Everything posted by monoccular
-
Tom Fullarton - back up ruck?
kial - do you have a strategy whereby we could keep Brundy and play Max? Our brains trust couldn’t. dice - are you seriously suggesting that we just “give him a go”? Where and for whom?
-
PODCAST: Rd 19 vs Fremantle
Thanks guys for all your hard work in getting these fabulous podcasts together. I just love them after a win, of course; less so after a loss. However I am really looking forward to this one - why does Freo seem to have our number, even previously when we have been playing well? Is it just their pace, run and link that mesmerises our midfield, and completely destroys our usually solid team defence. They seemed to just run it out with someone going past then a forward running well deep of our zone, over and over again. Is their coach some sort of wizard who takes our game plan apart, on a regular basis? Or, perhaps we are just not as good as we have beleived? The past fortnight we did seem to be getting it together and I was starting to subscribe to the loading, training, planning for the July, August, September surge, but it now looks more and more despite my usual optimism that the September part will be irrelevant. When and if September becomes a mathematical impossibility, will we change our plans and drop those who aren't by then committed to 2025 and beyond, and bring in even more young blood? Kynan Brown had an unbelievable number of tackles at VFL and needs time on ground at AFL level. All the youngsters we blooded this year have been more than serviceable. Windsor of course the standout, Howes looks as if he will make it, Kolt was IMO unlucky to be subbed out and has added just so much energy to the forward line, AMW just fits right in. Sestan? Verrall? Not sure about McAdam and Fullarton though. Here endeth my ramble.
-
Petty Re-Signs for 2 Years
He almost certainly will have to do some ruck duties this year. IF TMc stays, then Harrison may remain a swing man. So much depends on how Turner and Jefferson develop as tall forwards as well. But medium to long term he is likely to become our key defender.
-
CASEY: Rd 17 vs Frankston
Just asking - does Bell actually want to play full time AFL? Not everybody does.
-
NON-MFC: Round 19
This is how it will go. "Just a football act" - Michael Christian AFL HQ - "better send him to the tribunal so it will look ok" Tribunal - "3 weeks for the elbow, and one more for the dive" Appeals board - there wasn't an 'and in the right place where the charge sheet was filled out - cleared. AFL - oh, how unfortunate. but at least Clarkson won't be there to take credit An adult worm has exactly 302 cells in its nervous system - by comparison, the human brain has around 100 billion cells. But almost two-thirds of the worm's nerve cells form a ring in the head region, where they make thousands of connections with each other.23 Aug 2023 What worms can tell us about brains and behaviour University of Leeds https://www.leeds.ac.uk › news-science › news › article Should be 3, plus 1 for the staging after see above
-
CASEY: Rd 17 vs Frankston
Thanks. Hopefully there is nobody quite as impartial as Michael Christian deciding these things.
-
CASEY: Rd 17 vs Frankston
Well it is VFL - a very poorly run and administered excuse for an AFL development and support organisation. OMG - will he be suspended.?😮
-
2024 MRO & Tribunal
Except, the AFL in their infinite and unquestionable wisdom, have enabled Cameron, yet again, to escape sanction. What an absolute rabble.
-
2024 MRO & Tribunal
re *1 - two going for a mark, head clash, one concussed (maybe after medical review), the other not concusses according to protocol but off for 10 minutes due to gash on head - no way should either be suspended. That is a genuine footy act and accident, unlike setting up someone who has long disposed of the ball and is wide open. Agree 100% re points 3 and 4 Seriously unable to explain that anomaly??!! 😮😡 Was she also asked to explain how she can remain in office if she can't explain that?? Should have been. I must say I haven't followed her career in any way at all until this post, but she appears to have been a completely Incompetent appointment. Was it DEI??
-
NON-MFC: Round 19
Woke up on a cold windy morning to the sad news 🤣🤣🤣 that the Bombers choked in the dying moments Couldn't have scripted it better. Have they actually beaten a team at the time in the top 8?
