Nasher

Why?

Here's the same list, in order of moderator activity. (I found this interesting): Finks (Daylight) Nasher Whispering_Jack Jaded Wise Monkey Rhino Richards Demonland Fan mickrocks1 Hards Interestingly, Run and Carry Resurrection has actually edited more of his own posts than Hards has done all moderator activity. Lift your game Hards! :D

Awww Here's the full list, I've scratched off those who don't qualify as "active". Demonland Fan Finks Hards Jaded mickrocks1 Nasher Rhino Richards santiago tm Whispering_Jack Wise Monkey ??

3 - Nasher! Topic closed. I win.

I think it'd be a bit wanky if one of the "inactive" mods won personally!

Anyway, my top 3 posters: 3- Maurie Lithen. Not the most regular but you very rarely see a post that isn't quality. 2- Rhino Richards. Is often the lone voice of reason amongst an awful lot of noise. 1- Fan. Has been easily my favourite poster for as long as I can remember on both 'land and 'ology. I wish he posted more, if he did he'd be a shoo-in for my 3.

Damnit, when's the best mod vote?!

Where's the part where someone hands off to Damien Gaspar who spins out of trouble on the wing when he's clear by 15 metres?

You are offering them Ward or Godfrey. Jamar has about the equivalent worth. A ruckman who can't do anything other than "tap" is completely useless. Big ruckman aren't hard to find, they're damn near everywhere. Hell, they've already got one in the 211cm Street. Big ruckman who can play are hard to come by, and they are worth something in trades. Unfortunately, Jamar isn't one of those. McDougall's not a ruckman. He's a (useless) KPP player.

You may as well just say Robbo + 21 for 5. Jamar adds nothing to the deal at all. It probably makes it less attractive if anything.

For some, maybe. Personally I'll find it fairly easy to swallow given his stubborness and the way he plays.

Well put. The club is doing its due dilligence and is attempting to move hell and earth to get Judd here, and we should expect no less. If we don't pull it off it won't be for lack of trying and that's how it should be. It will be disappointing but there's plenty of other blue sky appearing this off season that should keep must of us happy.

Lame conspiracy theory that needlessly undermines the integrity of a man who I believe is not deserving. In short, an utter load of crap.

Hardly just a member! Although Jack has the "grandfather" role sewn up you're definitely a chance for "favourite aunty"!! :D

Let's not contribute to this thread anymore for now, considering it has absolutely no content whatsoever. When the news breaks, where's jacka can have his thread opened again so he can take all the glory of getting the scoop Edit: Whoops, I pinned it instead of closing it. Fixed!

Fair enough. I assumed we were trying to be determine who we could spend this year's pick 4 on, realistically.

Jeez you mods here are quick. Every time I go to update the list thanks to a new departure, someone's already done it!

Agree with all of that. The only part of me now that doubts we can and will pull this off now is the automatic 1% of doubt that is reserved for absolutely anything to do with this club. I think any Melbourne supporter knows that slight tug of doubt I'm talking about!

Yes.

Are they on the market?

I would not trade Pick 4 if it wasn't for Judd.

#30 is available if he wants it :D

12th of October is my birthday. I don't think a nice birthday present from the club is too much to ask for is it? :D

It isn't going to cost the club anything. He left on his own accord. If he had been sacked it would involve a payout. All it is going to cost the club is an assistant coach that will need to be replaced.

Best result for everyone involved IMO. I wish Mark all the best.