jayceebee31

Yes I did, but what relevance is that to my objection re this trade regarding Thomas for Scully.I cannot win the premiership, but I will go down the path of being, honest and trying to do everything in the spirit of the league.This is not.My main aspect in this keague is trying to beat you in the tipping comp.I thought you would gain on me last round. This round will be exciting.No, seriously, Thomas for Scully is not on.

I am not saying anyone is tanking, I am saying that the trade of gaining Scully, when a coach has 6 current rookie qualified players to pick from and to give upa player of the likes of Thomas for Scully,SMELLS. We need to gain a committee as I have stated earlier to bring in rules for us to operate in. This matter so close to final time is a joke.Fair is fair and this is not fair by a very long way.And as stated I am disappointed in these two coaches due the spirit of the game.Are they brothers, friends ??

That is totally irrelevant JA isn't trying. Given up I think. That is why RR should be congratulated in not giving up.JA could have gained players if fair dinkum. As you know, I am a stirrer.I am not stirring about this. This is a con big time and totally unacceptable. We are all competitive and try to keep to the true spirit of the game.This is not on IMO. I will give you a trade seeing you can't win and see if you will accept it.

With regards to questioning me with regards to my knowledge of ratings etc..have a look at the current ladder and where we both ended up last year. I think I know my footballers quite well and Scully is totally inferior toThomas and going into the finals, Thomas is just a shoein for Robbo to win.Get real RR. I will offer you a similar trade and see what you think.I just wish we never,ever agreed to this keepe [censored], till season was over andvthiscwould not allowed thisccrap trading to occur.

What a load of crap- Stats are [censored] in some ways. Thomas- is one of the best footballers in the league, I would rate him as being I. The top 50 - Scully may get in the best 275 to 300 range.Also, IMO- Scully is a dud-although I feel this keeper system is [censored], there are at least 60 players in front of Scully that I would pick.I am vetoing this trade. It is crap and u acceptable IMO. I feel that there is and have been some funny trades between family or friends in this league lately and is just unbelievable. Just hoe D/L 7 keeps Scully as a keeper or I will give him heaps next year, if I stay I the league.Not on IMO.D/L 7 currently has 6 potential rookie keepers on his list, Scully would be 7.Come on , be real. If this trade goes through and Scully is not kept Asca keeper then this league is rigged.That is my opinion.It stinks if this trade goes ahead.

Ridiculous offer re Thomas for Scully.If this gets through, the comp is a joke.Cant believe D/ L 7. that you would try to stuff the comp up by doing this. Get real.I have supported you truly, but this is plain stupid.As defending champ I thought you would be fair dinkum.I am very disappointed in you. I have grat respect for you, but this trade is just sofar over the top.

No certainty that Crameri will return this week, actually, my mail is hevis doubtful.Could even be 3 weeks away.Hopefully for me- this is so.

Still waiting.

You have done a great job stickin in there this year.Early favorite for next year. And still could be a major threat for minor premiership if I am not in it.

Let's be totally honest, he has been as big a disappointment as Trenners has been this season.As a keeper you would have to be kidding.

You sound desperate- don't worry as I will not make the top 8. Bartel is not worth trading as a keeper next year. Robbo will belt me as will MM and Dappa will be hard to roll last round. I need to win one to make the 8, therefore give me Bartel for say, Wunderlink. Help a poor bugger like me out.

I think there are some doubts that your post is correct.I am one that feel even before his injury,he was under a cloud.

Agree- Looked good with speed and great kicking ability before injury.great to see return,best of luck on return.

Hi Smithy,I'm an old Ballarat guy, any help needed? Take care-JCB

Yep- thanks team for getting us back up on stream.Very much appreciated.

Very pleased to say had all the picks stated in my list under the National championship thread.

Start screaming now my friend because we will go for at least one player whom will need developing.Most of the top 20 will.

Your post made me crack up, but your points I couldn't disagree.

[quote name =H_T' timestamp='1341785881' post='591546] You'd be right. 5 to go before the weekend. Probably uphill battle to get in. Would need all 4.

Mark played in the 2009 NAB under 18 Championships with names like Scully, Trengrove, Martin in front of him at draft time. At least 14 of his peers were drafted from WA that year. My records show he was worth a round 3/4 draft pick, who was hard at it and quite skillful. DOB- 25/05/91, 180cm, 82 kg. I thought he was a little flabby at the time. A major pre season would make this bloke - I wrote at the time.

Crap as Magner only joined us this year.

Thanks for your insight / report Fan.

High- has tremendous talent.Another Howe.

I thought 4 to go.One of us can 't count. However, you are catching me quickly with the tipping.Only tipped 7 this week, I think.

Hi, I haven't seen him play for weeks as I have been working with the Under18's.Has he got the motor to play CHF?.And if not would you play him at Full Forward.? Please advise.