old dee

On this one we are in total agreement Macca.

Sadly I am old enough to remember him well mono. Was nothing flash but then at that time no one at Brunswick Street was much good either. They lost every game from mid 63 till the end of 64. A streak of 27.

I have only one problem where is the replacement money coming from? All I hear is wishy washy comments about increased membership, sale of merchandise and more money from sponsors. All of which is BS that I can see. The only thing that drives those things is winning lots of games, playing one extra game at the G will IMO not drive up funds. We also have trouble winning at the G playing away from the G seems to give a better chance of winning. IMO you could form an argument that playing the extra game increases the chance of a lose which would drive down finances. I understand members want more games at the G but there is a cost of returning the game that everyone is happy to ignore until the profit for 2020 is announced.

RB because we are all human there will always be something to regret. Imagine if a pick at 4,5,6,7,8 or 9 turns into the next dusty. It will be we should have taken him.

Why?

Saying he should play second round 2 is hardly cautious optimism. all I am saying is give the kid a chance, he has played most of his short career as a Ruckman at under 18 level. Becoming a Ruckman / goal kicking forward is a big step up at Senior level.

We all have our opinions dd. I just don't believe Jackson is the Messiah. He is a ruckman who we all hope can make it as good forward. But I rail against talk that he should be playing round 2. He is a kid who will be learning the game at senior level the next couple of years. To expect him to haul the forward line up to finals in 2020 is folly.

It has been cut because we are only playing one game in 2020, GCS have taken over the Darwin game.

Guess what dd He knows a lot more than you and I put together. Other than a few highlights have you seen Jackson play? I sure haven't but I suggest Buckenara has and he has played the game at a very high level. At this point I will take his word versus the hopes of Demonlanders looking for the lastest messiah. Having said all that I have nothing against Jackson I hope the kid turns into a great MFC player who helps us play in the GF in 2021.

You are making assumptions that I believe will not happen. We will not get a replacement game against a team like the Bombers it will more likely be the GCS. I cannot believe that one new member will be acquired it 2020 because we have one more game at the G, winning is what drives membership and nothing else. After 2019 we will struggle to get to that level in 2020. As for winning after the Darwin game we were absolute crap for the majority of the time we played in Darwin we could not win anywhere any time. Surfice to say Mr. Leg we have opposite views of the benefits of playing in Darwin and I doubt either of us will change their view.

An example and I have seen others, Gary Buckenara said in yesterday's HUN review of this draft. " He will need to improve his marking if he is going to play forward" and I have concerns over his ability to play as a marking forward" As Dees suporters we seem to constantly look for the messiah to lead us to the promised land and while it is early days this kid seems to be seen as the latest Messiah. He has talent and I like everyone else on here hope he becomes a very good player for the MFC but let's not pretend that he is flawless and expect him to be playing round 2 in 2020.

Pie in sky stuff, won't cover the lost revenue by a long shot.

Yes time will tell.

To cover the play of 720 players, almost 2 " journalists" ( I use that term loosely ) for every player. Do they pay a fee to be accredited ? Is the only reason I could see for having that many.

Our coach is like the Weid IMO. 2020 is put up or shut up time. Make finals or on your bike for both.

Seriously Jackson at FF by round 2! From what I understand he has never played at FF. I also understand his marking is average. Second round 2021 is perhaps a chance but he would need to play blinders in the preseason to be in the team round 2 in 2020. I will be astounded if he plays in the senior side this side of July 2020 and he will only get a game if two things happen. - He plays way better than most expect in 2020. - He plays because existing players are injured / hopelessly out of form. He is a junior Ruckman who has much to learn about playing against the big boys.

Sadly I think another one of Jacks comments fits here. " Don't get where the ball aint"

Under Mr Taylor we have not made many mistakes unlike the previous crew. However his mate on the other end has got till June 2020. If we do not have a 50/50 win loss ratio by then I will be officially off his band wagon.

I agree Mr Leg if he makes it back it will be the greatest comeback since Lazarus. Perhaps a few games at Casey around late July.

So where is the lost income coming from?

Mr Leg I hate to be the one to tell you. They are 40 - 50 years younger than you! They are highly trained athletes not old!

Exactly, as usual it is the AFL dressing up something that will suit fans that is actually to suit the broadcasters. It is as always about the money.

Here's a novel idea to get fans in early. Play a under 18 game as a curtain raiser.

Have they spoken to the catering contractors? Seem to me they would sell substantial less in a ten break vs a twenty minute break. Are the AFL going to reduce the fees they play to compensate? Let's not kid ourselves this 100% about the TV companies and as usual the fans / players are running a bad second.

Monday 2nd as I understand it sns. I believe Brown is in good knick but I think Bennell is starting from scratch. Current wisdom seems to be that if he stays he would not play at any level till well after the start of the season. Struggle to see him making it, a Hail Mary shoot I think.