old dee

I don't know!

Hi Hardtack I think that has more to do with how good ( used the word loosely ) the Dees are then any thing to do with the opposition Says lots about us that we as supporters keep hoping things go wrong with the other team that might improve our chances. Sad really what it says about the Dees quality

Yes RR about ten of our team should play so poorly Not out yet by the way, we are all holding our breath. Wonder when we will know

Don't you mean When?

I have better ways to waste my money mate However if you want to send me $100 I will pay you back out of the winnings

Oh no you will miss the first week of our finals campaign!!!!

Choko not sure that these two out alters much Connors has only played 2 games this year and all my Richmond friends tell me Martin as been ordinary most games this year. Remember the Tigers beat us by 59 points ( almost 10 goals ) earlier in the year before our injuries hit the current massive levels. They only lost to Adelaide by a couple. We have won 2 games they have won 6 Bookies have us at $5 tigers $1.16 they are seldom wrong I think Ricmond will beat us with one leg in the air

How is the warm weather wyl Freezing here don't rush back

Versus ?

What I am saying is that there are five others that i would drop before Bate based on last sunday's game.

What is Bail's role Akum? I am not being smart just interested in where you see him playing. Also interested in the same for Tapscott, not sure where he fits as well.

McQueen I was at the Brisbane game IMO he was far from our worst.

Davytrain1 this is all in the Changes for Richmond thread

demonland's undying love!!!!

You have my Vote olisik, I would go further and say he would be less influential

Is this finally a piece of luck going our way?

Easy, Bail, Maloney or Tapscott

I thought he was crap The only player with less possessions was Spenser but the alternative is Bennell so not really an alternative I am never sure what Bail's role is in the team. Does anyone?

Spot on satricon, Magner and Bate did their jobs on Sunday from what I could see. If Rivers and Garland had played as well we would have been a lot closer that 10 goals at the end. And you forgot to add that it is only 6 weeks ago that Leigh Williams was in a coma in Hospital. Give the kid a break

Taking McLean for a first round pick probably says it all.

And has not even had time toi screw them yet. If BM continues on BP may have the shortest career yet at Carlton.

I assume you mean Carlton RR? We don't exactly look flash either!

DC have you seen it? What a joke. GWS were not allowed to wear their Grey and orange strip against us but Essendon would be allowed to wear the one! Oh please

It has been asked elsewhere but I will ask again "what does Bail bring to the team"? I have yet to see him play a game that would justify his inclusion the following week. But the FD seem impressed e.g. they give him a game on Sunday after being injured for 4 weeks. However the the alternative was probably Bennell Oh well yes play him next saturday

He may be the "mystery" injury for this round?