- PREGAME: Rd 19 vs Fremantle
-
Wildcard Weekend
If they insist on the “pre finals bye” (which I hate) then maybe 9-18 could play some sort of 9v10, 11v12 etc to fine tune draft positions - with the winners of each pair getting a better pick. see above. On the other hand, it would make top 4 a priority, but 5 and 6 far better than 7 and 8 which could give added incentives. But imagine “we hope to get into the 10” in an 18 (or 😡 19) team competition. Surely falling below the middle of the ladder usually means NQR.
-
2024 MRO & Tribunal
.... and he has never been suspended 🙄 Cameron drove his opponent into the turf: Bedford did not. 3 weeks for Bedford, nothing (once again) for Cameron. Who knows - clearly the AFL, and their lackey (of very limited intelligence) MC does not. I am over the AFL - will watch my beloved MFC but won't watch anything else of their rubbish.
-
Tom Scully
I just looked at his junior highlight reel Is he just a big huge fish in a small pond? I guess one can only play against those who are there. I would be interested in JT's opinions.
-
Tom Scully
Chuckling, or chucking, BBO? If he really is a 203 cm tall marking forward who can ruck, why hasn't he played yet? Maybe he is NQR, apart from his name https://www.easynamechange.com/au/legal-name-change/how-do-i-legally-change-names/#:~:text=Any Australian citizen or permanent,or removing your spouse's name.
-
2024 MRO & Tribunal
Christian is an absolute dud.
-
Trade Targets
Agree 100% re Stringer. Wade Derkson… who knows. Stringer seems to fit the profile you paint.
-
NGA Rule changes mooted
Sure. Until it isn't. Dogs get their man, Suns get Dee's man, Bombers get their man. The AFL are a disgraceful organisation.
-
Trade Targets
Question: does Harry Boyd have any forward craft at all? We are unlikely to run two rucks every week. … and if that was a reason to offer him for trade, who would want him? Yes and no. TMc surely has only one more year in him at most, despite his Lazarus like year.
-
PREGAME: Rd 19 vs Fremantle
Wal - the pose is more like what I would expect from Hemingway - I must say I haven't noticed any of his postings recently. Tholstrup, with his aggression and energy looks pretty safe for at least a few games. He, with Melk, has invigorated the HF area. Dingo - just what do they get right 99% of the time is the big question? Sunrise and sunset times usually pretty close. But up until the last week they have called a lot of rain that failed to deliver. Wind they tend to get close. Temperatures usually within 5 or so.
-
Judd McVee - Future Melbourne Champion
Wasn't it the pre preseason learning running with his grandad at Geraldton that he attributes to his sudden development? He certainly became an immediate lock in selection - great pick up, and great self dedication to his craft. I would an agree a high quality half back who can think his way through and deliver with precision is absolutely essential. Unless AMV (smaller) or Blake Howes cements that spot, or Bowey returns to his best, I would leave him to become a backline leader especially as May and Lever inevitably slow down and move on over the next half decade. I realise he will not replace them as positional players, but he oozes leadership.
-
Tom Fullarton - back up ruck?
Depends on how one actually defines ego. I am sure every successful AFL player has enormous self belief and thinks that they are the or among the best in their rôle. In some it transfers to arrogance which does not appear to be the case in Max. Self esteem vs self importance.
-
Trade Targets
Fullarton and McAdam, and Billings.
-
POSTGAME: Rd 18 vs Essendon
What a precious little twerp - don’t like him and he doesn’t like us, clearly. I asked about the pressure acts in the podcast thread, as I thought that Petty was playing a rôle. Ethan. Brilliant stuff. Thanks. Made my day reading that Beautiful to see - though of course some of the negative Nellies would say that Clarry was sucking up to the coach and that is the only reason he gats a game 🙄🙄🙄😧 The Kozzie 50 was ostensibly after a 5 meter kick was paid a mark, whistle not heard, and not called to stand. Poor umpiring that whole episode.
- PODCAST: Rd 18 vs Essendon