but no, lets go down the line quick players have no hope.

Won't be disappointed if he moves take away his tackling and not much is left for a so called A grader that people think he is, but will admit he gave his all.

And that has been different to the last 3 weeks.

Stop blaming the umpires we are a poorly coached club same plan as last week everyone run back and leave the opposition loose to waltz in game should have been over in that quarter, this is just under 10's football.

To help the Weed I would get Nick Riewoldt to have a talk with him have I listened to him explain what he did and how he went about it damm interesting, nothing to lose by doing it.

Who cares that people think Derms a [censored] but gee he was spot on in his comments about us in the first quarter against the swans his comments are usually spot on regarding special comments. Robbo is just a [censored] of a man who just wants to be something important never will be. King is just starting to rely on stats as a conversation football is a lot more than that.

Love him or hate him Dermie is pretty well spot on regarding special comments picked up Melbournes problems in the first quarter maybe Goodwin should have him on speaker in the box cause no one else is telling him whats wrong.

Forgot ANB, Fritsch becoming a very lazy footballer.

Smith is always the whipping boy but Viney and Jones get a pass because he is hard at it and gee we must get him to 300 well that will win us a flag.

Viney, Jones would even drop Salem to make a statement, assistant coaches and Goodwin enough is enough.

I know it's something out of the box but saw him play that role a couple of years ago could work.........

The answer is simple Harmes into the guts as a tagger would have helped last week and Viney out.

We always have problems against sides that play a run and carry with transition movement Eagles, Saints Dogs yesterday etc lets have a look at our kickouts always to the left either a short kick then down the line or long bomb from the goal square nothing changes, lack of leadership from the midfield how many times the dogs just took it away while on the run not one of the midfield try to change anything, forwards always behind their opponent so if a goes in from a contest we are always caught short. If you look at the North game our goal kickers were running in a straight line yesterday Fritsch running in an arc same with Oliver no set routine. Goodwin well is it time to part ways not sure but gee it makes it hard to defend him you could see what was happening in the third but bugger all changes the saints play they same way as the dogs so I hope it does not end up with same result.

I reckon the forward coaching has been really top notch the last 5-6 weeks. Incidentally, I think this occurred after moving Plapp into the forward coaching role. FWIW... Looking at the front on vision of the goals scored it seems that the players are running in on a straight line for their shots on goal perhaps they have listened to Dunstall on goal kicking technique.

The answer is simple let Viney go and keep Gus, more upside than Viney.

I can understand the love for Viney but he is a one trick pony if the game is fought in close he goes alright but once the game is played on the outside where he cannot make tackles he is slow as not a great mark, kicking to position not good let him go as a free agent but get him to where he wants to go.

In Gawn out Tmac pretty simple.