whatwhat say what

do you honestly believe that? our supporter base is small, and ageing, and devoid of sustained success i think we're forever destined to be mid-lower tier size

if lists are reduced to 35 i am not certain that hore would survive the chop would be borderline

unfortunately it's not something that makes me happy i completely understand why we signed him up but north were prepared to offer him big coin so we could've got a decent trade for him at the time all his 'value' has diminished as @DeeSpencer said i really thought after his first year that he was going to be a ripper for us off half-back more than thru the midfield, but his disposal has somehow got worse since then and his lack of accountability defensively is atrocious

mckernan from only 16 games tho that hunt was our top ranked marking player i50 followed by fritsch - who barely played there til the last five or so games of the year - says volumes

i guess - i just see trac as more a ground level player and stringer more damaging in the air

hore is injured for half the season and not much chop so that's not going to happen not to mention t mac's kicking out of the backline...have people forgotten how horrible a ball-user he is coming out of the backline?!??

wow, i would have sworn he was more of a key forward target! interesting numbers - do you have splits for i50 marks vs around the ground?

callum mills was #3 pick ahead of oliver - he's possibly even more of a good-average afl level player than gus mills makes salem look like a superstar

i feel like i see stringer take a lot more marks than trac mckernan would be our #1 key forward target if he was in our side

north were prepared to offer him a hefty contract at the end of 2018 but instead we signed him up to a fairly decent one instead he's one more poor year away from being worth a lot less than a third rounder

mckernahan (198cm) and stringer (192cm, but arguably 'plays' taller) are pretty decent targets

nope, i said so at the time he's always been a frontrunner

unfortunately he's incredibly one-dimensional, doesn't work hard defensively, and has chronic poor disposal he's no better / worse than dom tyson shoulda traded him at the end of 2018

carlton review just went up, i would imagine ours would go up at some point in the next 24-72 hours...

i think this can be expanded to our midfielders struggle to defend the amount of freewheeling going on inside the square and around the contest is very concerning going forward

melksham and t mac on thin ice at this stage i think - on the g - you need some tall targets to kick to, so i'd give lj a reprieve this week IN: weed, o mac OUT: jones, smith sad to see nate go out like he is - looks a shadow of his former self anb and hunt did their roles; pickett will need to wait, silly boy

better than may for mine

6: petracca 5: oliver 4: gawn 3: langdon 2: rivers 1: hunt

this

Head to head with Clarry who is dominant in close

Let them right back into it with an appalling last five to seven minutes

Good start

Neither have Carlton, AFL.com, or any other news sites

Nah, I shoulda used quotation marks to make it more obvious

i dunno... cats got destroyed by gw$ in rd 1, poos&wees mangled the bears, richmond haven't lost a match for 12 calendar months, and the filth have lost to one 2019 grand finalist by 4 points and drew with the other in 2 out of their 3 most recent games i don't think you can read anything into this season yet...give it til about round 10 - if we get that far - and then we'll know where every team sits