old dee

But then you are not a AFL level player wise.

Yep he is a good half forward. He ain't a FF or CHF.

Problem is there is only 9 games to go. Short season does not give them time to mess about.

Thanks SWYL

Guys as I am about to be locked up I will be visiting my daughter and grand daughters tomorrow evening before the cut off so I probably won't hear the pod cast live. Will I be able to hear it later on?

You total miss the point so why go on.

Got it jaded. Gee some people have little feeling for their fellow humans.

The difference is when you join the army you know the conditions, these are far from normal conditions for AFL players. Not a lot of sympathy for your fellow humans.

Tonight I saw the Richmond captain on tv saying that a number of their players had young children and some were expecting children soon. He said some of them were questioning wether they would go. Consider Viney from the MFC, his first child was born a few day ago and he has to leave for what could be 4-8 weeks. If I where him I would be seriously considering “ see ya next year guys”. With that in mind I have decided this years competition is seriously damaged. I will be attaching little significance to the results.

But he is not having the impact of previous years. And his ruck work is so predictable everyone knows what he is going to do.

Do you get the feeling the FD is wishing and hoping?

That’s possible LDC but surely when you are crying out for forwards why persist with him in defence. What about the others?

Stop trying to turn players into something that are not. Smith is a forward play him as one Harmes is a good middle fielder not a HB. TMac is a high half forward or CHB not a deep FF. Bailey is not a KPF. Play him where he plays best as a HF. Hannah is a VFL talent that’s why he was not on the Dogs list reserves for him no consistency. Play Weideman as a key forward for the next month if does not fire we will know he is a bust. He ain’t a Ruckman.

Of course it won’t but the discussion show what we lost when he left. No replacement of the 50 goals he kicked in 3/4 of a season in 2018. You know those things that win games.

I agree it Defies believe TC

Oh god please no Joe do not change!

Missed that LN. I will blame recent problems well that’s my excuse. Perhaps my sarcasm meter needs new batteries!

LN that lot would get you one of browns legs. If you want class you have to give something of value. As we Have already given North our first pick this year which will be a good one we have nothing to offer. Ask them for Brown and they would ask for Gawn in return. No chance Brown is going anywhere and why on Earth would he want to come to us?

How come Gawn does nothing around the ground he has developed into a tap ruckman and very little else. Where have the forward line marks gone? Used to drift into the backline and take defensive Marks not now. Now his ruckwork is so predictable the other teams just rove to him. Is this by design from the FD?

He is a good player but he is not KPF and never will be.

Every team could make the claim they are under done Cards. We are simply don’t have enough talent to consistently kick a wining score. Then we have a FD that is seriously second rate. Dead before we run out.

Why did we extend his contract last year before a ball had been kicked in anger?

Most of that will be too hard Dr.

33% winning rate won't get it done T J. 2 and four at the half way mark and we are dead for another season. Please tell me how this forward line is going to consistently kick winning scores?

We have consistency now not all that impressed with it.