old dee

and Sydney

very bizzare. But have no fear we will not beat the Eagles. And now the tigers and Gold coast are looking danger games.

bbo I have had none I do not understand either. Perhaps that is my problem

now be nice RR we will get bigger crowds over the next five years

me too it is expecting too much to get another Grimes but you never know

He simply does not produce often enough. The He is one of the reasons we have gone backwards this year. I do not hate him but look at his results this year. 4 -5 good games vs Gold coast, Richmond, Brisbane,Adelaide But Hawthorn, collingwood, West coast, North melbourne, St Kilda, geelong bloody terrible. It is Trapper all over again.

Hangon if you do not appreciate a little humour in this bleak period I am sorry for you. Leave us all here having some resonable discussion and a bit of fun. It is called "not the Tom scully Thread" for a reason.

DD we do not have a "great list". We have some promising kids. Hardly any senior players who are better than average. Our list is average. If it was great we would not get beaten every other week by 10+ goal margins.

best news for the last 3 months.

I may be a little thick but I do not understand what you are trying to tell me. Please explain!

mate it is just a joke. don't lose your sense of humour as we don't have a lot else left.

spot on I thought last week if you take the injuries into account it was nearly as good as it gets. simply our best 22 or our develop 22 are not good enough. results prove the point and we don't just lose we get killed.

but Ron he does not produce! have a look at his results over the years. most of this year he has had the sulks. He is exactly what you suggest good pick can play very well but infrequently. Can you depend on him in the trenches? Together with Green, Davey and Bate we have got nothing this year. It is guys like him that are the reason for our constant 10+ goal losses. The kids are doing reasonabily but these senior players have been terrible all year.

the solution is very simple "Start winning games" and the crowds will come. add an occasional win at ES would help. also make sure the game is not over at quarter time

but what do we get with Sylvia for $500 000 ? occasional good game followed by 3 poor ones. always among the missing against good sides. Simply does not produce often enough and after 7 years he will not change.

spot on Jaded

well here goes - got belted by them earlier in the year. - have lost to every one of the top 6 teams by 10+ goals - have not won at Eithad since adam played fullback for Jerusalem. - I doubt there was more than 10 000 Dees at the G on saturday. - dees traditionaly stay away fron ES - looks good snow this weekend so add all that together and we will struggle to get more than 8000 plus Eagles supporters. How is that!

give him our best offer and if that does not suit get the best deal we can and wish him good bye. he has done bugger all this year. I have said elsewhere I think he is another "Trapper" I am tired of these senior players who seriously over rated their value. Has not earned this year's salary let alone a higher rate.

it is a much darker red than anything else. I have got the old one out as I sent it back after the Geelong game. I never remember Melbourne being this colour red.

Ht I think 4 will see us out. God you would wonder that there is anything left to say. So come on guys there must be lots of other things to talk about. Does any one like this years scarf. I don't it is maroon and blue

I do too but I am waiting to see the sides before I make a final decision.

The answer is NO. but we only have 4 weeks to endure it

all of the above pm!

Me either

There is that name Trengove pops up again. Captain material!