old dee

Thats your view RR The sheer fact we had poor senior and middle range players would suggest to me that recruiting all kids was just going to delay any improvement. And do you always have to start every comment with the likes of "this is plain Rubbish"? There is no need to be so aggressive. It does nothing for your argument IMO except perhaps to get most people's back up.

Just shows FD that early draft picks are not everything. Also shows the folly of our youth only drafting plan between 2007 and 2010 You have to have a mix or you end up lower than where you started from.

Neeld suggested it last week Jnr.

Thank you rpfc I keep thinking the same thing Makes me wonder how many people actually think before they post

Mostly guess work old55 Most on here are like me Really have no idea I guess based on what I see

I always take the injury list with a grain of salt The only ones I believe is when they Say "Season or Indefinte" The rest is just to keep the troops happy.

I was meaning Lack of talent franky_31 I am not up to that sort of crap I agree I have changed it did not look good

Sorry Munga I do not agree. He is entitled to his opinion, this is a forum for discussion. On top of that The MFC needs every Supporter / member it can muster. Take a deep breath and relax.

Gee I hope lack of talent does not rub off on him!

Not without good reason BM

Liam Jurrah off the injury list for the first time in what, three months? By my reckoning he was on the list until May 10. Then played 1+ quarters vs Swans May 19 Then back on May 25 and has been on it for 11 weeks. Not exactly a great productive year. Does that mean he fronts for Casey this weekend? I really hope so

Christmas day lunch would be interesting DC

Perhaps they saw the writing on the wall and got the hell out of there DC. Otherwise we can only assume that an AFL football went out on his own. Must happen all the time No Oh well there goes a good theory.

80 might be an ambit claim but seriously I do not believe he is worth more than a third round pick. I just don't see anything more than an average player What about Cook you left him off. Where does he now fit Caddy was pick 7 and Cook 12

" determination and guts sometimes is worth more than potential and reputation" I would say "the vast majority of the time"

Morton was 4, Gysberts 12 and Cook 12 Would you give those picks for them now? Of course not. It is what you do after the Draft that matters and Caddy has been anything but wonderful. I will stick with 80

He was found unconscious in the street. Work it out!!

Me too JT

Please one X Port never been is enough for the MFC in our lifetimes.

JT I don't know what all the fuss is about with Caddy. He is average not worth 13 in a pink fit. The last thing the MFC needs is another average recruit that we take 3 years to work out he is average. I am not trying to be a smart Ar-- but what do you see in him? From my view he has don't very little since being drafted.

I agree 100% old 55 especially re fitness above. At one stage half way through the third quarter yesterday Blease could hardly make it to the bench he was gasping for breath. Now this is not the last quarter there was still 40% of the game to go. Not so the likes of Bail or Howe who seem to be going as hard at the end as at the start. No matter how good your skills you need to be fit in today's game there is nowhere to hide.

Pick 80 for Caddy and we keep Sylvia

Yes remember 186

We are due one yde after some we have recruited

I reckon he is right now Hatchman and we have not had to wait 3-4 years for him to mature, put on weight, grow into his frame or all the other bull--it. Was a goer from his first game